Posts Tagged ‘Marginalisation’

Attempted murder charge for Hindraf protestors

December 4th, 2007
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


This is like giving more "bullets" for Hindraf to gain support/sympathy.

 

This is quite funny – "They threw bricks at his head. Do you think it will not cause death?" .

Possibly the visitors to the temple were wearing night vision goggles and infrared telescopes to pinpointly aim at the someone's head. Is it more likely the head came in the way of the brick?

Of course, the head being on top of a body will be hit by any object thrown hit into the air – imagine spitting into the air or watching a quarterback hurl the ball in american football. The gates are quite tall, so undoubtedly a brick can't come at a lower projectile angle.

Maybe the accused can be given royal pardon and absorbed into rugby teams.

Btw, I'm curious if the same charges be leveled at FRU officers who shot tear gas canisters into the crowd causing injuries? Maybe a case can be made saying the shots should be fired at a "safe" area near to the crowd, instead of firing at the crowd itself.

I'm getting more and more confused…….

Attempted murder charge for Hindraf protestors
http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/75637

Beh Lih Yi
Dec 4, 07 3:07pm

Twenty-six Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf) supporters were charged with attempted murder and causing damage to public property during the mass rally in Kuala Lumpur on Nov 25.

Contacted by Malaysiakini, their lawyers said the men were charged before judge Azimah Omar at the Shah Alam Sessions Court this afternoon.

Attorney-General Abdul Gani Patail said the alleged victim was a policeman who received stitches to his head after protesters threw iron pipes and bricks, and that if convicted, the accused faced up to 20 years in jail.

"They threw bricks at his head. Do you think it will not cause death?" he told AFP.

Out of the 26, 15 were earlier  charged at the Selayang Sessions Court last week for allegedly taking part in an illegal gathering under Section 27 of the Police Act and Section 141 of the Penal Code. They were subsequently released on bail. 

Today, they were slapped with additional charges under Section 307 of the Penal Code for alleged attempted murder and causing mischief while taking part in an unlawful assembly or riot under Section 440 of the same code.

The remaining 11, who were in the dock for the first time, faced all four charges like the rest.

“The protesters were alleged to have caused damages to some of the properties at the Batu Caves temple, including the front gates and cars,” said lawyer Rajpal Singh from the legal team representing the accused.

In the early hours of the banned Nov 25 Hindraf rally, a crowd of 3,000 – mostly from neighbouring states – had gathered inside the Batu Caves compound to spend the night. 

Police used tear gas and water cannon to disperse the crowd and 69 people were arrested although 43 were let off with a warning.

‘Victimisation continues’

According to Rajpal, who is also the Selangor Bar’s legal aid centre chairperson, attorney-general Abdul Gani who personally appeared for the prosecution objected to granting bail to the accused.

The court has yet to make a decision on this as the case was adjourned to tomorrow morning to allow Abdul Gani to make the submission, said another defence lawyer M Manoharan.

“The group will be remanded until tomorrow morning,” he added.

Manoharan – who is also a key leader in Hindraf – said the latest development showed that the alleged “victimisation and prosecution against Malaysian Indians has started again”.

Under Section 307 of the Penal Code, the accused, upon conviction, are liable to a maximum of 20 years jail if hurt is caused. While under Section 440, they could face up to five years’ jail and a fine.

They are also liable to a jail sentence of up to a year and maximum RM10,000 fine for the illegal gathering charge.

About 30,000 people took to the streets of Kuala Lumpur on Nov 25 to protest against the marginalisation of Indian Malaysians.

Many of those who were dispersed in Batu Caves earlier that morning marched all the way to town to join the rally.

The police, which had denied a permit for the rally, used tear gas and water cannons to disperse the crowd.

In an immediate reaction, Opposition Leader Lim Kit Siang said the attempted murder charge was "shocking" and a surprise.

"All efforts should be channelled at de-escalating the atmosphere. But the reverse seems to be happening," he said, referring to the turmoil that has worsened Malaysia's already tense race relations.

N Ravi, a member of the defence legal team, said the accused, aged between 19 and 46, would fight the allegations and other charges levelled against them including rioting, illegal assembly and causing damage to public property.

"We can raise reasonable doubt against the charges," he said, adding that the 26 were being detained in Pudu jail in downtown Kuala Lumpur.

Bersih group fails to turn up

In an unrelated development, 10 protestors at the Nov 10 rally organised by polls reform group Bersih who were expected to be charged today did not show up in court.

According to their lawyer Zulqarnain Lukman, the 10 were told earlier to report back to the police station on Dec 10 and this was stated in their bail.

However, a police officer called them on Sunday and told them to come to the police station today as they could be charged for illegal gathering at the Kuala Lumpur Magistrate’s Court.

“The group decided not to go since they were informally informed and they will stick to Dec 10 to report to the police station,” said Zulqarnain.

form cabinet task force to aid Indians

December 4th, 2007
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


the indian community at large worry about temple, tamil schools, housing/land/TOL, govt jobs, IC/birth cert/marriage registration, minimum wage, microcredit loans, harrassment from authorities, free/cheap/reliable medical services, removal of gangs/thugs, removal of samsu shops, and education opportunities.

those in middle class and above have slightly different set of worries. their worries will be on employment, housing, business opportunities, crime rate, toll rate, petrol price, civil rights, migration, transportation problems, local council performance, children education, peace, etc.

Form Cabinet task force to aid Indians
http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/75622

Dec 4, 07 1:53pm

Parliamentary Opposition leader Lim Kit Siang today urged the government to establish a Cabinet Task Force to find solutions to end the marginalisation of Indians and other groups in the country.

He said the task force should be headed by Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi and should focus on:

• Conversion of all partially-aided Tamil primary schools into fully-aided schools

• RM500 million allocation to upgrade Tamil primary schools

• Stop demolition of Hindu temples and other places of worship nationwide.

Lim said his proposal was in view of a 30,000-strong “cry of desperation” by those who attended the Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf) rally on Nov 25.

“The Cabinet should end the denial about the marginalisation of Indians in Malaysia and come out with a new policy for a new deal to end the marginalisation of Indians and all marginalised groups in Malaysia,” he added in a statement.

Lim stressed that the Cabinet and MIC president S Samy Vellu cannot deny that Indians have been marginalised over the last three decades.

As an example, he pointed out that before the New Economic Policy was implemented in 1971, the civil service comprised of 17.4 percent Indians. This figure shrank to 5.12 percent in 2005. 

MIC's 'disservice' 

Since the Hindraf rally, Abdullah, Samy and other Cabinet ministers have on a near daily basis denied Hindraf’s charge that the Indian community is marginalised.

Meanwhile, Lim also accused MIC of doing a “disservice” by not properly informing Abdullah about the plight of the Indian community.

“Abdullah said he has ‘big ears’ and is prepared to hear the truth. It is shocking that nobody in the MIC leadership… is prepared and has the courage to tell the prime minister the truth.

“For decades, the Indians have been marginalised politically, economically, socially, educationally, culturally and religiously, reducing them into a new underclass,” he said.

Lim said these were the reasons why 30,000 Indians from all over the country rallied behind Hindraf.

However, he disagreed with Hindraf’s claim that the Indians are victims of a state-sanctioned ethnic cleansing.

GCC condemns PM

December 3rd, 2007
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


PM ticked off for attack on Hindraf
http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/75591
Yoges Palaniappan
Dec 3, 07 4:38pm
The Group of Concerned Citizens (GCC) has lashed out at premier Abdullah Ahmad Badawi for castigating the Hindu Rights Action Force over its claims that Indian Malaysians are being mistreated. 

At a press conference in the Parliament lobby today, an emotional GCC coordinator K Arumugam questioned Abdullah’s stance in relation to “angry and hungry Indians”.

“This is a ridiculous statement for a PM to make. He must use his ‘big ears’ and walk through the streets to look at the poor – be they Indian, Chinese or Malay – and listen to them,” he said in response to Abdullah’s statement that he has big ears and hears everything.

“This country has a major problem. When we organised a meeting in 1999, there were 3,000 people. In 2007, it turned to be 30,000 people. Do want to see 300,000 people in five years time?"

He said the government must examine the impact of poverty, as it has divided the nation along racial and religious lines. 

Arumugam also clarified that it is not the GCC’s intention to bad-mouth the MIC, as there is agreement with president S Samy Vellu's claims that the party has done a lot for the community.

However, he said that MIC, as a race-based party, will not be able to find solutions for the community’s depressed situation.

"MIC cannot and will never solve the problems. If policy makers are serious about resolving the marginalisation, they have to revamp policies," he said.

He said the MIC is not in the position to "shift even a sen into the pockets of Indians”.

“MIC has to beg and promise 101 things to the government to ensure that the votes of the Indians can be garnered and presented on a silver platter, in order to even get a seat to contest in any election. That is the reality."

Where’s the will?

Another coordinator Charles Santiago said the government must reveal its political will in overcoming the marginalisation of the community.

He said this must start from the Prime Minister's Office, with the premier chairing a high-level task force to address issues pertaining to poverty within the community.

"The problem must not be left to be addressed by MIC alone," he said, referring to the hotline set up by the Barisan Nasional component party, following the PM's request for advice on the community’s problems. 

"The people who attended the Hindraf rally (on Nov 25) are poor and vulnerable. They need help. They are Malaysians to begin with, therefore we feel that responsibility must not be left to MIC. It is the responsibility of the government to respond. 

"The federal government has legal and moral obligations to solve the problem. It must solve the issues using its policies, mechanisms and programmes."

Santiago explained that Indians have had enough with being marginalised and want real action to address the matter.

He said the MIC initiative to set up a hotline is not the solution.

"The hotline will never resolve the deep structural and institutional problems that need to be undertaken to address the issues of Indian poverty," he noted.

Hindraf leaders apply to overturn restriction order

November 30th, 2007
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Hindraf leaders apply to overturn restriction order
http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/75485
Syed Jaymal Zahiid
Nov 29, 07 8:06pm

Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf) today filed an application for revision with the High Court to invalidate the restriction order issued on Nov 22 prohibiting them from handing over a memorandum to the British High Commission.

Seven days ago, the Magistrate's Court had, upon the application made by Cheras police chief Ahmad Amir Mohd Hashim, issued a seven-day restraining order that prohibits Hindraf leaders from handing over a memorandum to the British High Commission.

However, the restraining order did not deter Hindraf members and some 30,000 protesters from gathering at the British High Commission last Sunday to support a US$4 trillion class-action suit against the British government for bringing the Indians as "slaves" to this country.

M Manoharan, one of Hindraf's lawyer said the appeal made to the Kuala Lumpur Magistrate's Court was to ask for a hearing and to argue that the restraining order issued was done with ill-intentions and therefore should be invalidated.

Asked why Hindraf lawyers were still pursuing the matter as the order expired today, Hindraf legal advisor P Uthayakumar said the appeal was done as a matter of principle, adding that such an order is deemed to be an infringement of human rights.

Other arguments to invalidate the restraining order include:

  • The restraining order did not specify the exact location and address
  • The magistrate who issued the order had acted beyond his jurisdiction
  • The magistrate did not give any reasons as to why the restraining order was made ex-parte (which excluded consultation with those who were issued the restraining order)

IGP's statement legitimises rally

Meanwhile, Hindraf counsel Gobind Singh Deo when met at the court lobby said that a statement made by inspector-general of police Musa Hassan today clearly showed that the restraining order was unnecessary.

According to a New Straits Times report, Musa was quoted as saying that the police were ready to negotiate with Hindraf leaders at the Sunday rally and allowed them to proceed with handing over the memorandum but could not do so as no Hindraf leaders were sighted.

The statement made by Musa was made in the context of government officials' allegations that the rally was not really intended to express the grievances of the Indian community but merely served as a means to fulfil the ulterior motives of Hindraf leaders.

"If Musa said he would negotiate with Hindraf leaders, what does that say? To me, it means that Musa had recognised the rights of the protesters to be there," Gobind reasoned..

Following Sunday's rally, more than 100 people were arrested and charged yesterday for illegal assembly though many have been released on bail.

Government leaders had accused the rally as being racially motivated but the organisers had argued that the rally was a reflection of the marginalisation suffered by the Indian community.

malaysia better off than india and no protest from other indians says minister

November 28th, 2007
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I'm not clear on why are they comparing our country with India. I mean comparing a country with 1 billion over people who have got independence 10 years before a country with 27++million people doesn't make much sense.

Also, looks like the global indians out of Malaysia have not complained to our govt over the attack on protesters. Maybe the need some help finding their emails and addresses. best place to try would be:

www.gov.my
www.parlimen.gov.my
www.umno.org.my
www.mic.org.my
www.mca.org.my
http://www.pmo.gov.my/

Opposition behind Hindraf rally
http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/75412

Yoges Palaniappan
Nov 28, 07 6:22pm

The opposition had instigated the people to demonstrate to create the impression that the public is angry with the government, the Dewan Rakyat was told today.

"The opposition know that they would not win the coming elections. So they have resorted to create such an atmosphere," said parliamentary secretary to the Foreign Ministry Ahmad Shabery Cheek

He explained that the government had not received protest notes from other countries over the claim that the Indians here have been marginalised.

He was replying a supplementary query from Lim Kit Siang (DAP-Ipoh Timor) who asked Ahmad Shabery whether the government had received protests from Indians residing in other countries over the marginalisation of Indians in Malaysia.

Shabery said the living conditions in Malaysia is better than India and quoted a report from the United Nations (UN) in 2006 which stated that one-third of the problems in the world are faced by India.

"With so many immigrants from India flooding our country only goes to show that the situation in Malaysia is far better than India," he added.