How to trust the mainstream media?

/* September 3rd, 2010 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Today PM Najib said something, which sadly, can be interpreted as humor/satire/joke.  Just compare the two articles below. The Star’s is about half the length of the other article. I think the alternative media had more “facts” in terms of quoting the PM compared to Star (OK, its just one example). I don’t agree that mainstream media presents fact and such are more trustworthy. Sometimes, one  can choose which facts to present, or present “facts” in certain ways so as to craft the perception of the reader.  I firmly believe we need mainstream media, alternative media, independent writers, the casual bloggers, forums etc to present a more holistic view. Putting trust in mainstream media is surely a grave mistake.

Nowadays, alternative media also carries Bernama news. And, government can choose to publish their advertorials, scholarship info, job vacancy info, tender info, statistics etc in alternative media, which will increase the “fact” quotient.

Not to forget, regardless of whichever media, we find cases of issuing apology for “misunderstanding” or “miscommunication” or for wrongful reporting. So, both groups can and do make mistakes.

BTW, for me mainstream media does not include the sorry excuse for a newspaper,  Utusan.

This is what mainstream media Star published (taken at 11.50pm):

The public should trust the mainstream media as it is fact-based, compared to the opinion-based alternative media, said Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak.

The Prime Minister said some of the articles published on the alternative media, such as websites and blogs, were “half truths and inaccurate”.

“The mainstream media has one strength which cannot be found in the alternative media, and that is the mainstream media can be considered fact-based.

“If we read the mainstream media, we intuitively regard it as an authoritative report, where its facts cannot be questioned,” he said at a breaking of fast ceremony at the New Straits Times Press headquarters here Thursday.

“There must be a discerning public who can see the strength of the mainstream media,” he added.

This is what alternative media Malaysian Insider published (taken at 11.50pm):

Datuk Seri Najib Razak told the public tonight to trust the mainstream media and not the alternative media which are based on half truths.

The Prime Minister said that mainstream media should be considered as an authoritative news source that can be trusted.

“In the development of the media today, the market is different from the market in previous years. Now we are faced with the alternative media which has been a direct competition to mainstream media like NST.

“However, the mainstream media has one strength which cannot be found in the alternative media and that is the mainstream media can be considered as fact based,” Najib (picture) said when attending breaking of fast with the media at The New Straits Times Press headquarters here.

He said that the mainstream media is different from alternative media because the former is fact based while the later is opinionated.

“If we read the mainstream media, intuitively we regard it as an authoritative report where its facts cannot be questioned.

“Its principles are based on facts and this is different from blogs and websites which can be developed for personal use and can literally become a one-man show,” he said.

He added that alternative media published reports based on opinions which are “half truths and not accurate”.

Recently a poll by the Merdeka Center showed that six out of 10 Malaysians don’t trust the mainstream media.

The June 27 to July 25 survey commissioned by a research organisation showed that 57 per cent of Malays polled said they did not trust reports in the mainstream media, while 33 per cent trusted the media and 10 per cent said they did not know.

As for the Chinese community, 58 per cent said they did not trust the mainstream media, 30 per cent trusted and 12 per cent did not know.

A total 590 Chinese and 413 Malays as well as five focus group discussions with Chinese voters in Peninsula Malaysia were involved in the survey.

The findings will provide sober reading for many mainstream media organisations. Recent circulation figures show that English and Malay-language newspapers like New Straits Times, The Star, Berita Harian and Utusan Malaysia have all suffered significant drop in circulation this year compared to 2009, with some as severe as 20 per cent.

Privately, newspaper executives note that partisan political coverage has hurt sales.

Comments from the focus group discussions also showed that many felt that there is limited media freedom in the country because of the practice of censorship.

Some participants in the focus groups also pointed out that Malay-language newspapers were the most biased.

Najib stressed that the public must be able to differentiate between mainstream and alternative media reporting.

“The public must be discerning and can differentiate between the strength of the mainstream media, which has a place in the era of ICT and access to website and blogs which are opinion based.

“I urge the mainstream media to continue to hold its principle as a paper based on factual based reporting with opinion which are constructive and educated,” he said.

Bell Club in Johor transfered RM60k

/* August 31st, 2010 by poobalan | View blog reactions 2 comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Johor MIC seems to be in headline again. Just few weeks ago it was a division head who was convicted of corruption. Now is an “individual linked to MIC” – whatever that means.

Anyway, investigation only, doesn’t mean got any wrongdoing right? Maybe some simple case of miscommunication or misunderstanding of procedures. But, RM60,000 is lot of money.

The Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) is investigating allegations that an allocation given to an Indian non-governmental organisation had been transferred into a politician’s bank account.

It was learnt that the MACC had already begun recording statements from individuals and politicians in connection with the RM60,000 allocation to a Bell club in the state.

Johor MACC chief Simi Abdul Ghani confirmed that they were investigating the case but declined to disclose any details.

It was learnt that the probe started after the Johor Bell Club committee initiated its own investigation into one of its branches for receiving the allocation from the state government and then allegedly channelling a large part of it into the account of an individual linked to the MIC, keeping only a token sum for itself. The matter surfaced recently when the RM60,000 allocation to the branch in question was published in an MIC booklet.

Since then, questions have been asked as to why such a large sum was given to a small branch instead of the state committee to be distributed to all the clubs in the state.

This prompted the state Bell Club to call for an emergency meeting, its president G. Ganesh said.

“We view this matter seriously and want the branch chairman to explain as there are many rumours circulating.”

Ganesh said it was wrong to use the club’s accounts to get money and then use it for other purposes.

“We also do not know how they got such a huge allocation or who helped to source for the cash.”

Asked whether action would be taken against the chairman, Ganesh said they first had to decide whether to refer him to the disciplinary committee.

As for previous allocations from the Government, he said Johor Mentri Besar Datuk Abdul Ghani Othman had given RM150,000 to the state Bell Club to pay off a bank loan for a building in Kluang last year.

“That was the only allocation we received from the state government,” he said, adding that presently there were about 26 active Bell clubs with about 5,000 members state-wide.

Mother Mangalam

/* August 31st, 2010 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Article about Mother Mangalam, one of the recipient of Merdeka Award for 2010. From the Star.

At 84, Mother Mangalam is still busy solving problems and helping the less fortunate. Sunday Star catches up with the recipient of this year’s Merdeka Award in the education and community category and finds out what makes her so unique.

DATIN Paduka Mother A. Mangalam is totally surprised at being named as one of the recipients for this year’s Merdeka Award.

“I never expected this. Why me, of all people?” asks the 84-year-old who is shy of publicity of any kind.

As president and co-founder of the Pure Life Society (PLS), which provides shelter for needy children, Mother Mangalam has selflessly dedicated her life to the welfare of the less fortunate. With her faith in God and a never-give-up attitude, she has helped to provide a better life for the 2,000 children who have passed through the home.

Mother Mangalam: ‘People give love for many reasons, but he (Swami Satyananda) told me that true love is simply given for the sake of love, and not to ask for anything back.’

Although a teacher by profession, Mother Mangalam has always been a spiritual person, and she cites her father as well as founder-president of the PLS Swami Satyananda, whom she considers her spiritual mentor, as the two people who have influenced her the most.

“I was born into a Hindu family, but my father was a practising Catholic. On Sundays, he used to take me out marketing, and we would go to church too.”

She remembers the first prayer he taught her when she was seven.

“It went, ‘Oh my god, give me the true love of thee.’

“People give love for many reasons, but he told me that true love is simply given for the sake of love, and not to ask for anything back. That idea has stuck with me.”

She met Swami Satyananda when she was nine and recalls how, at one point (soon after World War II), she wanted to go to India to join a nunnery. But the Swami advised her against it.

“He reminded me that I was the eldest in my family of seven, and that I had to help my brother and sisters who had been affected by the war. He told me I must obtain my parents’ blessings before going into religious life.”

The war, she recalls, also had a great impact on the way she approached life.

“It put me into deep thought, and I used to reflect a lot about life and death during that time. Life was full of difficulties – poverty was all around and people barely had food to eat. Death was everywhere.”

It was then that she resolved not to marry and have children, as she felt that there were so many others who needed her help.

In the years after the war, many orphans came into the care of Swami Satyananda, and he used to place them with families.

“I used to go around with Swami and we would visit children whom he had left with associates.

“During those visits, it was so sad to see the children’s faces – they were very withdrawn and inexpressive. Furthermore, some foster parents would complain about the child right in front of them, and that hurt me a lot.”

After a visit one day, she blurted to Swami that they should start a home for them.

“He asked me who would look after them, and I remained silent. I had parents to look after, and to get away (from her responsibilities) was not easy.”

But the thought must have been working in his mind, and one day he asked not to be disturbed for three days and nights.

“He did not say why but after three days, he opened his door and said: ‘I have got the green light. How are you people going to help me?’”

That led to the PLS being set up and officially registered on July 15, 1952.

But it was also the start of more trials and tribulations.

“Funds were hard to come by and we used to live on porridge every night. We found it very difficult to get milk. I used to practically beg for milk from Nestlé and Dutch Baby (now Dutch Lady) and we would mix the two for taste.”

Despite all the difficulties she had to face, Mother Mangalam remained confident because of her belief that God would always provide.

“I never lost or gave up hope. Miracles happen all the time and the divine power is ever present.”

She recalls another time in the 1970s when her life was in turmoil – torn between her work and her own family’s needs.

She was the head of a school and also heading the PLS. Conditions at the home then were very cramped.

“We started getting many anonymous letters which were highly critical of the home – saying that the children were packed in like livestock.

“At the same time, I had my sisters to take care of. My brother had lost his job and they all turned to me. So I had to hold on to the school job.”

The pressure on her was overwhelming and one day, she broke down in tears and prayed for one of the burdens to be lifted from her shoulders.

“Two weeks later, my mother called me and said my father had won a RM400,000 lottery!”

She says the windfall allowed her to take optional retirement and concentrate on her work at the PLS.

So what keeps her going at an age when most people would have been retired for 30 years?

“Look at the needs of the nation – when I read the newspapers I get so involved in the problems. Why do religions rise up against each other, or try to dominate another? This all means people are not thinking in the right way. We are all of one God, of one Mother Earth, and there is only one race – the human race. People are made to look different, like the different flowers on earth, to make life interesting.”

To many, Mother Mangalam is synonymous with the PLS, a perception she has no control over.

“I’ve been in it from the beginning and people see Pure Life Society written all over me. I wouldn’t encourage this, and I feel odd when people say it.

“The society is the product of the many hands that have served through thick and thin – especially the staff. This type of work will go on.

“I’m still looking for someone who will be able to carry on the work. This was started after prayer and meditation, and it is all God’s will.”

And you should read this article on how Dr Amir Farid describes Mother Mangalam:

A NATIONAL treasure! This is how Dr Amir Farid Isahak, chairman of the Interfaith Spiritual Fellowship (INSaF), describes Mother Manga lam whom he first met 11 years ago.

He says there is much wisdom the 84-year-old Pure Life Society (PLS) president can impart to the people.

“Malaysians should know more of her. I think more communities outside of the PLS should hear her message of oneness of religious purpose, tolerance and understanding.”

Their acquaintance, he relates, was not by chance.

They met in 1999, on the eve of Prophet Muhammad’s birthday. Prior to that, he had only heard of her but never met her personally.

“During prayer time, I asked God if he had any instructions for me. When I finished, and returned to the hall, Mother Mangalam approached me and said she wanted me to lead INSaF, the inter-faith programme of the Pure Life Society.

“So mentally, I said to God ‘Instruction received’, and have been chairing it ever since.”

He explains that the PLS was set up as a multi-faith spiritual organisation.

“INSaF is a gathering of spiritually-inclined people of all faiths, including representatives of the major religions. Mother is our adviser and provides us much spiritual advice, guidance and motherly love. She reminds us of the need to be loving and caring in our everyday life, and to be God-conscious at every moment – and she recites beautiful prayers and poems!”

Dr Amir says Mother Mangalam respects the spiritual essence of all religions, that God is one but understood differently by different religions.

“The message of oneness, respect and learning from each other is an important message. This can help bring down barriers, and foster stronger bonds of friendship and understanding – this should be shared with all Malaysians.”

Dr Amir has a strong affinity and fondness for Mother Mangalam, and says she treats him like a son, which he reciprocates.

“She is a pillar of patience and wisdom. She is strong-willed and determined, but rarely shows her anger whenever something upsets her. She is always composed, and in that way her thoughts and decisions are never clouded by emotions.”

He says that he tries to follow her lead.

“She has taught me to be patient, and to be disciplined in all aspects of life. What I have yet to try to emulate is never to be angry!”

Shelter Home for Children executive director James Nayagam, who has known Mother Mangalam for more than 30 years, says she is thoroughly deserving of the Merdeka Award.

“We can see how the Pure Life Society has progressed under her leadership.

“It requires dedication and commitment to face the challenges, and she has been there throughout. She has dedicated herself to providing children a safe and wholesome place to stay,” he adds.

Nayagam feels that the dedication Mother Mangalam displays is lacking in the young. She can be a role model to many who want to take up social work, he says.

“Time and age has not been an issue for her, and she looks upon it as a service to the country, and that is why she is recognised.”

Nayagam remembers meeting her when he was 25, and he asked her how she could manage such a difficult job.

“She told me that one must always be in control, and that stuck in my mind.

“You cannot find another Mother Manga lam – she has her own unique appearance, character and personality. She is one of a kind.”

Many ways to skin a cat, Namewee

/* August 31st, 2010 by poobalan | View blog reactions 1 comment »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I think using foul language is a cheap way of getting your point across. Puts you in same level as some politicians.

If you can’t figure out a better way and insist on calling it work of art or form of communication or whatever, well, sorry then, I’m not in the list of “public” that stand behind you. More likely, I’m in the list that is against you for being a negative influence for our children and youths.

Wee said he grew up with friends of various races and that was why he was angered by a few “black sheep” in the education system who did not respect Malaysia as a multiracial country with religious freedom.

“My main reason for uploading the new video was to stand up against racism,” he said, adding that he used obscene language as a form of communication and did not intend it to offend anyone.

Well, if people are offended (And I think you knew people would be), is it wrong for them to make police report? I guess not. Two wrongs doesn’t make a right here.

If allow people to use foul language so freely in the name of freedom of expression, work of art,  or pure stupidity, then something must be wrong here.

Anyway, you must be doing well as an artist, meaning you have your own brand of followers. Says here you have your own BMW.  It may earn you good buck, large following, and popularity, but to me, its a sad state of affairs.

Indian becomes UM deputy VC

/* August 31st, 2010 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


53 years! That long to see an Indian become a Deputy Vice Chancellor.  Took 51 years to get Deputy Chief Minister. Can I say thank you HINDRAF (in one way or another)?

I guess another 50 years to see one become a Vice Chancellor.

Congrats Prof Dr Kurunathan!

Prof Dr Kurunathan Ratnavelu has been appointed as University of Malaya Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Development) for three years effective Sept 1.

Prof Kurunathan succeeds Prof Datuk Dr Khaw Lake Tee whose term ends Tuesday, UM said in a statement Monday.

An expert in “theoretical collision processes” with specific interest in positron collisions with atoms, Prof Kurunathan obtained his Bachelor of Science (First Class Hons) and his Master of Science by research from the Department of Mathematics, University of Malaya, and furthered his PhD study in Atomic Physics at Flinders University, Australia.

He started off as a lecturer at the UM in 1989 and was promoted to Associate Professor in 1994 and subsequently made Professor in 2001.