Archive for December, 2008

food problem from PLUS to local universities

December 30th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Roti canai and tosai lover Michael Yeap makes it a point to stop at the Ulu Bernam rest area near Tanjung Malim for breakfast when driving to Kuala Lumpur.

However, his 15-year love affair may have to end after Dec 31 because the stall that serves the Indian delight has failed to obtain a permit to continue operating at the rest area.

The 60-year-old dance instructor said he would time his travel so that he would either catch breakfast or lunch at the Indian stall at the rest area.

“I have been doing that for the past 15 years. I love the food there,” he said yesterday.

“But during my last visit, the operator told me his permit for the stall has been terminated,” Yeap said, adding that the stall was the only one run by an Indian there.

He said he or other travellers would be unable to find non-Malay food along the expressway if the permit were to be terminated.

The Star

I took PLUS quite often in the last two months. Most of the time before this, ‘ll enjoy a cup of tea or coffee together with some roti bakar (toast bread). But recently, not many stall are offering roti bakar (There’s one chinese stall in Air Hitam stop towards JB). Worse still, there’s lack of real Chinese and Indian food. The chicken rice or fried kuey teow doesn’t taste authentic. No fresh thosai or roti canai with thick, tasty sambar (dhal curry).  Most of the stalls are selling Malay food or localized version of other cultures’ food. There can be many copycat chicken curry, but nothing beats the authentic southern Indian chicken curry (IMHO).

Forget about getting vegetarian food. You can only depend on bread and fruits.

This is only natural as population imbalance increases. Traffics towards northern states will be predominantly of certain race, thus only those selling particular type of food will make profit. Those catering for minority will eventually suffer a loss as they can’t get the business volume needed.

But, those rest areas in the middle and southern region should have more multi racial meals.

Recently, the lack of non-Malay food served along the expressway was highlighted by Ipoh Barat MP M. Kulasegaran at a press conference. Kulasegaran said there were only a handful of stalls that served non-Malay food in the Tapah and Ulu Bernam rest areas.

“Many Malaysians use the expressway and it is a problem to those looking for vegetarian or non-Malay food,” he said.

Kulasegaran said he was not against the number of Malay food stalls at the rest areas but he was hoping that PLUS would allot more stalls for non-Malays.

He said he had written to PLUS, the Malaysian Highway Authority and the Works Minister to look into the matter.

According to PLUS representative, they are planning to introduce fusion food, and also said that meals were introduced based on demand. Also, the stalls were terminated due to various reasons as given below:

When contacted, PLUS senior public relations manager Khalilah Mohd Talha said PLUS would introduce a fusion of Malay, Chinese and Indian foods that appealed to the masses next year.

We are re-looking at our rest and recreational areas along the North-South Expressway. We are introducing more varieties in terms of menu to appeal to travellers from different ethnic and cultural background.

She said PLUS had never practised discrimination against the multi-racial stall operators, but over the years, operators requested to serve titbits and more Malay-based food based on demand for those kind of food.

We do invite multi-racial stall operators. The response is another story.

She said licences were only terminated if the operators did not comply with the Health Ministry’s guidelines on food preparation, cleanliness of premises or hygiene discipline, did not pay rental or had customer complaints.

“But this is after several warnings are issued.

Well, for those who are having certain preferences or limitations, better plan your journey well so that not deprived of your meals.

Now, the same problem is also manifesting in local universities. Recently, UM closed down its only Chinese-run food stall due to violation of its rules – serving non-halal food and employing non-Muslim cook. This was protested by the students and MCA stepped in. Through the BN Youth Education Bureau, the university management were persuaded to reinstate the stall at College 12. The college has about 600 Chinese student of 1200 students.

However, the stall operator has to abide by the rules –  Chinese cooks are allowed but only halal food and must be clean.

According to MCA Youth education bureau chairman, Chong Sin Woon, who had brought the issue of the stall closure to the BN Youth, the Chinese stall was ordered to close in May.

“However, on the insistence of students, the stall was allowed to operate until this month.

“UM then awarded the tender for the stall to another operator.

“The reason given by UM was that the stall served non-Muslim food and employed a non-Muslim cook.”

Chong said the demand by MCA Youth, acting on behalf of Chinese students, was that the food be prepared by a Chinese chef, especially as there were a total of 13 other stalls at College 12, run by Muslim operators.

Chong said only Universiti Sains Malaysia had proper Chinese food stalls while Chinese stalls at Universiti Putra Malaysia and Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia were only allowed to serve vegetarian food.

This begets the question – who should be tolerant? Is it wrong to eat the food the students are used to? What is the unversity imparting to its students? One-sided rule? All it takes is some extra measures to ensure the areas where non-halal food are separated. Disposable utensils can be used in some cases.  And we seldom can get nice Indian food if cooked by non-Indian, so I guess its the same for the Chinese. The food will be watered down or tastes different. So why get fixated with the rule that must be Muslim cook only? If there are muslims who like Chinese food, then set up another stall la! This kind of small things can be settled easily.

This problem rarely happens in Indian restaurants/stall as they don’t cook pork-based dish. All the chicken and mutton are halal. So its easy to accept Indian cook compared to Chinese cook. Yet, how many universities have Indian stalls with Indian cooks?

While I was in university, there was a short period when a chinese stall operated. It disappeared after a year or so. Most of the time, the Indian students get food from outside. The food served in the cafeteria had a kind of smell which was terrible.  Many of my friends, especially in their first year were forced to eat in-campus since no other option. But after entering second year, all those who had own transport seldom visit in-campus cafeterias.

As time goes by, due to relatively small population of Indian and Chinese students in local universities, the non-muslims stall will die a natural death. Unless of course we consider students from China (some of which who are Muslims). So, non-Muslim students face stiff challenge in adapting to university environment especially those who only avenue to a degree is local university.

Samy has another tantrum

December 30th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Not too long ago, Samy was unhappy with the audience at the MIC general assembly eve dinner. More recently, he lashed out at party members during a dinner at the Klang Executive Club attended by 140 Klang and Kapar MIC members. Samy was unhappy with the members who were not paying attention to his speech (perhaps it was the same old stories or the food was delicious)

They were said to have been too busy eating and walking around, and after giving them a piece of his mind, Samy Vellu told those present to “eat first” and returned to his seat.

He returned to the rostrum 30 minutes later and said he would cut short his speech.

It did not end there. Samy also questioned a photographer from Makkal Osai who was busy taking his pictures. The photographer’s camera were later taken away and the pictures were erased. A female staff of Makkal Osai was also threatened by MIC member not to report the incident.

Malaysiakini provides more details:

The photographer  told Malaysiakini that the newspaper had been invited to cover Samy Vellu’s meeting last night with some 140 leaders of the Kapar and Klang MIC branches, at the Klang Executive Club.

On arrival about 7.30pm, the two began covering the event. About 9.30pm, during dinner, Samy Vellu began delivering a speech, only to notice that the crowd not listening to him.

“Samy Vellu went back to his seat, to allow them to continue eating. He later stood up to deliver his speech but the people still not attentive. So he ended his speech about 9.58pm.

“As he was leaving the venue, he was angry. He was scolding the branch leaders for not showing him respect. He was angry because people had left their seats and were walking about, instead of listening to him.”

The photographer said he was recording all this when Samy Vellu spotted him and asked which newspaper he represents.

“I told him ‘Makkal Osai’ and he immediately seized my camera and gave it to a MIC senator. Samy Vellu told him to delete the pictures. (When it was returned to me) about half of my pictures were gone,” he alleged.

“Samy Vellu continued to verbally abuse me and my newspaper, saying we should not be there and that we had not been invited. I told him we had been invited by a branch leader.”

The photographer said he and the journalist continued to suffer verbal abuse and threats from Samy Vellu as they were leaving the premises.

“His bodyguard approached me and warned against reporting the matter in the newspapers. He said that if we do so, ‘you are finished’.”

The duo then decided to lodge separate police reports, as they feared for their safety.

“We were only doing our job and yet Samy Vellu resorted to such irresponsible behaviour,” said the photographer.

He also said the incident happened in front of those invited, leaving the journalist and himself feeling “very humiliated”.

Wonder what’s happening with MIC members. Tired of listening to same old stories?  Perhaps they are all new members who are part of the rebranding exercise?

Developer takes Tamil school land

December 30th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Another case of Malaysia Boleh! A round of applause please to the actors in this land-grabbing drama!

SJKT Taman Melawati’s land area has been magically reduced from 1.45ha to 1.36ha. The 0.9ha has now been made into a site for a low-cost flats project. The area in question was the school field.

The issue was highlighted by Gombak MIC who organised a protest. 200 over people took part in the protest.

So, how is it done? Here’s some tips for aspiring developers:

According to the Gombak MIC division chairman G. Jayakumaran, the developer used its own team of surveyors and resubmitted the school land plans to the land office. The plot of land was then transfered to a third party on 4th September 2006. He claimed that this act also misled education ministry and Public Works Department.

The problem started with PWD not properly fencing the school area, thus delaying its land application. Biasalah, when there’s a chance, surely the money-minded businesses would take advantage.

According to Jayaraman, a memorandum would be submitted to state and federal government next week. 480 people have signed the memorandum, and the campaign will go to various temples to garner more signature.

In NST, the developer has been named as Negara Properties:

Gombak MIC Division chief G. Jayakumaran said the school field was 1.44 hectares (3.6 acres) but the developer of Taman Melawati, Negara Properties Sdn Bhd had claimed that the area was only 1.35 hectares (3.38 acres).

The developer wants to use the remaining 9,000 square feet of the field to built low cost flats, Jayakumaran told reporters here today.

He added that he could not understand why Negara Properties had informed the Gombak district education office that the school field was only 1.35 hectares instead of 1.44 hectares.

They (developer) may have misled the education office into believing that the land was actually 1.35 hectares, for the purpose of using it for their own benefit, said Jayakumaran.

He said transactions involving the transfer of the land title from Negara Properties to Melawati Development Sdn Bhd and to an individual, done simultaneously in Sept 2006, also raises suspicion.

So, what is the state government going to do? Land matters come under Selangor state, but 2006, it was Khir Toyo’s government. Only option is to get a stay order, investigate the case and make the right decision. Not sure if SJKT Taman Melawati is fully-aided school, which means the land should be federal or state owned land.

Klang Sentral Terminal a hot potato

December 30th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


The new RM300 million bus terminal (air-conditioned and has a food court, surau and closed- circuit TV system, among others) started operating 3 days ago, and there’s been both optimism and opposition to the new terminal.

Commuters face the biggest problem – longer travel time and higher cost:

However, some commuters were not happy with the move. They said the new terminal was far from the town centre and government offices.

Lim Boon Kig, 58, who was heading to Banting said it took him 90 minutes to reach Klang Sentral from his home in Sekinchan, instead of just 45 minutes previously.

“At the old terminal, there would be several buses to Banting. I could just hop on one without waiting.

“Here, not only is it further, I have been waiting for 30 minutes and there is not a single bus to Banting yet.”

Another case:

Housewife Zainiah Mohamed, 35, was at a loss with her three young children in tow, wondering how to get back to her home in Banting after a shopping trip here.

Nallamah, 55, from Bandar Sunway in Subang, went to the nearly-abandoned station yesterday afternoon to catch the bus home.

“I’m now told I will have to go back to the Jalan Meru bus station in Kapar to catch a bus to Sunway.”

It seems MPK has distributed pamphlets on the changes of bus service. According to one officer, there are five pick-up points in Klang town including the old bus station. However, the I guess people still have to travel to Meru and take a bus from there in certain cases.

Some traders seemed to be optimistic:

More than 90 per cent of the shoplots and kiosks at the new terminal have been snapped up despite the “high” rental.

Trader Shamsul Kamar Abd Razak said even though the rent was high and the terminal had been operating for only two days, business was encouraging.

“The rent is at RM3,000 for a convenience store and about RM2,000 for a kiosk but I’m in this for the long term and I’m confident business will pick up.”

But those in old bus terminal are an unhappy lot:

With the buses and taxis gone, the 250 traders at the Klang Utara Bus Terminal claim they are now staring at bankruptcy.

Trader C. Krishnan said: “We will lose 80 per cent of our income and most of us will go bankrupt within three years.”

According to NST:

The lunch crowd at the Komathy Vilas was halved overnight, from about 2,000, when the Klang bus station was relocated from the town centre on Saturday.

Restaurant owner V. Jeyaraman, 40, said commuters used to make a beeline for his restaurant on arrival at the Jalan Baru bus station, located adjacent to his shop.

Stall owners at the food court at MPK Plaza in the vicinity claim they had only themselves for company over the last two days.

Zaniyah Yeob, 53, who sells nasi campur at the food court, said stall owners were dealt a double blow with the relocation of the bus station and the economic downturn.

Cendol seller Ah Seng, 52, said he had been operating his stall for about 20 years and hoped the authorities would reconsider the move.

The unhappy traders protested near the old bus station yesterday with placards and banners slamming State Assembly Speaker Teng Chang Khim and the Klang Municipal Council for being “pro-developer” The traders chanted slogans and protested for about an hour. The group together with bus operators and commuters had held a meeting and formed an action committee to protest the relocation.
Transport company lament the higher charges, but can’t do much except complain:

The local council decided to shift operations as the new terminal, located 10km from the town centre, would ease traffic congestion. The New Straits Times found operations at Klang Sentral were running smoothly.

One of the bus companies operating at the old terminal, Wawasan Sutera Travel & Tour, urged the council to open a lane for buses to pick up and drop off passengers.

Its operations manager, M. Logesvaran, said bus firms should be given more time to move to Klang Sentral to avoid huge losses.

“The rental at the new terminal is 10 times more than what we are paying now. My company will also lose a lot of time travelling as it will take us almost 40 minutes to reach Klang Sentral.”

A bus operator said companies were being charged RM900 rental per month for a counter at the new terminal, compared with just RM150 at the old terminal. Buses are charged RM10 per entry, from RM2 previously.

As calls for transparency pick up, the local council (MPK) and the state government is under pressure to manage this potential political bomb. As it is, PKR and DAP are seen to have internal squabbles and rift, with MP for Kapar, Manikavasagam as the central figure.

Even though the bus station was mooted under previous administration, the new state government should do something about it. The objective of mass transportation system is to move people efficiently.No point having a system that causes more misery for the rakyat especially in terms of cost. The bus operator may use higher operating cost to increase ticket prices.

In the long run, perhaps the banning of private vehicles into Klang town will be a better option. Heavy vehicles should be limited to certain hours, and both the old and new terminal should co-exist. There should have been an effort to integrate bus service with the Komuter service. The local council should have tried to get some land near Komuter station like Klang or Tepi Sungai.

HINDRAF wins SUARAM award

December 30th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


An old news, but still worth mentioning:

The now-banned Hindu Right Action Force (Hindraf) and Penan activists of the Ulu Baram area in Sarawak have won Suaram’s 2008 Human Rights Award.

The annual award, presented since 1999, was given to the two rights groups for their unique achievements in highlighting concerns of their communities.

Civil society movement Hindraf was recognised for being able to “captivate, mobilise and empower vast numbers of Malaysians of Indian origin” within a short period of its existence, said Xavier.

She said the judges were “impressed by the way Hindraf contextualised the current situation by bringing in colonial history and demonstrating how, even after 50 years of Merdeka (independence), the Indian community has continued to be marginalised and disenfranchised”.

“The success of Hindraf can perhaps be seen in the fear it has caused the government, to the extent that it detained five of its leaders under the ISA and outlawed the organisation.”

Accepting the award, the movement’s national coordinator RS Thanenthiran (left) said it was an honour for all marginalised communities and noted that the struggle has been recognised for the first time.

“This shows that the banning of Hindraf does not make any sense because the spirit and the struggle are continuing. We the civil society… who are all fighting for human rights have shown that a lot of changes have to be made to the system,” he said.

“You (the government) cannot control the people with ISA… they are now bolder and braver to tell the government that it is violating human rights.”

The award comprises a trophy, a certificate and prize money of RM1,000.