Posts Tagged ‘Hindraf’

Action against HINDRAF under Societies Act

October 9th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


After Home Minister Syed Hamid started the ball rolling by labeling Hindraf visit to Hari Raya open house as “very threatening“, Deputy Home Minister added that government will take action using the Societies Act 1966.

Funny thing is, Syed Hamid said that the Government would study public feedback on the matter before responding to calls for the Hindu Rights Action Force to be banned. He claimed that the action during the open house could easily have become a danger to public order if the situation had erupted or if one of the members had been carrying something dangerous.

“Security cannot be taken for granted and we are worried about the prospect of other open houses being ambushed in this way.

“We are getting feedback before we decide on the next course of action,” Syed Hamid told The Star.

He declined to reveal what measures, if any, would be taken against the group or how long the Government would collect such feedback.

Syed Hamid, however, pointed out that the Government’s decision would not rest solely on the latest incident, but would encompass all that had transpired in the past with Hindraf.

“We can’t just react to one incident or action and there is no such thing as Hindraf as it is an unlawful society. It is not registered,” he said.

Actually there is something called HINDRAF. If not why are few people upset over nothing? There are many loose entities, like Aman Malaysia for example. Its just a feeling of affiliation.

I agree with this, but for the matter, anyone who visited the open house could have been an assassin, mentally disturbed or depressed, thus its highly likely that future open houses are installed with metal detectors, bomb squads, and also body checks being conducted. Forget Hindraf, you’ll never know when a demented person does something stupid. I remember reading that statistically every one in three person are mentally affected one way or another, which means potentially 8 million Malaysians can do something illogical, stupid, dangerous, and careless. But even if all Indians are HINDRAF supporters, that’s only 1.8 million people. So, whether HINDRAF attended or not, security was lax at the venue. Perhaps the police want to cover up their weakness?

Deputy Home Minister, Senator Datuk Wan Ahmad Farid Wan Salleh, said the government will take action against the Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf) under the Societies Act 1966 for causing a disturbance during the Hari Raya function hosted by the Prime Minister and Muslim Cabinet ministers at the Putra World Trade Centre in Kuala Lumpur last Wednesday.

He said action would be taken soon on Hindraf, its committee, and members, even though the organisation was not registered.

“Action will be taken. We have many alternatives. Under the Act, whether the organisation is legal or not, it is still an organisation. If it is not legal, action will be taken based on the provisions for an illegal organisation, unless if it is legal then action will be taken under the proper provisions,” he said.

Wan Ahmad Farid said this when asked to comment on calls by several quarters that action be taken against Hindraf for their ’rudeness’ at the function on the first day of Hari Raya.

Wan Ahmad Farid said the government through the Home Ministry would not hesitate to take action against an illegal organisation as it had to follow the law.
“When it comes to the law, there must be no delay. Whatever action taken has to follow procedure and legal channels. What is clear in this matter is that whoever breaks the law must face action,” he said.

Wan Farid Ahmad, however, declined to state what action will be taken aginst Hindraf.

He said when action is taken, Hindraf cannot blame the government, or allege that it had not been given opportunity to voice its views.

I’m a bit lost here. When was HINDRAF given opportunity to air its views? Was it on TV because I missed it. However, if its leaders are taken into custody (fines won’t work), we are looking at 30-odd people being arrested. And definitely stronger support for HINDRAF.

HINDRAF condemns Utusan

October 9th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


After making police reports and voicing their plans to sue Utusan, Hindraf also vented their unhappiness over the paper’s continuing condemnation of HINDRAF, claiming that its politically motivated. I this is unavoidable because the paper is owned by a political party, so surely there will be an element of selective reporting.

Utusan Malaysia today front-paged calls for action against Hindraf supporters who were allegedly unruly at the ministerial Hari Raya ‘open house’ last Wednesday at the Putra World Trade Centre in Kuala Lumpur.

The report entitled ‘Tegas tangani Hindraf’ (Deal firmly with Hindraf) quoted several individuals who called on the government to take action.

Reacting to this, Thanenthiran said: “Umno elections are around the corner. Now, they are condemning Hindraf to get Malay support…(Utusan) is trying to please its political owners.”

He claimed that the daily did not present a true picture of what transpired at the event and did not contacted Hindraf representatives for clarification either.

Another coordinator, Jayathas said that photographs of the even available on HINDRAF website is enough to show what happened on that day. But I think, there must be independent evidence as well.

“They should go to our website and see the photos. These show very clearly that everything was done in a peaceful way. It is not our culture to create havoc in other people’s house,” he said.

On suggestions in the Utusan report that Hindraf was being rude to the Malays and Islam, Jayathas said it was a non-issue because the movement merely used the opportunity to ask Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi to repeal the Internal Security Act (ISA).

“How can they say that we are racist? In what way? We are just asking for the ISA to be abolished,” he said.

Hindraf’s legal advisor, lawyer Surendran said it was the police who acted unruly that day.

“They were intimidating and threatening to arrest people who came to participate in the ‘open house’. They (initially) prevented the Hindraf supporters from entering the venue.

“One even asked P Waythamoothy’s (Hindraf chairperson-in-exile) wife to remove her t-shirt (which carried a Hindraf logo),” he said.

Surendran said Hindraf has become the victim of a harsh campaign to incite hatred against the movement and Indian Malaysians.

“They creating something out of absolutely nothing. Absolutely nothing violent happen during ‘open house’ (at) an open venue. Nothing wrong with that in a democracy,” he said.

On Home Ministry secretary-general Abdul Aziz Mohd Yusof’s suggestion that Hindraf be ‘banned’, Surendran said that the statement was “absurd” and without justification.

“(Hindraf) is not a terrorist or armed movement. It is a mass movement of citizens calling for social improvement – not just for Indians, but all marginalised communities,” he added.

Although Hindraf is not a registered body, Surendran argued that the movement exists by virtue of Article 10 of the Federal Constitution which guarantees the right to freedom of association.

Hindraf denies PM accusation

October 7th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Hindraf national co-ordinator Kannan Ramasamy today denied the accusation by PM Badawi that only one person wished him festive greetings.

“We went there in peace and there are no photographs or video footage showing us being unruly,” said Kannan.

He said he knew many Hindraf supporters attending the open house had extended Raya greetings to Abdullah.

“I am surprised the Prime Minister was not aware of this.”

UMNO Youth Selangor wants HINDRAF punished

October 7th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Well, this fellas who already run out of ideas are now jumping into the Hindraf-bashing bandwagon. They are pressuring Home Minister to take action against HINDRAF over the Hari Raya open house visit. The chief, Abdul Shukor also tries to link the action with insult to Islam, another attempt to create uneasiness.

“I hope the Home Ministry will not be frightened to take action against them,” said its chief, Abdul Shukor Idrus.

Abdul
Shukor said the Hindraf supporters’ action at the open house went
against the principles of a multiracial country and society.

“What they did was akin to insulting Islam and stern action must be taken against them.”

HINDRAF lodges police report against Home Minister and Utusan

October 7th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


This is a good move from HINDRAF. They should make police report if they believe in the actions. Home Minister Syed Hamid, Utusan and its columnists, plus few other NGO leaders were issuing statements that seemed off tangent and diverting the issue into something else. Not one, but many police reports were lodged throughout the country by HINDRAF members. According to Malaysiakini, Hindraf national coordinator RS Thanenthiran, 46, who lodged the first police report this afternoon, said the movement wanted police to take action on the home minister, Utusan and the NGOs for wrongfully accusing the human rights group of “creating chaos and insulting Islam” during the open house in Putra World Trade Centre, Kuala Lumpur.

“They should be charged under the Sedition Act for inciting communal hatred and instigating racial conflict and under the Penal Code for criminal intimidation by issuing threats to racial harmony,” said Thanenthiran (photo, left), who with Nibong Tebal Hindraf coordinator Sanjeeviramah Subramani, 42, lodged the report in Butterworth police station at 12.50pm.

That report was followed by a series of others lodged by Hindraf leaders and activists in George Town, Nibong Tebal, Simpang Empat, Shah Alam, Petaling Jaya, Klang, Alor Star, Sungai Petani, Jitra, Kulim, Lunas, Ipoh, Bagan Serai, Air Tawar, Parit Buntar, Taiping, Teluk Intan, Sitiawan, Muar, Tangkak, Skudai, Kluang and Johor Bahru. Reports were also lodged this evening in Kuala Lumpur, Kuala Terengganu, Seremban, Malacca and Tanah Merah.

Earlier, HINDRAF said it was planning to sue the same group of people. Now the quantum of claim may be set as high as RM100 million it says.

The movement plans go ahead with a civil suit against the newspaper and home minister and if warranted against the NGOs as well.

Thanenthiran told reporters that Hindraf had decided to raise the quantum of its claims from RM1 million ringgit to perhaps even as high as RM100 million. The movement is now discussing the matter with its lawyers and will file the suits soon.

Last Friday, Utusan had front paged its report with the headline – ‘Hindraf Keterlaluan’ (Extreme Hindraf). Two more articles – Baharom Mahusin’s commentary in his ‘Cetusan’ column and Zulkifli Bakar’s commentary in his ‘Pada Hemat Saya’ column – published in the same edition were unfair and intimidating, alleged Thanenthiran.

“The reports and criticisms were inciting racial hatred and instigating communal conflict. The reports suggested that we trespassed the function when in truth, we were invited,” said Thanenthiran.

“The function was not held in a mosque not a buka puasa event. It was organised in a common public building with an open invitation to all Malayians. Suddenly open houses during festive seasons were given new definitions, thanks to Syed Hamid and Utusan,” he added.

The Hindraf leader also alleged this was not first time the Malay daily had played up communal hatred and conflict against various organisations and individuals in the country.

Thanenthiran also challenged Syed Hamid, Utusan and the NGOs to speak the truth and apologise to the movement for “distorting facts and lying to the public.”