If it was not a church but…

/* January 5th, 2010 by poobalan | View blog reactions 1 comment »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I couldn’t help but wonder, if this was not a church/tokong/temple/gurdwara but you-know-what, would the outcome be different? Maybe the land would have been gazetted, allocations provided, and grand officiating ceremony performed. Hmm…

Temerloh High Court Tuesday dismissed the application by two orang asli who sought a judicial review of the decision by a local district and land office which had cut off water and electricity supply to a multi-purpose building that was also used as a place of worship by 70 Jahut Christians in Kampung Pasu.

Judicial Commissioner Justice Akhtar Tahir said that the decision to cut the water and electricity supply was proper because the building was illegally erected.

He added that under Section 6 and 7 of the Aborigines Act, the state authority was empowered to gazette an area as orang asli reserve land.

“However, in this case, the land or area is not gazetted for the orang asli and as such, the application is dismissed.

”The decision made by the Temerloh District Land Administrator is proper,” Justice Akhtar said.

The judicial review was initiatied by father and son, Wet Ket, 59, and Yaman Wet, 33, who named Temerloh district and land office and Pahang government as respondents.

They filed the application in December 2007.

Senior federal counsel Kamal Azira Hassan represented the respondents while counsel Annou Xavier and Kenny Ng appeared on behalf of Wet and Yaman.

The applicants were accompanied by 10 people in the court here Tuesday.

In July 2003, the applicants erected the building, which was also used as a church by the Jahut Christians.

They, however, received a notice by the district office at the end of July stating that the building was illegally built on government land.

In Dec 2006, Wet and Yaman lodged a police report and complained to the Government and following some negotiations, they were given a compensation of RM35,000 to rebuild the place.

Their application for water and electricity was, however, rejected by the Temerloh district and land office on the grounds that it was erected on an ungazetted land while the building was constructed without the approval from the authorities.

1 comment »

Posted in BornInMalaysia, Religion

Tags:

Tamil movies 2009

/* December 31st, 2009 by poobalan | View blog reactions 1 comment »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


2009 saw the release of some interesting Tamil movies, but that’s usual for an industry that spews out movies non-stop.

I managed to catch some of the movies and present a very, very short report of those movies., in alphabetical order.

Aadhavan – Surya’s second release of the year. Not so strong as Ayan, since it had a similar story track. The songs and action scenes are OK, but the main plus point is comedy track with Vadivelu and sidekicks. Oh, and of course a better looking Nayanthara.

Achchamundu! Achchamundu! – A story tributed to the sexual abuse cases that is happening in India and elsewhere, but funnily, the story takes place in US. Prasanna and Sneha act as a couple with a kid. The movie is quite short, and the ending predictable. Nevertheless, it’s a bit different from the run-of-the-mill stuff normally found in Tamil movies.

Ayan – One of the top movies for 2009. Glamour, sophistication, comedy, songs, scenery. Surya scores a hit in this movie. The storyline focuses on smuggling and piracy industry. Heroine Tammana had nothing much to do, other than the usual heroine stuff.

Eeram – Another movie with good reviews from the public. Seldom does a horror movie manage to enthrall the audience. The actors Adhi (his second movie I think), Sindhu Menon, Saranya and Nanda performed well. The director also made use of the water and color elements creatively throughout the movie.  The plot is about a revengeful spirit that kills those people that caused its death. The investigating police officer was ex-lover of the ghost.

Kandaswamy – One of the highly anticipated and underachieving movie for 2009. I’m still undivided if this is comedy or action movie. Kids seem to enjoy the rooster routine, while youths enjoy Shreya scenes. Songs were catchy, but Vikram’s role is wasted here.

Kunguma Poovum Konjum Puravum – Another movie based on love, this time with actors who are not famous (yet), Ramakrishnan and Tananya (she’s a med student in real life). Set in typical village setting. Sad story but lovely song or two. Not suitable to watch if you want to relax or have a fun time.

Malai Malai – Prabhu’s getting some decent roles in his twilight years. Acted well in Ayan, but average in this movie. There’s Vedika for eye candy, and hero is Vijay Kumar’s son Arun Kumar. Story is normal love+action+ rowdy stuff. Some nice songs. Watch if you have nothing much to do or  ardent fan of Arun or Vedika.

Maasilamani – Well, what can you say – Nakul movie. Style, dance, dialogues – usual stuff. Famous for its songs, but nothing much on the acting. Again, watch this if very free.

Modhi Vilayadu –  I had high expectation for this movie, and boy, was I disappointed big time! Vinay and his funny voice was irritating. Kalabavan Mani was at his usual crazy antic stuff. Heroine Kajal Aggarwal was the standard eye candy. She was OK in Arjun’s Bommalattam, but not in this movie. Story is about a rich businessmen who raises an orphan as his own son, and his own son as the “pretend” son’s friend.  Reason? To protect his real son from any harm from business rivals or bad guys. Too bad, the real son actually dies when assassin attacks. How the “pretend” son handles the truth forms the rest of the story. Skip this if can.

Newtonin Moondram Vidhi – A different fare from SJ Surya. Its about a lover’s revenge with the clock ticking away. Can’t really remember the heroine. Story has some loopholes and the ending was copied from English movie, if I’m not mistaken.

Nadodigal – The scenes where the friends help the girl to escape from the parents is still vivid in my mind. One can empathise with the guys (one who broke his leg and the other who went deaf). A different take, but probably the acting skills could have been better. A must watch movie.

Pasanga – a different story indeed, focusing on children rivalry, a funny love story and a friendship between two families. Vega Tamotia’s second movie after Saroja (She’s a model and resides in Australia it seems). May not be your cup of tea, but I enjoyed this movie.

Pokkisham – Another good movie from Cheran, with one of his (and my) favorite actress, Padmapriya. Tale of love in the 1970s between an Hindu guy and Muslim girl. Sad story, told in flashback. Worth watching during those nostalgic moments.

Sarvam – Directed by Vishnuvardhan, so you think it will be a wee bit different at least. And it was. A wee bit different. Guy loves girl routine, but girl dies. Heart donated to a small boy. And someone is planning to kill the small boy. Our hero turns protector to protect his love’s heart. Arya and Trisha star in this movie. The movie had potential, but somehow fails to deliver. I wasn’t particularly enthralled with this effort. And yeah, Maestro sang a song for this movie.

Siva Manasule Sakthi – Entertaining love story between a delivery guy and a Radio RJ. Movie is corny, irritating, and even funny, but I enjoyed watching it. Ending was a bit unexpected. Stars Jeeva and new actress Anuya. Movie turned out to be hit as well.

Thoranai – Strictly for Shreya fans. Co-stars Vishal. Enough said.

Unnaipol Oruvan – Another of the highly anticipated movie for 2009 due to the actor – Kamal Haasan. A movie with no duets or songs, no heroine (well, there’s the chain-smoking reporter Anuja Iyer). Well taken movie, crisp, direct and great dialogues as expected of Kamal movies. Mohanlal acts as police officer. Story is about terrorism. Its adapted from the Hindi movie A Wednesday.

Vedigundu Murugesan – A super comedy movie starring Pasupathy (Veyyil, Kuselan). It’s about a poor guy who sells water to shops, and his brush with some local bad guys. Love comes in the form of local police constable Jothirmayi. A funny movie.

Villu – strictly for Nayanthara’s fans. And Vadivelu’s too. It also stars actors like Vijay. Some nice songs and scenery. Don’t ask about the rest, I barely paid attention.

Yavarum Nalam – A ghost story starring Madhavan! I think its a remake, but not sure. Its about a family that moves into an apartment. Later things that happen on a TV show depicts the real things the family goes through. A scared Madhavan investigates and story unfolds. A bit slow moving and short movie.I kind of enjoyed it because it was not the typical story. Watchable.

Movies I have not seen yet:

Adhe Neram Adhe Idam
A Aa E Ee
Ananda Thandavam (heard this is a good one)
Laadam
Naan Avan Illai 2
Naan Kadavul (heard this is a good one)
Ninaithale Inikkum (stars are Prithvi Raj and Priyamani – two of my favorite actors)
Padikathavan (heard this is a good one)
Peranmai (heard this is a good one)
TN 07 AL 4777 (remake from English movie?)
Vaamanan (heard this is a good one)
Vennila Kabadi Kuzhu
Vetaikkaran (been asked to avoid this)

My vote for best actors for 2009 (s0 far): Kamal, Santhanam, Cheran, Padmapriya, Surya, Nayanthara, Jeeva, Vega Tamotia, Tananya.

List of movies for 2009 can be viewed here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tamil_films_of_2009

1 comment »

Posted in Indian, Movies

DAP blasts Samy over civil service intake

/* December 31st, 2009 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


DAP’s doing what it always does – prodding the ruling coalition. This time, the target is MIC/MCA and the issue is civil service population.  DAP’s Sivanesan says this:

He took to task MIC president S Samy Vellu for harping on the 5.5 percent of civil service job opportunities allocated to the Indian community by the BN government.

Sivanesan claimed that of this figure, five percent is in the Tamil education system in the country which comprises 523 Tamil school headmasters, about 1,000 senior assistants and around 6,000 Indian teachers.

“This leaves about 0.5 percent of Indians working in the lower ranks of the civil service and this is not something to be proud of as the community is not represented in the top levels of the civil administration,” he said.

Sivanesan, who is Sungkai state assemblyperson, said now Samy Vellu is talking about increasing the percentage of 5.5 to 7.5 for the Indian community as promised under the 1Malaysia concept of Premier Najib Abdul Razak.

He alleges the move is only lip service for the Indian community by the BN government rather than real job opportunities.

He said BN must show to the public how they plan to restructure the civil service.

Sivanesan questioned what Samy Vellu had done for Indian civil service opportunities during his long tenure in the cabinet.

“Now he is out of office and he has come up with a new BN figure of 7.5 percent for the Indian community which has yet to be realised,” Sivanesan said.

“Does this mean more Indians will be allocated top civil jobs in the judiciary as magistrates and judges, as chancellors and deputy chancellors of government universities, heads of government departments, state-linked companies and other public subsidiaries like Felcra, Felda and Mardi?” he asked.

Sivanesan also claimed that there are no non-Malay district officers or local council presidents in all the state governments in Peninsular Malaysia.

Well, I don’t have actual figures on number of Tamil school teachers or the number of Indians in public service. I would say that logically, most Indians would be in education, nursing, medicine and police force. There are some prominent Indians in foreign ministry and one ministry chief secretary, plus another two or three directors of federal government departments. That’s about it. Never heard of any Indians as DO, head of local councils, etc.

But its logical that the number of Indians are less because the intake has been much less and not able to substitute the retiring staff nor compete with the imbalanced intake from the majority race. Since no concerted effort was taken in last 4 decades, we have the imbalance in our hands now. It can’t be removed overnight, unless government issues order than 90% of all intakes for next 5 years should comprise of non-Malays (which is like asking the sun to rise from the west). Even if such order is issued, the non-Malays will hesitate because the reality is that the civil service is overwhelmingly one-sided, and even in that side, competition is very tough. The non-Malays would think that the career development and progress path won’t be fair. Its not necessarily true, but the perception exists because the nearly the whole civil service is made of single race.

Anyway, it would be good if the civil service intake is made part of MIC’s KPI. 7.5% of Indians at ALL level of civil service, local councils, state governments, GLCs, etc. Looking at the difficulty, I doubt Samy Vellu would take this as KPI. Mesti MIC bungkus  🙂

By the way, Sivanesan should also open his report card and show what his coalition has done in Penang, Selangor, Kedah AND Kelantan. Talk is easy, action is hard. Let’s see some proof of how his coalition have managed (or is trying to manage) the population imbalance in civil service, local councils, state-linked companies etc. Don’t think just because you talk loud, people forget to question you as well! 🙂

No comments »

Posted in Indian

Tags:

Deputy FT Minister clarifies on Sentul issue

/* December 30th, 2009 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


If yesterday we read about YTL’s explanation, today we have a look at Deputy FT Minister Saravanan’s views:

THE Federal Territories and Urban Wellbeing Ministry has asked the developer, YTL Land & Development Berhad, to honour their promise to build low- and medium- cost homes for the poor in Sentul.

Its deputy minister, Datuk M. Saravanan, said when the negotiations was done years ago between Sentul Raya Sdn Bhd and Keretapi Tanah Melayu Berhad (KTMB) for the development of Kampung Railway, Sentul Raya had committed to build the low-cost houses for the residents.

“This agreement was done during the then Deputy National Unity and Social Development Minister Datuk Alex Lee’s time. We have a written confirmation on this (agreement),’’ Saravanan said.

“When YTL took over Sentul Raya, they confirmed that it would be their top priority to build these homes. Now they are refusing to honour their agreement,’’ he said.

Saravanan said he was disappointed with the developer’s reasoning that they were not responsible because the agreement was made with another company (Sentul Raya) and that YTL only took over in 1997.

“When you take over assets, you also take over the liabilities. As a developer you also have a corporate social responsibility to the community and not just be profit-driven,’’ Saravanan said.

Some 50 people, comprising Batu MIC division members and squatters from Kampung Railway in Sentul, staged a protest at the YTL building in Jalan Bukit Bintang in Kuala Lumpur on Monday over claims that low- and medium-cost flats were not being built as promised.

The group demanded for the promise based on an agreement in 1994 be fulfilled.

They held placards and marched for a short stretch along the street before crowding in front of the YTL building entrance waiting to hand over the memorandum to a management representative.

Kuala Lumpur City Hall Advisory Board member C. Ramanathan said DBKL had even issued a letter confirming the 1994 agreement and re-affirming the proposal to build the low-cost units.

“The letter basically says that they (DBKL) are still waiting for the developer to put in the development proposal,’’ Ramanathan said.

Ramanathan, who holds the housing and squatter relocation portfolio in the DBKL board, said the area was now developed with many high-end apartments.

“What about the poor people who have been living here since the beginning. What about their plight?’’ he asked.

Kampung Railway resident S. Siva said he was appalled by the manner how the residents were being side-lined by the developer.

“We are not squatters. We have been paying quit rent since the 1940s up until 1991. Till today we are paying the assessment fees and bills like Indah Water,’’ he said.

The residents are being asked to relocate to Puchong — which will cripple them financially since most of them are very poor.

According to the 1994 agreement, Sentul Raya Sdn Bhd (under YTL) was to build 3,000 low- and medium-cost flats and two multi-purpose halls and a football field.

But so far, nothing has materialised.

See how is it to be labelled as squatters?  Last time, the community was driven out from estates to urban resettlement or left on their own. Now the vicious cycle continues in urban areas. Where else to run to?

No comments »

Posted in BornInMalaysia, Indian

Tags:

Can nurse or medical assistant give out medicine?

/* December 29th, 2009 by poobalan | View blog reactions 2 comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Amidst MMC’s claim that the 1Malaysia clinics are illegal, the Health minister says this:

“Health Minister Datuk Seri Liow Tiong Lai had said all the 1Malaysia clinics would open daily and be manned by a nurse and a medical assistant.

He said they were allowed to give medicine to patients for minor ailments like fever and cough but would refer more serious cases to clinics or hospitals.

So, is this acceptable or still illegal in the eyes of the law? Any qualified people can clarify?

The public are quite happy with the idea of 1Malaysia clinic because they can access easily and with less cost.

2 comments »

Posted in BornInMalaysia