Samy hits back at HINDRAF on memorandum

August 17th, 2007 by poobalan | View blog reactions Leave a reply »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe by Email



finally, something that appeared on mainstream media (the NST) about the memorandum by HINDRAF. Just some hot air and no facts as usual 🙂

Samy Vellu hits back at Hindu Rights Action Force
BERNAMA
source
try H E R E
PUTRAJAYA, FRI:

MIC president Datuk Seri S. Samy Vellu today launched a stinging attack against a non-governmental organisation, the Hindu Rights Action Force (HINDRAF), which claimed that the Barisan Nasional (BN) government had done little to address the woes of the Malaysian Indian community over the last 50 years.

“I must state here that if there is anything that affects the Indian community, the MIC will be there to fight it out even when we are partners of the Barisan Nasional. To me, I have never remained idle and I don’t waste time,” Samy Vellu, who is also Works Minister, told Bernama today.

The MIC supremo was asked to comment on a 18-point memorandum by HINDRAF, which was handed to the Prime Minister’s office last Sunday by the organisation’s chairman P. Waytha Moorthy, secretary V.K Regu and its legal adviser P. Uthayakumar.

Apart from stating that the Indian community was marginalised by the BN government, in the memorandum, HINDRAF also wanted an end to special privileges given to Malays. The memorandum also took a dig at Umno asking the largest political party in the country to “stop playing politics” through the “mandore” (supervisor) system by dishing out aid to the Indian community on a piecemeal basis.

Advertisement

847 comments

  1. Ahmad Sanusi says:

    Dear Killer,

    I think you are right, you are reallly an eskimo. Insyallah, if you decide to declare yourself as an eskimo. If you still have some respect for islam as an religion then just forget about UMNO. Not all muslim and malays are pro-UMNO. Please behave yourself when you don the colors of UMNO. Terima Kasih.

  2. tuah67 says:

    Dear Ahmad Sanusi,

    My stand remains not to support Hindraf, its got nothing to do with racism. All my points is to justify my stands, Malaysian regargless Indian, Chinese, Malay, Kadazan, etc should only take amicable approach in addressing their plight. You are so naive by saying UMNO members only get supports from their 3million members. I never joint UMNO, most of my friend since my childhood are not UMNO members. But, they all share common principle. BN and its component members form strong government, and Majority Malaysian wants a strong government to prosper Malaysia.

    To All, who keep on doing personal attack, please be rational with your own stand. I play my role as piece loving Malaysian. I’ve been voting since the year I eligible to vote. I do vote for opposition but mostly I vote for BN. I just want Hindraf to stop manipulating facts, distort and dilute Malaysians fundamental principle to strive together and develop Malaysia.

    I’m very busy and yet I sacrifice my precious times to play my role as peace loving Malaysian to discourage Malaysian from supporting Hindraf. I provide you all the reality of the geo politics in Malaysia. I’m not racist, but strongly support the government to ensure Malaysia safety and security.

    I would like to rest my case, good luck and have a nice day.

    cheers !

  3. pablo says:

    pls my indians..stop all this nonsense..its just going to make things worst..

  4. pablo says:

    ur going to make our future generation suffer?even im indian when i schooling the malays always refer to 13mei..now u want my kid to suffer because of hindraf?childrens get influenced faster than adults..pls la..govt just take all those ppl who supports hindraf under ISA.game over.

  5. Umanan says:

    Chong is a typical materialistic fella….and probably racist too…
    U wanna Indians/Malays as friends/customers but internally, u feel they r beggars n u r superior..
    If you dunno what Hindraf is advocating for, just dun comment on it. Dun show you r naive in the subject discussed…

  6. Mael says:

    Sikit je nak cakap….. Buat la apa nak buat tapi kene ingat sarang tebuan jangan di jolok…… Bahaya kalau dijolok…. ingat balik sejarah…kita hidup kat malaysia ni dah kira aman damai dah jangan gatai2 nak buat orang lain susah…. GUA Peduli apa lu punya masalah tapi tolong sket ar JANGAN DOK USIK HAL ORANG MELAYU… Selendang merah masih ade tau…

  7. ajax says:

    Tuan Hj Othman

    The issue is not whether the temples are bigger or not..The issue is whether the temples are legal or not.

  8. Raji Lamari says:

    i’ve never been interested in politics especially malaysian politics as i feel it’s full of bullshit! Isn’t there anyone who can stop the atrocities of the government and police??? Now they say Hindraf is involved with terrorist and the murder charge….daaaaaa! I wonder what next?

    it wud be just a matter of time,whereby the leaders and supporters of Hindraf are going to be locked up for 10/20 yrs under some stupid charge by creating some new name under the bloody law…and in no time close the case…trust me be it MIC or what ever party that exist they going to hide their tails in their pants and go running behind BN…bunch of idiots.

    It saddens me to read abt the updates which clearly shows there is no justice in this country, just look at the way the Badawi, Nazri,Khairy and the likes n not forgetting MR Semi Value…instead of amicably solving the problem they are making it worse. I wonder if the care what the world thinks abt their reactions!!!

    SOMEBOY PLEASE SAVE THIS COUNTRY!!!

    Very upset…Badawi ur a failure…

  9. Prakash says:

    Hey Thamilian

    You should have gone back a little further back and pointed out that all mankind originated from Africa 🙂

  10. bobo says:

    GANYANG HINDRAF!!!!WE LOVE SAMY VELLU

  11. LEONG says:

    MP: edited.

    HINDRAF ADALAH PEROSAK NEGARA.PENDERHAKA..WA PUNYA BUISNESS MANYAK RUGI LO!!!!MARI KITA HANTAR INI ORANG BALIK INDIA..BIAR DIA ORANG JAGA LEMBU DAN KERBAU DI INDIA..DIA INGAT ITU NEGARA INDIA BANYAK BAGUS KA..PIGI BALIK INDIA LA..JANGAN KACAU WA PUNYA BUISNESS..***** LU..

  12. BO BO says:

    FOR HINDRAF MEMBERS..PLEASE GO BACK 2 YOUR HOME TOWN(india).FOR MIC MEMBERS..U ARE MY FRIEND..LET,S WORK TOGETHER…HIDUP SAMY VELLU!!!!!

  13. MAN MANJA says:

    MP: Edited. many questions you ask, but i’ll answer one of it. in islam, if you marry a muslim, you must convert to their religion (from what i know). i suppose this is not strongly enforced in many countries in the world, but it is strictly enforced in malaysia. there are those who can afford to migrate to oversea and live with their spouse without converting.

    OHH..AJE AJE NAK CARI PASAL…
    ASYIK CAKAP WE ARE MALAYSIAN …MALAYSIA BOLEH!
    WAWASAN 2020..RELIGION FREEDOM..FULL EDUCATION..
    ITULAH INILAH….*****
    EXAMPLE….
    PEOPLE WHO PRAISE THE LEADERS AND LICK THEIR FEETS..ANSWER THIS
    WE ARE MALAYSIAN……WHY GOT DIFFRENT TYPE OFF PREVILAGE?
    WHAT MEANING OF BUMIPUTRA? IS THAT ONLY MALAYS BORN IN MALAYSIA? OTHERS?
    HOW ABOUT ORANG ASLI? IF MALAYS ALWAYS SAID THEY ARE BUMIPUTRA?
    MALAYSIA BOLEH? BOLEH UNTUK APA? UNTUK PAKAI POLIS GERTAK ORANG MISKIN?
    WAWASAN 2020? APA ITU? ADAKAH ORANG MISKIN TAHU APA ITU? ORANG MAKAN DUIT MEMANG TAHU…ADAKAH WAWASAN 20202 MEMBANTU SEMUA ORANG?
    RELIGION FREEDOM? PENIPU…. WHY OTHER RELIGION MUST CONVERT TO ISLAM IF MARRY MALAY WOMEN?
    WHY GOVERMENT ONLY BUILT MOSQUE?
    WHY RELIGION ISSUE DISCUSSED FAIR? WHY MUST GO TO SYARIAH COURT FOR DISCUSS OTHER RELIGION CLASH WITH ISLAM(SYARIAH ALWAYS SUPPORT ONE SIDE)
    WHY GOVERMENT DEMOLISH OTHER RELIGIONS PLACE.WHICH ALREADY HERE BEFORE THE MERDEKA? JANGAN CAKAP TANAH HARAM..NAGARA INI DAH MENJADIKAN BANAYK TANAH HARAM MENJADI MILIK MELAYU..
    THE WORST IN MALAYSIA..
    EDUCATION…..50 YRS MERDEKA…
    WHY OTHER SCHOOL(MOSTLY ALL TAMIL SCHOOLS)STILL LOOK LIKE PONDOK..IS THAT MALAYSIA SAYS SAMA RATA?
    WHY ALL SCHOOLS NEVAR SUBSIDY BY GOVERMENT?
    THEY CAN SAY GIVE RM10 OOO OR RM 100000..WHAT IS IT? BAGI SEDEKAH KE? EVEN MY CAR POCH ALSO CANT BUILT FOR THAT..MONEY..
    WHY MALYS SCHOOL SRK LOOK LIKE UNIVERSITY..BUT TAMIL SCHOOLS LIKE CANTEEN?
    IF PEOPLE WHO CANT SEE THIS SITUATION..THEY ALL SUCKING LEADERS XXXX.
    HOW MANY STUDENTS GETS CHANCE TO STUDY IN UNIVERSITY?
    WHY IF THEY GET ALSO ..WHY SEND THEM THIS END TO THAT END OR TO SABAH SARAWAK?
    WHY WHY WHY?
    THE THINGS HERE CAN SEE CLEARLY GOVERMENT FOR 50 YRS CLOSE EYE..AND PUSH AWAY OTHERS ONE SIDE..WHY WHY WHY?
    .WHO ARE THE LEDARS?
    WHY THEY COME FROM ZERO..TO MILLIONEIR IN 5 YRS TERM ONLY..EVEN THEIR RELATIVES BECOME MILLIONEAIR..HOW POSIIBLE?
    THE ONE WHO LCIK FEETS ….YES GET WAT THEY WANT AND CLOSE THE MOUTH LET OTHERS DIE…
    SAMY ******.
    HISAMUDIN ******
    NAJIB ******
    BADAWI XXXXXXX

  14. frankie_teh says:

    dear all,
    Mei 13 is like world war 1 and world war 2, please be reminded that mei 13 is also where freddy kruger kills all. Mei 13 is about friday the 13 where all killers roam the streets. Mei 13 is also where the stock market crash and mei 13 is also where terrorist invaded america and also where japanese bomb pearl habor. Huh? what else we have about mei 13? I think we can do a movie here about mei 13 since during childhood, mei 13 is a very-very frightening nite for a moviegoers. Let’s do a movie on mei 13, anybody here wanna be a movie director??

  15. hahaha Frankie I like ur joke here, we can do a movie where we have some phychopath brandishing a keris that roams the street at chow kit road killing all chinese and indians and are invincible to the FRU and polis. This bloody lunatic phycho have got a fetish to stab protestors and also hide within the shadows of Darth Veloo. We will have parents telling their teenagers children not to go out on mei 13 every year as the lunatic phycho have a magical keris when stab you will turn into a pontianak hahahaha care to apply for a movie director post???

  16. Ong Kah Ming says:

    Hey John,
    Can I edit some movie lines in “Mei 13 – The Return”. Mei 13 is suppose to be every year celebration where all the Mat Rempits comes out of their hiding to celebrate their freedom. Unfortunately, some bloody looney that carries a keris starts killing every Mat Rempits. Now the polis have problem in identifying this serial killer as most people carries a keris for protection. Wait….this must be a preview of Mei 13 let’s hope that there’s no censor board from TV3……”Mei 13 – You Scream in Silence”

  17. Jaihin says:

    Hey guy’s we all know that Hindraf have done a good job. Stop giving coment and start thinking about next election. To whom we should vote. Start think why this assembly happen frequently. There should be some political support for this team. Why this assembly did not happen 2 years ago and Why it should happen few month of before the election. It clearly show that some body try to send signal dont vote blindly to BN. This issue now become as racist and going to lead to terrorist issue. So start think in advance for whom we should vote. But Hindraf are thru our nation Hero no matter if their not spend time in Space.Their are our true hero’s.

  18. Song says:

    MP: nope. this is my blog 🙂

    Is this a LTTE terrorist blog?

    :-p

  19. zorro says:

    MP: pendatang haram came here on their own accord right? i don’t think its the same with the time before 1957. If the indians did not agree to the terms during independence, then there would not have been any independence at that time. anyway, calling people pendatang haram can be hurtful. wonder what khir toyo will say if tell such things about his parent 🙂 . Secondly, these general labour (including the chinese) are the ones who made malaysia as it is now. growth in mining, plantation and transportation sector helped malaysia move forward between 1900s until 1970s. so, after 30 years, you conveniently want to chase them away? hmmm…sounds ungrateful and unbecoming of a person who professes any religion.

    I think the govt should support their money claim to British govt. After that, after they acknowledge that they only rought here by force by british govt, means the are just as good as pendatang haram to malays, since those days. If they knew and acknowledge that the are just ‘pendatang haram’, they should know as well that they are dont deserve to be here. Just get the money and go back to india. It is your place. You can live happily ever after with your descendent. Why should you be here? You dont have any history here except that you were brought in as prostitute to british, and ESTATE worker, buat jalan etc. in another words as GENERAL LABOUR. You all is just for that. Now, when all the estate closed down, you got no where to shout. You got no place to mabuk todi. Those days you all make noise in the estate, and no one bother. Once all the estate is closed down, you go to street, make noise. I think, the only place you deserved is only estate.

    Remember, you got no history here. You are just a labour, as good as current maid from indonesia, workers from bangla, nepal etc. You dont deserved to have anything. We can live without you.

  20. Peace Loving Man says:

    As a peace loving person, I urge the government of Malaysia to take stern actions against those who create unstability and chaos in our beloved country. It doesn’t matter who they are, Hindraf, Al-Maunah, Islamic Terrorists or what not/ If they are threats to our nation, they should be eliminated. I have multi-racial friends and neighbors whom I make friends not because of their skin colors but because of their sincerity. Friendship is color-blind. You Hindraf supporters should stop your violent activities at once.

  21. Kicker says:

    These Hindraf supporters need to have their asses kicked out of this country real good and hard.

  22. love indian says:

    hey…Pablo do you think you only have kid & family don’t be self fish….scoundrel bull shit. Hindraf fight for us and our generation doesn’t be puppet to Umno government.
    Come on man you want your next generation suffer with Umno treat….
    What Hindraf asking for our basic rights…….its is criminal acting???

    1) In the grant of state land,
    2) Admission to public and administrative service;
    3) To trade and do business, licenses, permits etc
    4) Primary, secondary, skills Training, university and overseas university education.
    5) No special privileges for the Malays,
    6) No discrimination of any ethnic community based on race or religion,
    7) The retention of all their places of worship in particular Hindu temples, crematoriums and burial sites,
    8) Freedom of Religion,
    9) Malaya is to be a Secular State and not an Islamic state,
    10) Right to mother tongue education in particular Tamil schools to be fully aided,
    11) Minimum wage for the lowest paid, and
    12) Equal recognition as sons of soil for all Malayan born.

    Come on Malaysia Indian keep on support Hindraf. And don’t listen to the Puppets, Hindraf for Malaysia Indian justice…… We love Hindraf and support Hindraf.
    Go for our Indian rights,,,,,,

  23. eagleyes says:

    OK PENYOKONG HINDRAF…TERUSKANLAH DENGAN EMOSI ANDA..TERUSKANLAH BERPRASANGKA..SAYA MENYERU ORANG MELAYU..PEDULIKAN MEREKA! KITA HIDUP MACAM BIASA…ERATKAN PERPADUAN MELAYU! BANYAKKAN BERURUS NIAGA SESAMA KITA! PEDULIKAN MEREKA YANG BERPRASANGKA DENGAN KITA.. BANYAKKAN ZURIAT/GENERASI KITA… INSYAALLAH TANAH MELAYU TETAP MILIK KITA !!!!

  24. Ninjaturtle says:

    MP: perhaps tax exemption can be provided for contribution to such as “indian development fund” and added with ringgit to ringgit match by govt. this can be extended to a “orang asli development fund” as well. i mean if such funds (like mara etc) can be create for the poor majority, there no reason at all to not create the same for the poor minorities, unless of course there is insincerity and selfishness involved.

    Dear Friends,

    INDIAN consists of hindu, christian, singh and others..
    Let we indians take oppurtunity on the uncertainty in Malaysia politics now.. Think big frens..

    Whether it is HINDRAF or MIC or YSS (controlled by christian indians), please propose to badawi’s goverment to implement a developement scheme for indians funded by indians themselves..

    The plan is like this:

    1. Every working indians must contribute RM 10 from their EPF every month and this fund must be governed by Bank Negara..

    2. 1 million EPF paying Indians will add up to RM 10 million per month to this fund..

    3. This fund is to be used only for education and skills related programs only.. No politics, No religion involved…

    4. This fund must be approved as an legislation by government, same as SINDA in Singapore..

    5. We, indians no need to rely on other race to build our own community..

    6. Forget about samy Vellu’s fund collection and his betrayal…

    7. Let’s start a new life.. Think about it..

    Please think about it.. and give ideas to make this a reality.. your good views and ideas very much needed by our indians.. Stop blaming each other and start to think positively..

  25. True Indian says:

    Dear Hj Othman,

    Wat u mean by it doesnt matter wheter the temple is bigger or not but if its legal… Only God knows how many mosque is legal… Breaking temple is a hyper sensitive thing for all indians, I believe other races too…. Indians wont make big fuss if its a house, hall or anything else… Common man, a 100 years old temple, why cant our government legalize it instead of it should be legal… What is mic doing…. dat aggravates the anger of all indians throught Malaysia… Otherwise, things will be a normal… So please use your head & think the cause before start to pin point indians. Its just like a matchbox, when u start scratching it with match stick, the fire will spark.

  26. Previta says:

    Dear Hj Othman,

    Wat u mean by it doesnt matter wheter the temple is bigger or not but if its legal… Only God knows how many mosque is legal… Breaking temple is a hyper sensitive thing for all indians, I believe other races too…. Indians wont make big fuss if its a house, hall or anything else… Common man, a 100 years old temple, why cant our government legalize it instead of it should be legal… What is mic doing…. dat aggravates the anger of all indians throught Malaysia… Otherwise, things will be a normal… So please use your head & think the cause before start to pin point indians. Its just like a matchbox, when u start scratching it with match stick, the fire will spark.

  27. eagleyes says:

    Biarkan mereka dengan emosi mereka…biarkan mereka dengan prasangka tak berasas mereka…Ayuh orang Melayu yang melawati blog ini…kita diam sahaja… kita bersatu hati…kita berurus niaga sesama kita…majukan ekonomi kita perkukuhkan benteng perpaduan kita. Tanah Melayu tetap milik kita !!!!!!!!!!

  28. eagleyes says:

    Mereka mungkin memang pandai bercakap…pandai berhujah… pandai memanipulasi fakta…biarkan mereka…tak mengapa…berjuanglah untuk kaummu…kami umat Melayu akan tetap terus bekerja, bersatu…Tanah Melayu tetap milik kita !!!!

  29. pablo says:

    apa pun melayu,cina,india semua boleh diam tak?komen tak tentu hala buat apa?jangan jadi macam sial kat sini..kalau nak komen guna bahasa baik baik..jangan nak kurang ajar

  30. southpark says:

    this blog is like bullshit!!
    hey all bro, no matter what race u r, just work hard
    n u will get as much as u work for!!

    long live MALAYSIA!!

    may god bless this country,..

    no more 13 mei…

    just remembar that…

  31. pe says:

    Ninjaturtle Says:

    I support what Ninja turtle says only the Indians shd help the indians. let those who earn more than RM2000 give RM20 per month while the rest give RM 10. Why not this scheme be combined with the KOP Didik scheme under MIC , and let it be run by Professionals. Maybe the Government can give RM for RM , if it really wants to help. We must prepare our next generation with education opportunities.
    The reason why the Chinese are not so affected is because they have an economy amongst themselves . We shd learn japanese and Chinese. Our skilled Indian workers can go to Japan or china in time to come . We could learn Arabic, and work in Dubai. There are a lot of possibilities here and around the world we shd not be afraid to explore. Hindraf shd now think of this instead of taking a confrontational approach. Because the government is not going to budge on the Bumi policy. We have to work around the government and take whatever opportunities that would come along. I think a good productive and skilled Indian worker will do well anywhere.There was this foreign Indian worker from India who worked with a Chinese contractor. In two years he become skilled in brick laying , tiling and pluming. He decided to go freelance and started doing small time renovation contracts.
    Do you know the sikhs in bangkok used to hawk in the streets. today they are businessman. I think fighting will get us no where

  32. Kicker says:

    If you see an Indian and a snake…well you know which one to kill first, right?! (Indian joke which I find it very funny) Hahahaha!!!!

  33. man manja says:

    MP: edited.

    melayu ingat dia orang bumiputra malysia ke?
    lu orang pun pendatang haram yang belot harta orang asli…
    pandai pandai je ingat bumiputra..sebelum kata orang lain tengok buntut lu orang dulu .bau belacan saja..
    makan hasil orang goyang kaki memang la bersatu padu..
    bapa lu orang pun..***** kaki british dulu..
    tengok lu orang punya perempuan..banyak bohsia..dah sekeloh menengah aje jadi *******..jangan cakap orang lain kalau tak nak jaga lu orang punya masalah..eagle..kicker .zorro…semua tiga orang bersatupadu untuk maian sama sendiri aje

  34. Ong Kah Ming says:

    Yo! Engleyes…Tanah Melayu atau tanah Malaysia??? Jom kita pergi rampas hak-hak cina and hak-hak lain orang tak kira bangsa lah. Mungin kita boleh rampas jugak tanah America dan tanah Jepun….kalau boleh kita rampas semua sebelum election nanti tak ada peluang untuk rampas semua. Apa pulak tanah ini tanah itu semua melayu punya…saya punya seluar pun you nak keh?? boleh lah you ambil saja, kalau boleh ambil lar seluar dalam jugak semua orang melayu punya, lain orang tinggal di Malaysia ialah buruh paksa.

  35. Cina Apek says:

    Aiya, just ask the govt to demolish all temples and churches lar. Take away all land and belong to chinese and indians and build more mosques. Also try to build some mosques in UK and Russia so that we can conquer all the other nations. Maybe can build some mosque in Japan and China also so that we BumiSias can conquer China and Japan. Also start buying more missiles and war planes so that we can go to war with India. Heard that the govt also banning pigs and christian crosses in schools. So let’s gather all dogs and pigs and start cleansing these animals. Wah!! Melayu power….the most powerful nation in the world!!! Makes me a proud Malay-sian.

  36. Henry Woo says:

    Heard that the UMNO sapiens are now planning to conquer Singapore by invading some islands near Johor. Each of us should donate RM50 per Malaysian to allow our govt to buy more arms to conquer Singapore. I also understand that we have enough ammo to disarm thailand and also Australia. Yeah man!! Malaysia boleh, we support Malaysia to conquer all other races. We support the malays to conquer Asia. Yeah!! Yeah!! Let’s turn Asia into Malay-Asia!!!

  37. Sam Wong says:

    Hey Kicker,
    You seem to have a fetish for snakes, why dun you go and play with some snakes in UMNO assembly. There’s a lot of snakes there. The UMNO snakes are blood sucking the nation poor man…n you seem to be more concern about killing snakes huh!!! Go start a movie at http://www.corruptor.com you will be able to develop top talents like sami veloo the top snakeman in Malaysia…

  38. chong says:

    I agree with Ninjaturtle, my point was why malays and indian still hopping for subsidies? can u guys stand on your own.

    Dear Umanan, if u HINDRAF (not all indian) don’t materialistic, why ask for 1 mil per person from british gov? it is begging. don’t say that u guys are not meterialistic.i don’t say that i dun support HINDRAF, but the method that u guys did was wrong. not in the proper manner.provoking others etc. all the while i’m in the opposition side, but what to do i support the party that always loose during the election. But at least i’ve my own stand. During non-election period, might as well focus on what u call ‘materialistic’ stuff which is cari makan. 1 question, why u r working all this time? satisfaction?just fullfill your time? don’t bluff man.it’s all bcoz money. u r fighting in this forum also becoz of money. no money to send children to oversea, etc. money is not everything but everything is money. U don’t know what MCA, GERAKAN and DAP does? eventhough they r opposite in the politics, but they r unite in helping us.

    lastly, lets us change the rulling of the country, don’t think all chinese agree with MCA, all malays agree with UMNO, and all indian agree with MIC. if u really love this country, try not to do something stupid (rally, etc). just change the gov, opposition has 5 years to try, if still fail than go the plan B (not think of it yet).

    sorry my english not as perfect as u guys coz i’m not study high.

  39. Malik Azizan says:

    Dear Hj Othman,
    Maklum semua melayu ada tempat sembayang tetapi kaum india kurang kawasan untuk sembayang. Jangan lah kata Temple di Malaysia adalah lebih besar dari temple di negara India. Itu salah dan boleh menyebab perselisihan dengan kaum india and juga bangsa lain lain kerana kita mesti respect bangsa lain and juga kaum lain. Tahun depan ialah 2008 sudah cukup kita orang melayu merendahkan kaum-kaum cina and india di tanahair kita. Biarlah kita tolong menolong. Jangan biar crony UMNO menperlakukan orang Malaysia dengan tipu-muslihat membutakan orang Malaysia. Biarlah kita menyokong parti pembankang dalam election yang akan datang dan undilah Keadilan dan DAP yang boleh menolong semua orang Malaysia tak kira bangsa dan ugama. This world is a better place for all religion and all races be united towards a new and peaceful world. Kalau kerajaan kita boleh bercakap macam kita cakap sekarang tentu tidak ada lagi protest dari Bersih atau Hindraf. Hj. Othman tentu setuju kan….

  40. Malik,

    I setuju dengan statement Malik yang kita mesti tolong menolong. Kita tidak bermusuh degan kaum india atau kaum cina. Kita mesti bergabung dengan orang india dan orang cina untuk memperkuatkan kedudukan Malaysia dalam arena dunia dengan pelbagai technologi dan perniagaan. Adakah kerajaan kita menyokong pergambungan bangsa Malaysia? Sudah lama kita memanggil kaum melayu sebagai Bumiputra, orang muslim orang UMNO, why don’t kita saja jadi satu united bangsa yang di perkenalkan sebagai orang Malaysia. Kan orang cina juga orang Malaysia? Kan orang India juga orang Malaysia? Kan MyKad menyatakan perkataan Malaysia? Lebih baik kalau mula dari 2008 kita drop perkattan “melayu”, “cina” dan “india” dari buku-buku teks sekolah menengah. Di negara lain macam France, Italy, Holland terdapat banyak orang afrika yang sudah dapat warganegara Peranchis dan kerajaan Peranchis refer mereka sebagai orang Peranchis bukan orang afrika. Saya juga ada ramai kawan cina kat England yang mempunyai warganegara UK tetapi orang british hanya panggil kawan cina sebagai orang british tidak kira bangsa atau agama. Time to change Barisan National, PM please hear the voices of the nation, I Dato Nooraishah, being a malay would like to be called Malaysian instead of Bumiputra. Salam Sejahtera. Terima Kasih dan Selamat malam.

  41. Song says:

    MP: Malaysian Hindu Sangam says there’s 17,000 over temples. Now, why are there more temple/population ratio for Hindus? (i) hindus pray to different deities for different reasons, thus you can find about 3 temples per location. just like denominations in christianity, i believe. however, it is possible to house few deities in one temple/location, so this can be a possible solution.(ii) migration/displacement of people from estates. The temples are seldom moved together with the migrating/displaced people. the temple left behind at estate areas are taken care by people still living nearby those temples, while those who got displaced/migrated will build new ones. thus, one solution is to relocate temples as well as the people. (iii) pockets of hindus are all over the place. there are very few locations with high indian population. so, with small population in a widespread location, logically people want to go to temple near to their home. just like a surau in every taman. if we set a temple or two (or any other religious building) for every 5km radius, that will be fairer rather than comparing it to population ratio. now, if we are as small as singapore and have good, affordable transportation system, maybe can revise the 5km idea. (iv) the hindus are well known to be religious and also temple building civilisation. a well known phrase in tamil says “don’t live in a place where there’s no temple”. so, how to let go of this culture? and i thought we are living in a multicultural society!.

    BTW, 16,000 is mosques only or includes suraus (even those at shopping centers/govt depts/schools/hospitals etc.)?

    For a population of 2 million Indians, what is the need for 20,000 temples in Malaysia? Remember, there are 16 million Malays and just 16,000 mosques.

    That was the rationale given by local authorities before razing down illegal constructions. Plus it is easier to manage, state support and monitor the activities of large places of worship with CCTV than smaller ones.

    By exaggerating, inciting against and stereotyping Bumiptera schemes and insulting the Agong (by carrying photos of foreign monarchs), Hindraf has done more harm than good to Indians in the long-term.

    I fully support the government.

  42. LOUIS says:

    my dear indian brothers just a word of advise . there s going to be a time in the near future the whole world is going to face a monitory crisis.go get urselves a piece of agriculture land and learn how to develop it .in the times of crisis money will have no value. if you have a land you it can save you and your family from this crisis.take this advise very seriously . you will never regret it. we can exel in this field cos indian s are the best planters in the world . god bless and good luck.plant short crops vegetable and grow live stock .cows goat chicken fish ect .

  43. pablo says:

    love indian refer to your comment about hindraf..pls la…im not selfish but im telling the fact..hindraf is full of bullshit..forget all these and get back to your work(if u have one).

  44. pablo says:

    MP: edited.

    yes kicker ur right..im an indian but i feel indians ni kaki putar belit..kick ur asses and get back to work my dear indians…another part i want to add here is im shy to be called a malaysian indian now because of some ppl like hindraf and the supporters..**** OFF HINDRAF

  45. Mat Rempit says:

    We love what Hindraf is doing, wish all Mat Rempits will follow the Hindraf way of society solution. Here we are a group of educated Mat Rempits roaming the KL streets with our Cup-Chai and also Harley Davidson. How we can elude the FRU and polis so far is by protesting at night, we don’t protest by walking – we protest by riding our Bikes from one end to another. We don’t carry placards and posters but we modify our bikes to make more noise. But our Mat Rempits still have got a lot to learn from Hindraf. We can beat up some polis to release tension, and our brother Khairi Jamaludin will bail us out so that we are above the law. In fact, our Mat Rempits have recruited a lot of Hindraf members, we have so far recruited bout 73 hindraf members and still recruiting. Our big brother Khairi is setting up a Mat Rempit fund to undertake to change all Mat Rempits to Mat Cemerlang. With the Mat Rempit funds now available, we can roam the city ….the Hindraf way!!!!!!!!!

  46. VIE says:

    udal manaku…uyir tamil ke….letz go to find the truth and show it to world….MY SUPPORT 100000

  47. Crazy Nuke says:

    there will be a time malaysia will kena nicely from other country! Till then you malays just keep talking.

  48. man manja says:

    pabla back stabber…
    dont said you are indian…you are xxxxing bxxxard

  49. man manja says:

    betul apa yang dikatakan oleh malik and dato noor.
    kita lebih gemar dipangil orang malaysia..
    daripada dipangil ikut kaum..
    we must equally being anak malaysia..
    why goverment and some stupids..think they are the one come from heaven? all born in a place called earth..now they think they own the land ….stupids..god give all for all..why u all seperate it..
    be unite as one nation

  50. Song says:

    Eventually, the industrialising world forgets noisy rabble rousers like:

    Luddite in England
    Falun Gong in China
    Hindraf in Malaysia

    There is only one panacea : education!

    ;-p