Posts Tagged ‘Politicians’

Shah Alam temple photos, moratorium idea and temple building

October 26th, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


MalaysianIndian1 Blog has some pictures of the said altar/shrine/temple before it was demolished, while Human Rights Party website has the scanned photos from newspapers post-demolishment.

Looking at the photos, I noticed the deities seem to resemble those found in Chinese places of worship.

So, is a proper religious site or used for obtaining 4D numbers as claimed by MBSA? Does it really matter? Its on government land, so they have right to demolish structure.  But is this considered temple, shrine or altar?

Very confusing. Anyway, MIC Youth wing advisor Vell Paari opined that a moratorium is placed on all Hindu temple demolitions until an amicable solution is reached on the status of these temples in the country. He said a  3 to 5 year period is needed for a “all-party” committee include stakeholders from state governments, political parties, civil societies, religious bodies, and temples,  to establish proper guidelines on Hindu temples. He further mentioned that till a proper guideline enforced with political will is established, temple demolishment issues will be used by political parties as part of the blame game, and the worshippers are the ones who suffer in the end.

I think it comes back to the culture. The Indians are known to be temple builders since thousands of years ago. Life practically evolved around temples if one observes cities in India, especially in southern states.  Things have changed a bit in recent years, as more of them embrace modernity. The “educated” tend to spend less time involved in temples but focus more on economic concerns. The rest still depend a lot on divine interception.  An ant hill or tree trunk can be converted into a place of worship easily. The story in Mahabaratham – Eklavya who makes a clay figure of his guru and learns archery by himself, comes to mind. Even in housing areas, there are residents who build an altar at their car porch area and do prayers till wee hours of night.

Asking the Malaysian Indians to not simply built temples everywhere is one of the possible steps, but how about those places already in existence? MHS is doing study on temples at myhindutemples.com for starters. Do we need some sort of committee at national level? Or to be handled by each states accordingly? Would it be proper to establish one under PM Dept or Ministry of Unity, for example?

Is accepting the culture of the Indian community part of 1Malaysia (or whatever)? If we are to accept others as they are, with warts and all, it should be the same the other way around, no?

Another temple demolished in Shah Alam

October 23rd, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Facebook is quite active with the news of temple being demolished in Shah Alam yesterday. The temple, Mathurai Veeran Temple located at Persiaran Kerjaya, Jalan Glenmarie, Seksyen U1 in Shah Alam, was demolished by MBSA.

MIC was quick to condemn the demolition (OK, we can ignore their record for the moment):

MIC president Datuk Seri S. Samy Vellu said demolition of the Mathu-rai Veeran temple in Persiaran Kerjaya, Jalan Glenmarie, Seksyen U1 in Shah Alam was an “act of treachery” by the Pakatan Rakyat-led state government.

… Samy Vellu said the Mathurai Veeran temple committee had submitted an appeal to the February 2009 notice sent by the Shah Alam Municipal Council but the temple was still demolished without an alternative land being offered.

“There were also no discussion with the temple committee and no recent notices given by the council. They just went ahead and demolished it,” said Samy Vellu.

He wanted the Selangor Government, especially state executive councillor Dr. Xavier Jayakumar to explain the demolition, failing which the MIC would seek legal redress.

Samy Vellu goes on to point EXCO  Xavier Jayakumar to provide explanation:

Samy Vellu wanted the Selangor government, especially its state executive councilor Dr Xavier Jayakumar to explain the demolition, failing which MIC would seek legal redress.

“He (Xavier) does not seem to worry about what is happening. Perhaps this (the demolition) is being carried out because the Indians are not united under the Pakatan state government,” he said.

I too wonder how Samy Vellu knew that MBSA took “direct orders” from the Selangor government to demolish the temple. Who gave the orders? An individual? a committee? Selangor government here means the state secretariat, the EXCO or MB?

“I salute the MPSA for taking direct orders from the Selangor government without consulting the temple committee,” he added sarcastically.

Granted, current Selangor government did announce approval of land for temples time to time, but this is the second such demolishment happening. AFTER they have given their word that temples won’t be demolished without proper relocation. Remember Ampang Jaya? Well, search this blog for the related articles on that demolition.

Back then, MP Kapar Manikavasagam did some drama about quitting and all. There was even news about suspending high level officer in the MPAJ. I sent email to the committee on non-Muslim religious affair. But no news till now.

This time, MP Kapar also mentioned in his Facebook entry that those who did it should be sacked. So, who would it be? Some low-level MBSA enforcement officer? The head of enforcement division? MBSA chief? State secretary? Or ask the 3-man committee (Xavier, Ronnie, Teresa) to resign?

The temple demolished already. So, what’s next? Who going to foot the bill for relocation and reconstruction? Who is going to be demoted/suspended/fined/sacked? Who going to resign? Who will face legal action?

Should MBSA put a non-Muslim as the head to turn things around? Just wondering….

KPI for MIC branches

October 17th, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


MIC boss Samy Vellu announces two new initiatives. One is a KPI for all leaders, specifically for the branches, and secondly, leadership workshop for 150 division leaders. He also mentioned that new members can register online via MIC’s website. However, I can’t find the link to register online till today.

MIC will implement the Key Performance Index (KPI) on all its leaders, particularly its 3,600 branch chairpersons by early next year to gauge their performances, said party president S Samy Vellu today.

He said that although the KPI initiative was mooted several years ago, it could not be implemented, “but now it has become necessary to ensure the party is run more effectively, especially at the grassroots”.

Samy Vellu said the role of branch chairpersons was crucial as the party depended on them to implement its policies and programmes at the grassroots level.

“They branch chairpersons will be evaluated every three months,” he said in a statement.

He said the KPI would also apply to the party’s top leaders and elected representatives in stages.

“We want to know the extent of their contact with the people and how they are performing,” he said, adding that a monitoring team would be established at the MIC headquarters.

Samy Vellu also said the MIC would organise a leadership workshop for its nearly 150 party divisional leaders on Nov 15 this year followed by a series of meetings throughout the country with state and branch leaders.

“This time, we will also invite community leaders and non-governmental organisations in the meeting because they are our partners in social work,” he said.

He said the party embarked on a transformation process since the last general election starting with its rebranding exercise and followed by amendments to its constitution last month.

The amendments include limiting the term of party president and divisional leaders to just nine years or three terms and lowering the number of members before a branch can be set up, from 100 previously to 60.

Samy Vellu said new members could also register via online through the MIC portal and perhaps soon through SMS.

“We are making many changes and more will come in order to strengthen our party,” he added.

Samy still making roads

October 7th, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Looks like ex-Works Minister still involved in roads, I mean, making inroads! 🙂

The Malaysiakini article title blared – “Samy: MIC makes inroads in Bagan Pinang estates”

The article contained the usual stuff from Samy Vellu that we have heard in the past 4 or 5 by-elections. Not sure how this one will turn out. The food and fun is still there via a pre-Deepavali open house (pre-Deepavali???). The goodies still being promised.  Schools promised funds and hopefully land. Temples allocated land. Youths to apply job via Jobs Malaysia etc. Really good that there’s election in such rural areas, and the people can demand for many things. One can also wonder why nothing before this? 🙂 NS have been under the same rule for so many decades, with same Chief Minister for quite some time, and estates under GLC. Nothing much changed back then. So, can the people expect change now and immediate future? Are they willing to put their trust on new leader? Samy thinks they will.

MIC president S Samy Vellu said his party’s election machinery has managed to make significant inroads in estates located in Bagan Pinang, where a by-election will take place on Oct 11.

According to him, MIC wanted to ensure its pledge of delivering as many Indian votes to the Barisan Nasional.

He said since nomination day last Saturday, almost 1,000 party members, including from the Youth, Wanita, Puteri and Putera wings “literally camped” at the predominantly Indian populated estates.

“We have maintained our position in the estates even before nomination day and have assured the Indian voters (in the estates) that the government will continue to bring changes and progress to them,” he told reporters after concluding another day of six straight hours of campaigning in Bagan Pinang last night.

The Bagan Pinang state constituency, which is under the Teluk Kemang parliamentary constituency, has 20 percent or 2,834 Indian voters who are mostly concentrated in the four estates namely Bradwell, Atherthon, Siliau and Sua Betong.

Samy Vellu said his confidence of Indian voters’ support for the BN candidate Isa Samad would be further strengthened by Human Resources Minister and MIC vice-president Dr S Subramaniam’s scheduled announcement tomorrow on his (Subramaniam’s) meeting with officials of Sime Darby which owns the four estates.

Subramaniam had said that he would announce details of his discussions with the plantation giant last Monday on the solutions to many of the estate workers’ woes.

Samy Vellu who is leading the MIC charge in Bagan Pinang, admitted that Indian voters are not only concerned with developments but also wanted their rights to be protected by the government.

“We have held several discussions with the residents in the estates and they are happy with the initiatives being taken by our prime minister.

“They are very clear now. They know for a fact that the government has taken steps to bring progress to the Indian community and it can only continue if BN is given a stronger mandate,” he said.

Samy Vellu said other MIC leaders like deputy president G Palanivel and minister Subramaniam who have also been campaigning daily, managed to “break the barrier” with the Indian voters since the last general election where many of them had supported the PAS candidate.

“The environment and mood among the Indian voters is now different compared the last general election,” he said.

He said MIC expected a big turnout at the party’s Deepavali open house tomorrow (Thursday) at 8pm at the Sua Betong estate.

Deputy Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin would be among top BN leaders expected to attend the open house.

“The entire BN machinery has worked well and cooperated with each other in ensuring a victory for BN,” he added.

Indrani Samy Vellu interview

October 1st, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


This is exclusive interview by Malaysiakini with Samy Vellu’s wife Indrani. Very rare to get her interview on online or non-Tamil media. Let’s see what she says about the issues affecting her family now:

Since her husband’s defeat in the last general election, Indrani Samy Vellu has kept a low profile. But now, she feels compelled to voice her thoughts in the wake of the mounting criticisms against her husband of 49 years.

What hurt her most were the scathing remarks by former premier Dr Mahathir Mohamad, whom she considers to be almost like family. [lesson: there’s no permanent friends in politics]

In an exclusive interview with Malaysiakini yesterday, Indrani, 69, said it was not proper for Mahathir to state, among others, that in Japan, defeated leaders would have committed ‘harakiri’ (killed themselves).

He did not say it directly… but what if he (Samy Vellu) had taken it seriously. It may not affect my husband but such statements do leave an impact on our family,” she said.

Indrani also disagreed with Mahathir and others describing her husband as a liability for Barisan Nasional.

“He (Samy Vellu) lost his parliamentary seat (in Sungai Siput) once (in the last general election) because of certain events, including some who worked towards ensuring his defeat.

But he was not the only BN leader who lost… so why single him out?” she asked. [biasalah, need a scapegoat.]

Indrani, who repeatedly stressed that Mahathir is a great leader whom she and her husband admired, called on the former premier and other BN leaders to be more judicious in their criticism.

Why didn’t they say something sooner?

“He (Samy Vellu) is not saying that he will not step down as MIC president. He will step down when the time is right.

“Other coalition party members also suffered major losses, so it is not acceptable to say that BN’s failure is because of Samy Vellu alone,” she said during interview which was conducted in Tamil.

“The BN leaders are now saying that he has not done anything for the community but nobody seems to remember the years he sacrificed to bring upliftment to the community,” she said. [maybe too many years already, so cannot focus on the “many” achievements and “upliftments”!]

“Samy Vellu was not the only minister in the cabinet, there were other ministers and there was the prime minister… if they are saying now that he failed the community, why didn’t they say something sooner or reprimand him for lagging? [ something about outliving its purpose comes to mind]

He did all he can to help the people… but sometimes you have to help yourself too, he can’t be knocking on everyone’s door to give aid. All we can do is teach them how to fish and feed themselves, we cannot be spoon feeding them,” she added. [true indeed. but when others get spoon-fed, one tends to ask “why not me?”]

The mother of two also stressed that her husband was a man of his own making, who worked very hard to get to where he is today.

On the claim that Samy Vellu was grooming their son Vell Paari to enter politics, Indrani said that was up to her husband.

Breaking into laughter, she quipped that Samy Vellu, whom she described as being a temperamental person, never even gave her a single award.

“When I asked to be recommended for an honorary title, he asked me why do I need one and where do I plan to stick it (the badge),” she said.

“But then, is it wrong for Vell Paari to come into politics? The other politicians also groom their children to be leaders one day. [Yes of course. every one have the right to groom their children, especially to follow the footsteps]

“My husband knows that Vell Paari has the capability and my son does contribute to society without any publicity,” she added.

Vell Paari is not a cruel person

Meanwhile, Indrani was also asked about her son being implicated in the death of drama actress K Sujatha.

Frankly speaking I hardly knew her. But to say my son had forced the poison down her throat is ridiculous,” she said, adding that Vell Paari was incapable of such cruelty.

She recalled how her son had even balked at the idea of slaughtering a chicken to cook a meal at home, and this was one of the reasons why he opted to pursue architecture instead of medicine. [this is quite subjective and possibly irrelevant. desperate people can do desperate things. Anyway, inquest already ruled it was suicide, and any personal relationship between employer and employee may have not contributed to the suicide.]

“Her (Sujatha’s) own family members had testified that she committed suicide, if that was not the truth wouldn’t they fight for justice,” she asked.

Indrani also lashed out at PKR MP S Manikavasagam who had pursued the matter, saying that it was a political ploy to attack the father by using the son as a scapegoat.

She also took a Tamil daily to task for running reports on the Sujatha case by splashing photographs of the deceased.

It was wrong of them to disrespect the girl in that way. They could have run the stories without using her photos, but they chose to print all sorts of photos in order to attract readers,” she said. [morally not good, but newspaper will claim need to sell the paper la..wonder why the family never sue the papers]

Ex-MIED CEO gets a lashing

Indrani also defended her husband against the accusations by P Chithirakala Vasu, the former chief executive officer of MIC’s education arm MIED.

Last week, Chithirakala said that Samy Vellu will leave behind an ‘empty shell‘ for his chosen successor G Palanivel.

Commenting on this, Indrani sarcastically said that while she lauded Chithirakala’s concern for Palanivel’s future, the former MIED CEO should not forget that she was given the ‘Thirupathi Undiyal’ by her husband.

Thirupathi is a holy shrine in India, where the ‘undiyal’ or donation box is known for raking in millions of dollars.

He had given her the utmost respect and treated her like a daughter… But she now makes all these baseless allegations against him, the man who sponsored her education and gave her everything that she has today,” she said.

According to Indrani, Chithirakala left MIED some three years ago after expressing unhappiness with Samy Vellu.

Then she asked for her job back and despite my disapproval, he forgave her saying that she was a young girl who did not know better, and took her back.

“But look at how ungrateful she is, and now she makes all sorts of accusations against my husband,” she added.

Hmm…what can I say. Once in politics, have to brace for back-stabbing, scandals, political manoeuvring, gossips, challenging decision-making, ethics, morality. Never an easy job.