Archive for the ‘BornInMalaysia’ category

Have Astro no aid

April 23rd, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Actually, earlier the minister in charge mentioned that if a house has “facilities” like TV or sofa, they won’t be eligible for aid. So, what’s next? Having motorbike, car, telephone, PC, or handphone means you are rich? Are we trying to keep the poor in the dark ages instead of empowering them?

So imagine when you read something like the news below:

The words “disabled, Astro” and “aid” cannot occur in the same sentence, as far as the Welfare Department is concerned.

The department bars the disabled from getting welfare aid if they have Astro or a television set at home.

The rule applies even if one lives in someone else’s house, temporarily or otherwise.

S. Karupanan, 73, found this out the hard way three months ago when the department cut the RM200 aid to him as he was temporarily staying in a house which “had Astro service”.

The department had paid for surgery on one knee and promised to underwrite the cost of the operation on the other knee.

But while awaiting the second surgery, he moved into his daughter’s house and his troubles began.

Welfare officers who came to visit him saw red when they chanced upon the Astro connection and immediately withdrew the aid.

For K. Shanmugam, 51, who applied for welfare assistance in 2005 on becoming paralysed, it has been a string of “no’s” from the department for aid.

His mistake, he believes, was his honest reply when asked if he had a television set and Astro at home.

“That’s the first question they asked. When I said I had both, they immediately said that I was not eligible for assistance as there were others poorer than me.”

The former crane driver, who was earning RM2,000 in Singapore when a motorcycle accident four years ago left him paralysed, was baffled by the department’s decision.

He said that the bills of the family of six were paid by relatives who realised that he only had Astro to keep him company when the children were out of the house.

“I cannot work. The only pleasure in my life now is the Astro service,” he said.

Another extreme case is that of a a disabled 40-year-old, paralysed from the neck downwards, who lives with her partly-paralysed mother.

The disabled woman, who declined to be identified, decided against applying for an Astro connection after being warned by a welfare officer that they would cut aid to them if she did so.

What she cannot understand is why they would do so as Astro was the “only” company she and her mother could have at home.

“We cannot leave our house and we live on donations and welfare aid. What’s wrong if some people who sympathise want to get us an Astro connection?”

I will agree with the Welfare department in the scenario that the aid given may be “misused” to subscribe to Astro services. I mean, if you can save the extra RM35 or RM50, it can be used for medication, food, savings etc.
However, in this era, the idea that TV is a luxury item is ludicrous to say the least, more so if by staying in a house that has TV (let’s say recuperating from injuries at your relative’s place) , your aid is cut off. The TV can obtained in many ways – second hand, hand-me-downs, gifts etc. Astro is also the only window to the world and information from some category of people, like the bed-ridden. Besides, it also provide cheaper entertainment for folks who can’t afford to go to cinema or hangout in shopping centers. So, the problem may lie in the definition/criteria used by the Welfare Department. I hope its not something created 20 years ago!
Now, I’m not promoting Astro or TV-watching, but I think it should not be a criteria for selection of people for aid. MIBA and KIOKU thinks the same as well:

The Malaysian Indian Business Association wants the government to review the decision to deny aid to the disabled if they have an Astro connection or a television set at home.

Its president, P. Sivakumar, said the Welfare Department should realise that the disabled had little else but television programmes to keep them company. “We have received many complaints of welfare aid being withdrawn after the department found out that the disabled person had an Astro connection or television set at home.”

Disabled Persons’ Integrated Family Services (Kioku) secretary-general Chris S. Kali Thasan said the Welfare Department should not impose such conditions on people seeking assistance. “I remember years ago even those who had a refrigerator were denied assistance. Now it’s Astro. It’s unfair in many cases as Astro bills are usually paid by relatives or well-wishers.”

He said Astro programmes were a good diversion for the disabled who could not work and had to stay at home.

Representatives from disabled people groups met Minister Shahrizat yesterday to show their unhappiness. Shahrizat promised to look into their request:

Women, Family and Community Development Minister Senator Datuk Seri Shahrizat Abdul Jalil said the department would be reviewing the ruling that bars the disabled from getting aid if they had a television set or Astro service at home.

She said this at a meeting with 12 disabled people who came to see her at her ministry yesterday over the issue.

The disabled, who came in wheelchairs, were from the Disabled Persons Integrated Family Services (KIOKU), Independent Living and Training Centre and the Malaysian Animal-Assisted Therapy for the Disabled and Elderly Association.

“You are telling me to look at it, which I will. I think it’s a reasonable request and I will look at it,” she said, adding the ruling did not constitute discrimination against the disabled.

“We will come back with realistic answers.”

… She said the ruling only applied to those under the Disabled Persons Unable to Work scheme, who were being given RM150 per month in aid.

“The underlying principle for welfare aid to the poor and needy is to ensure that their basic needs, such as food, clothing and shelter, are met.

“As such, the ruling on Astro is applicable because it gives an indication of the affordability of the applicant to spend on something extra, in this case entertainment.”

She said Astro was considered a monthly expense that would reduce welfare aid being used for basic needs.

Shahrizat said the ruling did not affect the other two welfare schemes for disabled workers and people caring for a bedridden disabled person, who get RM300 a month.

She said action would be taken against officers who imposed the ruling on people in these two schemes

…. She said she understood the predicament of the disabled, with most lying on a bed the whole day, with nothing to do but stare at empty walls.

Shahrizat said she would also speak to Astro to provide free services to the disabled as part of the company’s corporate social responsibility. There are 28,608 disabled people registered with the ministry.

Well, as part of CSR, Astro can afford to waive the fees, so its a good suggestion by the Minister. We hope it becomes a reality. Maybe by showing their OKU cards, the relevant groups can get waiver of fees.

It seems Baitulmal, which provides aid for muslims also have similar ruling, according to Sisters In Islam.

Tamil news airtime to remain

April 23rd, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Well, after MIC fellas submitted memorandum and made some complaints, as well as MCA, the Minister announced that the time would not be changed.  So from May 1st, Tamil and Mandarin news will revert back to the original time:

The Tamil news will be moved back to the 7.30pm slot from May 1 but on TV2 instead of TV1 previously.Information, Communications and Culture Minister Datuk Seri Dr Rais Yatim said TV1 had to respect the national policy, which emphasised the national language.

“Therefore at 8pm, we will air national news, important events and news from Sabah and Sarawak.

“We’ll also air a little bit of foreign news (in Malay),” he told reporters after a handing-over ceremony of the new ministry by former Unity, Culture, Arts and Heritage Minister Datuk Seri Mohd Shafie Apdal at the Sultan Abdul Samad Building here yesterday.

Dr Rais said the initial change of the Tamil news from 7.30pm to 6pm was part of the ministry’s process to refine the timing of slots for all news.

“Currently, the change of the Mandarin news time slot is from 8pm to 6.30pm on TV2 and Tamil @ 2 news from its original 7.30pm to 6pm.

“Tamil @ 2 news will revert to 7.30pm on May 1,” he said, adding that the ministry would also study whether the English and Mandarin news should be slotted for 8.30pm or within the nearest time to 8pm.

Human Resources Minister Datuk Dr S. Subramaniam had said that Indian viewers would not be home in time to watch the Tamil news if it remained at 6pm.

“This can prove to be a minus point in the Government’s effort to disseminate information about its policies and programmes to the Indian community,” he said in lauding Rais’ decision.

speaker sivakumar threatened by Nga?

April 23rd, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


A blog revealed some documents purported containing transcript of the communication systems installed in the assembly hall. This was carried by Malaysiakini. The transcripts seems to indicate the more experienced Nga dictating/ordering and even issuing threats to the speaker Sivakumar.

Questions arise if the transcript are copied from the system. Was it tampered with as claimed by Ngeh? He claims the system is not secured and anyone could have accessed it.

Its alright if a first time wants to refer to more experienced person, especially since it was about 3 months after being selected as a speaker. But, as a speaker, Sivakumar should not be depending too much on the senior assemblymen.

Unless current state government releases the actual transcript from the system, we can’t say for sure.

Super Teacher Apik

April 22nd, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I came across this article in Malaysiakini. Our education system always get a battering due to quality of teaching, teachers, facilities, policies etc.  While we can understand that out of tens of  thousands of teachers, there will be a number of black sheep, its also heartening to read about teachers like Apik.

The best teacher is the one that is role model for the student. One who inspires and motivates the students. One that is able to mold and influence the student to achieve more. One that student look forward to see the next day. How many teachers can be that person?

Apik can survive in the rainforest, completely alone, with a parang and some salt. He hunts, dives for fish and makes a bed for himself under the forest canopy.

He climbs trees to harvest honey from wild hives. He picks ferns and bamboo shoots to cook, and finds edible fruit and roots. He collects herbs to heal, and uses ipoh, a tree bark, to prepare poison for blowpipe darts.

He travels to neighbouring villages in a wooden longboat, with an engine modified from a grass-cutting machine. He manoeuvres the longboat through rapids strewn with giant boulders, as expertly as KL folk weave through rush-hour traffic.

If he finds snakes on jungle trails, he picks up them up with twigs and branches, moving them away from the paths, and from other travelers. He makes fishing nets, and mends them, with a dexterity associated with more delicate, less muscle-bound, maidens.

He can remain underwater for an astounding length of time, looking for fish or a missing propeller. He rears puppies, teaching them to hunt for barking deer and wild boar. He can carry a wild boar heavier than himself, on his shoulders, through the forest, for hours.

His real passion, though, is teaching. He teaches pre-school and primary school, in his small, remote Orang Ulu village in Sarawak. His students adore him, trailing after him after classes, pestering him to go swimming with them.

He takes them down to the river, to cool off and indulge in some horseplay. The children mob him, climbing all over him. They beg him to push them around in their makeshift dinghies, made from truck tyres. They perform somersaults, shrieking and splashing into the water, to impress him.

“I like watching the children grow up, watching them grow in knowledge and understanding,” he says. “It’s a wonderful feeling – hard to explain.”

He says kampung students are far easier to teach than urban children. He endured a nightmare, during his training, teaching in an urban school, trying to get students to listen.

When asked why, he ventures, “Maybe it’s because the kampung children get more attention. When the children go to their neighbours, they’re made welcome and cared for, as if they were their neighbours’ children.

“Parents in the ulu talk to their children all the time, even when they are bathing the small children. And then, of course, there’s not much television,” he smiles.

No IC until he was 25

Apik came to his calling late in life, graduating when he was nearly 30. He could not attend teacher training school when he completed secondary school, he says, because he had no identity card until he was 25.

“I didn’t think I could ever get to teachers’ training college,” he remembers. “To tell the truth, I was lucky to get to Form Six. The headmaster in my boarding school encouraged me to stay on, and he turned a blind eye to the fact that I didn’t have an IC.”

Apik was born to farming parents, in a quiet Orang Ulu village. His parents had been born and bred Sarawakians. Apik’s father even had a shotgun licence given him by the British colonial rulers, dating from the 1950s. But they could not obtain ICs for many years.

“My father served as a border scout during the Konfrontasi with Indonesia in 1963,” Apik says.

“He helped keep Sarawak part of Malaysia. Yet he couldn’t get an IC. My parents went to the towns to apply for ICs, many times. The journeys would take a week by boat, down fierce rapids, to the Registration Department.”

Many times, Apik’s parents were told the decision to confirm their Malaysian citizenship and ICs had to come from KL, and the decision took time. When Apik’s parents asked when they should return, they were bestowed the time-honoured advice of the bureaucracy – “just wait”. They waited for the letters from the Registration Department, but the correspondence never came.

Apik’s parents obtained ICs eventually, in the 1990s. The Registration Department had established “mobile units”, traveling to remote communities. Apik says the villagers appreciated these visits, because they could not afford the cost of travel to town. But the visits were rare.

He walked four days to school

“My parents were highly respected in the village,” he says. “They were always good to their neighbours, including the Penan communities who were beginning to settle down near our village.

“They spoke Penan fluently, they helped the Penan with farming techniques, and helped make relationships easier with the rest of the village – many of the people in my village looked down at the Penan.”

Most of Apik’s fellow villagers grew to accept the Penan, thanks to Apik’s family.

Apik went to primary school in the next village, where Penan children formed the majority.

“I learnt a lot from them,” he remembers.

“I learnt to be gentle, to respect my neighbours, and respect the forest. I learnt to value the trees and animals in the forest. The Penan are the best trackers around. They can walk for hours. They share what they have, so I always knew I wouldn’t go hungry when I went hunting with them.

“And they never waste. If they hunt a bear, and the dead animal’s young is left behind, they take the cub in and care for it.”

Apik went on countless hunting trips with Penan friends.

“Every time I went into the forest, the first few days were hard. I was tired all the time. But when my body settled into the routine of walking, I began to appreciate the beauty of the forest. The streams, the waterfalls, the animals, the trees, the wildflowers… he stillness.”

After primary school, Apik moved on to the nearest secondary school. Children in Apik’s part of Malaysia often walk for several days to reach school.

“I walked to the Sekolah Menengah, Form One to Three, when I was 13 until I was 15. Twenty of us, schoolchildren, walked four days, carrying our food rations, sleeping in the jungle.

“Some parents asked me to look after their young daughters, so I ended up carrying their books, food, clothes, even packets of sanitary pads… I ended up carrying 30 kilos,” he laughs.

Teachers ‘parachuted’ into rural schools

Many rural children suffer far worse than walking for days to get to school. Children are bullied by fellow boarders and even by teachers.

Penan children, especially, are shy and unfamiliar with shouting and aggression. They often leave school because of bullying and loneliness, and sometimes because their parents take them away to help in the harvest.

But Penan children do well if they stay on, according to Apik. Many become top students, both in the classroom and on the sports field.

Apik gives chilling accounts of teachers beating and bullying rural children.

“Children from my home village tell me how one teacher in their secondary school lost control of himself, and chased them with a parang.

“Another teacher threatened them with a shotgun. The headmaster knew, but took no action. The school has received many complaints from parents, but nothing has improved,” Apik says bitterly.

Few teachers volunteer to work in rural schools, and there are few trained local teachers. Apik himself has been posted to an urban school in the past, even after he had requested to teach in a rural school near his village.

Teachers “parachuted” into the rural schools experience culture shock. Many of them are poorly motivated and ignorant. They receive little support from the education authorities in the towns.

Apik likes to tell the story of a teacher from Peninsular Malaysia, posted to a remote primary school. The young teacher had never heard of the place, and did not know the school is nine hours’ drive and three hours’ boat ride from the nearest large town.

The teacher arrived at the airport, climbed into a taxi, and asked the taxi driver to take him to the school, Apik relates with a smile.

Contractors profit, children suffer

The schools Apik teaches in are dilapidated, without adequate electricity supply, treated water or clean dormitories.

The children bathe in the nearby river, downstream from the rest of the village. Scabies, head lice and worms are routine (left).

One rural primary school had toilets installed and closed down the same day, because of the contractor’s sub-standard work. The children used the bushes for months, until the toilets were repaired.

During lunch hour in another school, the children’s usual meal is rice, tinned food and cabbage. The schoolteachers say the food supply contracts are determined and awarded “centrally” by the Education Department.

Vegetables and fish supplied from the towns are often rotting, so that well-connected urban food suppliers can make their hefty profits. The teachers would prefer to buy chickens and fresh vegetables for the children from the villagers, but are not allowed to.

Many children in these schools have no shoes. Their families struggle to buy them stationery and uniforms. Poor rural children are meant to have an allocation for these items, and are exempted from paying school fees.

Yet many children are still forced to pay fees in rural schools, according to headmen and parents in remote villages. Why? the parents ask.  Incompetence, overzealous bureaucracy, or most likely, corruption.

One headmaster in a rural school provides an analogy: “The allocation provided by the Education Department starts out in the towns, loaded onto the transport.

“But the amount gets smaller and smaller as it makes its way upriver. By the time it arrives, it’s a tiny amount. Most of it has fallen off the transport, on the way to the ulu.”

Poor rural children throughout Malaysia face the same hardship. Some overcome astonishing obstacles in getting to school.

A rural indigenous girl used to walk for days to school in Sabah. She left school after Form Three, to work as a domestic helper for an urban Chinese family. Her employers knew about her family’s poverty, and decided to pay for her to complete her schooling, while she was helping in the employers’ household.

Her results were good enough to go to medical school. Her employers helped her through university, for five lonely, trying years in Peninsular Malaysia. She works as a doctor now, and supports her family and community.

Some rural folk, doctors like this young Sabahan, and teachers like Apik, seek education, so that they can contribute to their poor communities. They support their neglected communities as best they can, in their labour of love.

How many of us, the other Malaysians – educated Malaysians – do the same?

30 percent equity limit removed

April 22nd, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


In a surprising move, the government lifted the restrictive compulsory 30% bumiputra equity ruling with immediate effect for 27 subsectors. Its not known if the move is temporary or permanent. If I’m not mistaken, there was some issue with Digi ownership few years back due to high foreign company equity. The subsectors are as below:

Computer and related services
* Consultancy services relating to the installation of computer software.
* Software implementation services — systems and software consulting services, systems analysis services, systems design services, programming services and system maintenance services.
* Data processing services — input preparation services, data processing and tabulation services, time sharing services and other data processing services.
* Database services.
* Maintenance and repair services of computers.
* Other services — data preparation services, training services, data recovery services and development of creative content


Health and Social Services
* All veterinary services
* Welfare services delivered through residential institutions to old person and the handicapped.
* Welfare services delivered through residential institutions to children.
* Child day-care services including day-care services for the handicapped.
* Vocational rehabilitation services for handicapped.

Tourism services
* Theme park
* Convention and exhibition centre (seating capacity of above 5,000)
* Travel agencies and tour operators services (for inbound travel only).
* Hotel and restaurant services (for four and five-star hotels only)
* Food serving services (for four and five-star hotels only)
* Beverage services services for consumption on the premises (for four and five-star hotels only).

Transport Services
* Class C Freight Transportation (private carrier licence)

Sporting and other recreational services
* Sporting services (sports event promotion and organisation services).

Business services
* Regional Distribution Centre.
* International Procurement Centre.
* Technical testing and analysis services – composition and purity testing and analysis services, testing and analysis services of physical properties, integrated mechanical and electrical systems and technical inspection services.
* Management consulting services – general, financial, marketing, human resources, production and public relations services.

Rental/leasing services without operators
* rental/leasing services of ships that excludes cabotage and offshore trades
* Rental of cargo vessels without crew (bareboat charter) for international shipping.

Supporting and auxilliary transport services
* Maritime agency services
* Vessel salvage and refloating services

This means foreign investors find one less condition to fulfill. No idea if this applies to to local players and also if the companies without 30% bumi equity can apply for projects because some of the tenders/projects require that companies have bumi partners.