
The declaration is with immediate effect. According to Home Minister (from Malaysiakini):
…the decision was made after the ministry was satisfied with facts and evidence that showed “Hindraf had and was being used for unlawful purposes and posed a threat to public order and morality”.
“Based on powers vested under Section 5(1) of the Societies Act, Hindraf from today is declared an illegal organisation,” he said in a statement today.
He said the order was being made as a result of monitoring and investigation on the organisation’s activities by the Registrar of Societies (ROS) and Home Ministry, since Hindraf’s inception.
Syed Hamid said if left unchecked, Hindraf would continue to pose a threat to public order, the security and sovereignty of the country as well as the prevailing racial harmony.
“The decision to declare Hindraf an illegal organisation is not based on one or two of its activities that are in contravention of the law but covers all the actions it has taken since being formed,” he said.
Syed Hamid said Hindraf had all the criteria of an organised movement because it had filed for registration with the ROS on Oct 16 last year. He added that the application was yet to be approved.
He also said that the organisation had actively exploited the Indian community to organise illegal assemblies and street demonstrations without permits.
Such acts, he said, had resulted in some members of the Indian community to rise up against the government.
Syed Hamid also said that Hindraf’s actions also caused hatred among the Malays and Indians in the country.
“Hindraf has also tried to secure support from foreign countries for the purpose of pressuring the government to bow to its demands,” he added.
Syed Hamid advised the public to distance themselves from Hindraf and not participate in any way in any of its activities.
Among the first to respond was Lim Kit Siang:
In an immediate reaction DAP stalwart Lim Kit Siang said the banning of Hindraf was a testimony to the failure of the prime minister to take nation-building to a new and more mature level.
“It is a retrogressive, vindictive and petty step which will hamper the nation-building healing process vital for Malaysians to feel one and united people again,” he said in a statement.
He said that the “ham-fisted measures to ban Hindraf will only aggravate the disaffection among the Indian community”.
He gave an assurance that opposition MPs will raise in Parliament the banning of Hindraf.
“I invite MPs from all the BN component parties to join with Pakatan Rakyat MPs to take a common stand – to demand that the home minister revoke the ban on Hindraf…,” he said.
So, Malaysians are advised to ” to distance themselves from Hindraf and not participate in any way in any of its activities”. What does that mean? Can I mention the “H” word? Can links be published in blogs or websites? Can SMSes be sent wishing Happy Deepavali, Valghe Hindraf?
Will this be the opportunity to harass every Indian-looking person in the country? Simply stop you and check your handphones? Do roadblocks and target cars driven by Indians? Disperse groups of 5 or more Indians loitering around? Sounds extreme, but this is Bolehland after all. Anything is possible.
Earlier, I wrote about the situation if Hindraf is banned. So, would Hindraf be renamed to Makkal Sakthi? Will the leaders challenge the decision in court? Or will they join a political party to pursue Hindraf’s objectives? No more interviews with Hindraf leaders, so their voice won’t be heard. It will be hard to gather support via the print media, but there’s always SMS and Internet.
If there is a massive show of dissent against this decision, for example, everyone wears orange on next open house or on certain day of the month, would it mean Hindraf still have support?
Whatever it is, HINDRAF has made its mark in Malaysian history. It will always live as a legend in the minds and hearts of the Indian community especially. Only the name is banned, but the spirit and support for the movement will remain strong, if not grow stronger.
Haris ibrahim has the links to Societies Act in the Pepole’s Parliament.
http://harismibrahim.wordpress.com/
How can you stop the rain from falling down? How can you stop the sun from shining?
thanks! i’ll look it up
looks like HINDRAF did not expect the ban. According to the star today, Waytha asked all the leaders not to issue any statement. Maybe worried they will be arrested.
First and foremost, please get the stupid Hindraf leaders to amend their 18 points demands because it really looks stupid to the core of it…
that document itself is sufficient to have them arrested as it is highly seditious and irresponsible.
For those supporting Hindraf blindly, just note that you are creating a dangerous precedent where you are giving an organisation power without discipline. I myself would have supported Hindraf if it really defended the poor… and used facts and not lies to uphold the causes for Indian rights.
Firstly, Hindraf must apologise for their explicit lies stated in the memorandum to the queen and their 18 points demand. I cannot bring myself to support a leader whose words, deeds and action is no more different than the present leaders running the country.
This is where the opposition fails. They are afraid to correct Hindraf. The opposition makes noises when the govt makes a mistake but when it comes to Hindraf, they keep mum… i wonder why?? Are they being bullied ???
If we still support a organisation which is striving to sow divisions, much of what we achieved today will be lost in ruins.
I think many people are missing the mark and reading it wrongly on banning HINDRAF.
HINDRAF has broken the law and violated the Society’s Act numerous times. In fact that they have made a mockery of the SA’s by being so voval and daring even though they are an unregistered organisation. It is really a wonder why the was no action taken agianst them for so long in the first place. Had this been under TDM’s time, firm actions would have been applied at the first instance of violation. However, the govt of AAB had been rather lenient and tolerant but their antics at the Open House was the straw that broke the camel’s back.
Second issue is the so-called suppression of the Indians’ voice. This is a joke as though only HINDRAF had been or could represents the community. Remember we have HINDRAF MPs and ADUNs in the Parliament and te state assemblies. So there’s nothing to stop these people from continuing their struggle.
Third issue is the impact of the ban. I can tell you that this is the end of HINDRAF. In the last few months, Thendran and Waytha had been doing a lot of activities not to achieve or fight for some causes but to keep the name of HINDRAF alive. There were really concerned that the support for HINDARF had declined drastically, so they had to be visible to be relevant.
As I had stated before many times, before this they were dying slowly and now with the ban they are gone for sure. All these talk about underground work is nonsense, these guys have no idea that for an org like HINDRAF to be successful it has to be visible and noisy. If HINDRAF goes underground, it would difficulties operating and raise funds as the modus operandi is very different. I don’t think any HINDRAF leader has experience in such skills. Furthermore HINDRAF is an open book for SB and any one who tries to start an underground operations will be arrested under ISA.
Furthermore all the PR MPs and Aduns will have perfect excuse not to help or get involved in HINDRAF activities due to its illegal status.
Forget getting help from Tigers or RSS (India), these groups too are having hard times on their own now.
RIP HINDRAF, MAKKAL SAKTHI
it’s getting excited . I’m getting excited . Actually if you happen to talk about hindraf to lay indians they’ll
tell you that “namakkaka thane poradi ulle irrukkanga…..” . It drew sentimental feelings .
But you wont see these lay or family people on streets joing hindraf activities . But because
of such feeling and peer pressure from relatives they joined the nation to kick off the March8
tsunamy . Remember the ‘choas theory’ ? The relation of butterfly wings and tornado !
umno thought by locking up H5 the dust will settle . They knew it didnt and so they made move
on banning it all together . Poobalan might be right on the subsequent actions since banning.
But wait … is it all about the name ? as i said before how to ban a spirit ?
Just take a look at number of nicknames in this blog alone . It’s not the name but the spirit
and message .
So why it causing excitement ? Well let’s rewind…… in past elections many
thinking indians have been telling their frenz/relations..etc that the ruling folks are not
interested in taking care of our makkal . So they were asked to vote oppo in elections .
But makkal were reluctant to change . They were scared of change and subsequent
impact to community . In those years lay makkal only know 3 leaders , not more .
They are ‘Kalaiger’ , DrM and SV . This for the first time in history makkal changed in GE12 . Of course
thanks to the great H5 ! Now they know a whole bunch of new leaders from opposition/NGO.
The awareness that we expected from makkal has surfaced out .
So the ‘impossible’ a decade ago is now ‘possible’ .
the excitement continues ….. the ruling party actually proving themselves that it will
continue to supress minority voice . As what a Tamil proverb says ‘ thavalai than vaayaal
kedum’ .
End of the day …. why we need to scold umno ? Pity them ๐
As always said it’s in their blood and mentality , cant change !
But we could change the way we think . That is what we WANT ???
If you rare a dog it will chase your cat ; if you rear a cat it will chase your rat .
We choose what we want dog/cat/lion/leopard ? Dont knock your head to teach a cat
to observe full time vege !
are you guys excited ? Good luck Makkal ! Fyi , if DSAI could turn the table
coming Dec/jan… GE13 is very close ! Ask yourself wht we WANT ???
btw , saw a fwd mail from someone….. suggesting a new name …
“He In Draft” hahahahha
Keep dreaming….bro…
One by one my prredictions are coming true….
the death of HINDRAF is very near….
as for DSAI, hahahahahaha…only fools will still believe in him or in his promises.
MP: it seems there is no such manifesto. PM ‘s Dept clarified today.
didnt i always say that our ‘big brother’ will never change… so we have to change … worth reading … good article … you can read in full at the blog.source:http://hsudarren.wordpress.com/2008/10/20/the-leopard-is-not-changing-its-spots/The leopard is not changing its spots——————————–2 things in the past 2 days helped strengthened my belief that UMNO would not change.Firstly, my fellow blogger romerz alarmed me as to the manifesto of our DPM in his quest to be the No. I of UMNO. It was mentioned in Malaysiakini that the DPM announced: รข??I will defend the supremacy of the Malays until the last drop of my blood if I win the mandate of the delegates to become the next Umno president at election to be held in March 2009?.The first thing that strikes my mind is whether UMNO leaders learned anything from the MArch 8 General Election. It seems that they are still willing to play race politics which was rejected in the last general election.—————————————————
ya MP , the ‘clarification’ was noted in the blog itself . Also not forgetting the conflict of how someone(support group..etc) could release manifesto on behalf of a top leader just like that…. that is the part many , incl myself , interested .
the manifesto seems a confusion. the reporter resigned it seems. should just drop the matter .
It is not a confusion, it was a plan to undermine Najib and boost support for DAP and their PR partners in crime.
This incident is serious enough to warrant an investigation. I wonder who is behind this and has the mentality to descent to such depths in desperate attempt to kill of Najib…
Know how RPK and DSAI planted stories about Altantunya, it would not be a shock if these clowns are behind this also.