Bersih rally participation estimate by PoliTweet

/* July 18th, 2011 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


 

 

This is an interesting calculation based on tweets. They estimate the crowd to be about 45ooo. I think if the footage from helicopters are released (untampered), then we can get a accurate estimate.

refer the website at : http://www.politweet.org/site/july9rally_crowdmap.php

 

 

PETALING JAYA: Crowd estimates for the July 9 Bersih 2.0 rally are almost as contentious as the rally itself. Various figures have been bandied about. Just about everybody has their own estimation – the organisers, police and the media.

Now, one man has come out and said that with his mathematical calculations, the figure is around 45,000 and 50,000. He is Politweet founder, Ahmed Kamal Nava.

Politweet.org, a research organisation that studies Twitter interactions between Malaysian citizens and politicians, had mapped out the number of people who attended the rally using polygons.

But before proceeding to draw the polygons, a timeline of events needed to be established.

Ahmed Kamal told FMT that his primary source to determine the timeline of events were tweets and also pictures posted on Twitter as these pictures, unlike the ones posted on Facebook or other websites, had the integral time stamped on them.

“Using the images from the photo gallery as a reference, I started to draw the polygons covering the area on a map. I used some photos found online, if they were of higher quality, and matched them up with my established timeline,” he said. He established that at about 1pm to 2.30pm the crowd was at its largest.

“The crowd estimation is based on this peak period for different areas within the same time frame. This is to avoid double-counting because crowds were moving, growing and shrinking between 1pm and 4pm,” he said.

“Using the polygons, I was able to use a custom tool to estimate the covered area in square feet. With the factors stated on the website, it was possible to gauge how many people were gathered.”

“Polygons were then generated based on the photos taken within that time frame in different parts of the city,” he said, explaining the methodology used on Politweet’s website.

“The area covered by the polygon was calculated using a separate tool, and this area was then divided by a factor based on how dense the crowd was,” he added.

“If the crowd was standing close together, the factor was one person for every 4 sq ft (one person/4 sq ft). If the crowd was moving about, or a mix of people standing close and far, then it was one person for every 5 sq ft to 6 sq.ft. The factors used are stated for each map.”

He had focused on three areas of the city during the peak period – Puduraya, KLCC and Sungei Wang Plaza. The other “hot spots” such as Pasar Seni were either counted as a subset of these three areas or fell under the “others” category.

“Crowds that were close to Puduraya (such as at the Agro Bank at 12.30pm) are assumed to have joined the Puduraya crowd,” he said.

“Smaller groups were recorded at other areas such as Jalan Raja Laut, Pasar Seni, and Jalan Maharajalela and are all assumed to be within the ‘other’ group of 2,000. This also includes people who stayed behind in Petaling Street when the majority moved to Puduraya at 1pm,” he added.

source: http://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/2011/07/14/bersih-rally-maths-puts-crowd-at-4500-to-50000/

MP Bagan Serai Gobalakrishnan escapes

/* July 18th, 2011 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


MP for Bagan Serai had his fine reduced from RM3000 to RM1000, thus avoiding the situation where he will be ineligible for next election, if he stand for election.

The High Court in Penang reduced to RM1,000 the RM3,000 fine a magistrate’s court imposed on Padang Serai MP N Gobalakrishnan, who was found guilty last year of obstructing a police officer in 2002.

Judge Zamani Abdul Wahab also ordered that Gobalakrishnan, who had paid the RM3,000 fine in full last year, be repaid RM2,000.

Gobalakrishnan had filed an appeal in the High Court in May last year, after the magistrate’s court fined him RM3,000 or six months’ jail for obstructing chief inspector V Saravanan from carrying his duty at Jalan Utama, George Town, at 12.20pm on Jan 29, 2002.

He was arrested for questioning police action in preventing about 30 supporters of the then Parti Keadilan Nasional from dancing during a Thaipusam celebration.

Met by reporters outside the court, Gobalakrishnan said he would continue to discharge his duties as an elected representative.

source: http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/170006

Indians participation in Bersih rally

/* July 13th, 2011 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I’m still wondering how this conclusion was arrived at. I hope those folks in MIC can share their statistics on the number of Indians who participated in the rally last Saturday.  Is the conclusion based on absolute number or percentage of participants? Are they relying on third party data (police/media/observers) or had their own team on the ground gathering data?

I saw a tweet from MP Padang Serai N Gobalakrishnan who was replying to MP Ipoh Timur Lim Kit Siang saying: “@limkitsiang It shows that the Indians have deserted PR as not even 1% in Bersih”

I tweeted for clarification from the MP, but no reply to date, even after sending a reminder tweet: “@Ngobalakrishnan @novinthen @limkitsiang 1% of 6k or 50k or committee members?”

 

The decline in participation of Indians in the Bersih 2.0 illegal rally yesterday compared to that in the 2007 street demonstration was because they realised that it was only aimed at tarnishing the image of the BN government.

MIC president G Palanivel said many in the Indian community realised that yesterday’s illegal rally held in the federal capital was not actually about questioning the role of the Election Commission.

“The Indians are now more aware that such a practice (street demonstration) is no longer relevant in resolving issues.”

He said this to reporters after launching a book on the early history of the Kinta Indian Association and ground-breaking ceremony for its new building.

Palanivel said the realisation came about after proactive measures taken by the government that focused on improving the lot of the Indian community.

He said the Indians were benefiting from the efforts undertaken such as in the education, business, economic and social sectors.

“This has brought about a high level of realisation among the Indian community of the government’s sensitivity to their needs and problems.”

Palanivel said yesterday’s Bersih-organised illegal rally also clearly showed that the opposition was actually behind it, from the participation of opposition leaders such as Anwar Ibrahim, Abdul Hadi Awang, Lim Kit Siang and Azmin Ali.

The MIC president praised the police for their quick and stern action  against the illegal demonstrators to protect public safety and national security. – Bernama

source: http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/169492

Menu Rakyat 1Malaysia RM2 Breakfast and RM4 Lunch

/* July 13th, 2011 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


You can get the list of premises involved in this campaign at 1Pengguna website. The current url to the list of premises is at:

http://www.1pengguna.com/customregister/MENU%20RAKYAT%201MALAYSIA%20KELANTAN.htm

 

It weird that the list is displayed in HTML pages. No proper formatting makes it hard to read. Not a searchable database. Selangor, for example, has 77 entries (as of this blog entry  date), and you have to scroll or search using browser function to locate premises. I really wonder how they actually allowed this pages to be created and published. Must be a very lousy IT company.

Looking at price of things, its  compatible to or slightly cheaper than your average stalls or restaurants.  For example, roti canai + teh o is charged RM2 in some of the eateries.  Nasi Putih + Ayam goreng is charged RM4 at some locations.

If you want to save money, just pack some bread + butter/kaya/jam/etc from house.

Another thing, I only saw two Chinese stall (under MBSA). No other Chinese eateries. Does it mean you can’t get breakfast for under RM2 or lunch for under RM4 at Chinese outlets?

 

The public can now have breakfast for a ceiling price of RM2 and lunch for RM4 at 728 eateries in Peninsular Malaysia, through the Menu Rakyat 1Malaysia (1Malaysia People’s Menu) programme.

Launched by Domestic Trade, Cooperatives and Consumerism Minister Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob at ‘Q’ Bistro Nasi Kandar, here, Thurday, the programme aims to reduce the public’s daily expenses when frequently eating out.

“The public rarely have lunch and breakfast at home now, so with this programme, they can spend RM6 for both meals at selected outlets,” he told the media after launching the programme.

Ismail Sabri said they expected the number of participating eateries nationwide to reach 1,000 by the year end.

He said other eateries interested to join the programme could obtain further information from ministry’s offices in the states.

“An advantage of this programme is that the operators will receive special buntings from the ministry to be displayed in front of their outlet, which will attract more customers,” he added. – Bernama

source: http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/7/7/nation/20110707202209&sec=nation

48 inch TV and 3 door fridge at PPR flat but don’t pay rent

/* July 13th, 2011 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


“They told me when they first moved into their respective units, they were told by some politicians in the area that they were there for free.”

Either politicians become the scapegoats or politicians simply told stuff that they can’t guarantee. Usually happens when people are relocated from areas being redeveloped. They may be from a non-rent paying house, and can’t comprehend that they are being displaced and have to pay rent on top of that.

They can invest in entertainment and other necessities, but not able to pay rent because its not a priority and there’s always a way around later. Can get politicians to appeal, or get some fund from government to settle the arrears.


PPR Desa RejangHIGH LEAVING: PPR Desa Rejang flats where most occupants choose to stay for free

KUALA LUMPUR: A majority of residents living in the People’s Housing Project (PPR) homes in Kuala Lumpur, who fail to pay rental, are not poor. Instead, they are just indifferent and plain stubborn.

This was revealed to The Malay Mail by City Hall’s housing management director, Sukiman Surahman.

Sukiman said out of the 52,914 families renting PPR units, 41,029 of them were defaulters and out of the total number of defaulters, only 20 per cent can be categorised as hardcore poor.

PPR door bills

The other 80 per cent can afford the rent, but instead they are just plain stubborn. They know there is a monthly rent to be paid but they just can’t be bothered,” he said.

Sukiman got a shock when he recently visited PPR Kampung Muhibbah in Puchong and found many residents lived in comfort and yet failed to pay their monthly dues to City Hall.

“There’s nothing free in this world. The residents have to change their mindsets and start paying rent accordingly. If they face problems in paying their rent, they could always talk to us and we could work out an appropriate payment plan for them.”

City Hall, he said, identified 2000 PPR units that were in the hands of hardcore poor as of April this year.

The people who live in these units are usually those unemployed, have children with little furniture and with no financial assistance from any source.”

“We have also identified other families in the poor category. These families receive some form of financial help,” he said.

“As of April, we identified 1,600 PPR units with people who receive financial assistance from Baitumal as well as 600 unit occupants who receive financial assistance from the Social Welfare Department,” he said.

Sukiman said when encountering such families, City Hall usually adviced them on their next course of action.

“When I was doing my rounds at PPR Taman Mulia, I encountered a family of ten living in a unit. Both parents were jobless. Their eight young non-school going children stayed at home.

“This family owes City Hall RM8,000 in rent. We referred them to several bodies. Yayasan Wilayah sponsors their children to school, the Social Welfare Department gave them some form of monetary aid to carry on with their lives. Baitumal helped them with their rent,” he said.

Sukiman said plans are afoot to group the 2000 units of hardcore poor families for transfer into one separate PPR area.

“This will make it easier for the government to monitor them. Probably, we can get companies to help them as part of their corporate social responsibility programme,” he said.

48′ flat screen TVs … but they don’t pay rent

CITY HALL’s housing management director, Sukiman Surahman was taken aback when he visited PPR Kampung Muhibbah in Puchong.

“I visited a family who owes City Hall about RM17,000 in rent after not paying for more than 10 years.

I felt something amiss upon entering the hall of the house which contained a 48-inch flat screen television.

“Then upon entering a room, I saw another 36-inch flat screen television set. The house also had a three-door refrigerator.

The surprises did not end there.

“I went to another unit which owes us RM11,000 in rent. Can you imagine that?”

Sukiman said when he asked the families why they failed to pay their dues for so long, they told him they are not aware of such payments.

“They told me when they first moved into their respective units, they were told by some politicians in the area that they were there for free.

On explaining to them that there was no such thing as ‘free’ the families have agreed to pay their dues.

source: http://mmail.com.my/content/77703-ppr-rent-issue-freeloaders