KGNS membership transfer price by race

/* January 31st, 2012 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


update: Some more news, this time form FMT:

… According to a source who took the photo, the membership price list came from a copy of KGNS’s official newsletter, Berita Subang, printed for the October to December 2011 period.

The source told FMT that he found it very “peculiar” that KGNS would practice racial policies in admitting members to the club.

“It is hard to believe that the club, being established by an Act of Parliament still practices somewhat offensive racial discriminatory policies in admitting members. This admission policy somewhat offends my ideology of what Malaysia is.”

“I would like to stress that I have no malice towards the club when posting the picture,” he told FMT.

Predictably the photo caused an outcry over Facebook, with many reacting in disappointment and anger over the racially-charged prices.

“Where goes the 1Malaysia concept (Where has the 1Malaysia concept gone)?” said a Md Farhad Rahman.

Another, only known as PuiSee Ch, said: “What’s in the minds of these pepps (people)? Now ‘race’ can be purchased? They gotta be kidding.”

Other comments were tinged with sarcasm. One Calvin Wong said: “Wow. I never knew Chinese and Indian (were) worth so much more.”

Aiman Baharum said: “Ahh, so good to be the cheapest one lol.”

Janson Chen said: “One day petrol is going to be like that too lol.”

Balancing the racial imbalance

One Facebook user claiming to be a KGNS club member said that the price list had little to do with racism, and more to do with the racial mix in the club.

“This isn’t racism. They’re trying to balance the number of races (there). Currently, there’s lots of Chinese and Indians but very little Malay club members. I know (this) because I’m a club member myself,” said Norman Zakaria.

“So in order to balance it, they charge higher for the Chinese and Indians so not many will apply, and charge less for Malays in order to promote membership to the Malays and increase the number of Malay club members.”

One of the names listed on the photo – who requested to be anonymous- told FMT that the membership payment was part of a United Overseas Bank (UOB) move to finance loans for potential KGNS members.

According to her, UOB had nothing to do with the price list.

The price was fixed by KGNS according to their quota. We are not selling this (the membership) on their behalf … As a bank, we are running a campaign for the payment,” she said, refusing to elaborate further.

When contacted, KGNS refused to comment.

source: http://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/2012/01/31/racial-tint-to-golf-club-membership/

My initial post:

I first got news of this via Twitter (refer: https://twitter.com/#!/inbarajs/status/163875141623885825/photo/1) yesterday. Today’s TMI article gets some response from KGNS president (refer excerpts from thel article below).

In my opinion, its hard to justify why there should be difference prices as its totally not related to the quota. You had already put a limit based on racial composition, so the price should be the same. However,  since the limited places available, then you can find the demand is pushed up for those under limited quota.  The selling of memberships (even if facilitated by 3rd party) based on racial lines is considered a racial discrimination (wonder if it will be illegal under the proposed Race Relations Act). Its just like hiring people (and paying them differently) or renting out houses (and charging them different rental amount) based on race.

And to claim that its put up by others and not related to the club is flimsy indeed. How can such transfers/sales happen without the club management’s knowledge? How can a finance company offer to facilitate loan/easy-payment scheme without club’s knowledge?

Yes, supply and demand can play a role in determining prices, but here it looks like the company is setting the price. One can google “easi-cash” and identify which bank is involved.

To be fair to KGNS, refer to their membership fees at website (http://www.subanggolf.com/content/fees+mode+of+payments-117.aspx):

 

The ordinary membership is RM25k. Ordinary membership is closed except for government servants, but its possible to get a membership transferred (willing seller-willing buyer basis). And there’s a Membership Dept to help facilitiate this transfer. So, don’t tell me they don’t know about such “pricing”.

The club should ask the finance company to remove such notices before its image is spoilt further.

BTW, one can go through the whole website, and there’s not a single reference to any racial quota for membership. I wonder why. If you are proud of your multi-racial membership, then surely you would highlight how its achieved right?

 

A photograph of a membership price list for one of the country’s most prestigious golf clubs that apparently charged by race triggered an outcry on Facebook, with many condemning the different rates for the different races.

… A picture purportedly of Subang National Golf Club (Kelab Golf Negara Subang — KGNS) membership prices surfaced on Facebook yesterday, showing rates of RM35,000-RM65,000 for Malays, RM45,000-RM80,000 for Chinese, RM60,000-RM80,000 for Indians and RM40,000-RM50,000 for “Others”.

Reactions to the photo, which was posted on Facebook community page “Malaysia”, ranged from disgust to defensive.

“Apa nie??? Racist nye! (What is this? How racist!),” said Wan Hairina Ayin.

“In Singapore, I am a Malaysian. In US, I am a Malaysian. In Australia, I am in Malaysian. But in Malaysia, I am belong to the group OTHERS…” said one Frisca Freddy.

“Malaysia and Spore is the only country that allow companies to advertise ….preferably chinese, or malay or indian…so am not surprised of this la…,” said Julian Maria Intachat.

Some respondents, who appeared possibly to be foreigners, chose to respond with humour.

“So many forms in Malaysia ask ‘Race?’ I simply write ‘human’ no one has ever questioned this ” said Chris Frankland.

 When contacted, KGNS president Tan Sri Megat Najmuddin Megat Khas said the notice in the picture was put out by a finance company and had nothing to do with the club.

He said that while KGNS had long practised racial quotas to ensure a good mix of races in its membership, it had never mandated the prices at which memberships could be sold.

Megat Najmuddin said that due to the race quotas, a member can only sell his or her membership to a person of the same race but at any price they wished and the rates in the notice could be reflective of supply and demand among the different racial groups.

He stressed however that the prices that appeared in the notice were just “indicative” and that the club’s philosophy of imposing race quotas was a noble one and not sinister.

“We are the most multi-racial club in Malaysia,” he told The Malaysian Insider. “If you go to other clubs you see it dominated by one race or the other.”

Megat Najmuddin, who also sits on the Umno disciplinary committee, said it was sad that in Malaysia it was getting rare to find the different races mixing together.

“In KGNS, you have all the races mixing together,” he said.

 The KGNS president said there have been no cases of members being unable to find a buyer for membership from his or her own race.

 “This race quota policy has been a cornerstone of the club and no member has ever asked for it to be removed,” he said.

KGNS, the only club in Malaysia incorporated by an Act of Parliament, limits Malays to 45 per cent of its membership, Chinese to 35 per cent and Indians and others to 20 per cent.

When contacted, “Zainah”, one of the names listed on the notice, immediately started denying having anything to do with the notice.

Calls to the rest of the numbers listed on the notice were not picked up or returned.

Megat Najmuddin said he did not know the finance company behind the notice but criticised the photo as “mischievous” for making it look like it was the club that had issued it.

source: http://www.themalaysianinsider.com/malaysia/article/racist-price-list-for-golf-membership-sparks-backlash/

Tamil Movies 2011

/* January 17th, 2012 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


2011 was not a productive year in terms of number of movies I managed to catch either on cinema or TV. Hectic schedule forced me to skip many movies, thus this review would be limited. As usual, a plethora of Tamil movies were released in 2011 (ABOUT 135!), culminating in Mambatiyyan (Prashanth), Osthe (Simbu) and Rajapattai (Vikram) in the December 2011.

Here’s a very brief review of the movies I managed to watch (alphabetical order) up to 31 Dec 2012:

180 (Nootrenbathu) – Stars Siddarth, Priya Anand, Nithya Menen, Mouli and Geetha. Within 1st 15 minutes, you could guess the plot. The hero, Siddarth, keep mentioning, “only 6 months” and you can related it to some illness (6 months = 180 days, hence title of the movie). The first song is reminiscent of Boys song (slow-motion).  Siddarth comes back to Tamil Nadu from elsewhere, and lives a happy-go-lucky life from a rented portion of a house (owned by husband and wife, Mouli and Geetha). Nithya Menen is a photographer who take his photo accidentally, and then becomes attracted to him. Overall the songs are quite nice. There’s some flashback scene to give us an idea of the hero’s history. Some of the scenes look like ads, and rightly because the director is a well known ad-maker. Be warned that movie moves slowly. The story has a twist at the one hour mark when Nithya confesses her love, and the hero moves out the next day. Along the way, heroine gets into an accident, and hero reveals himself to be a doctor. Heroine is taken to US for a surgery, and flashback continues. We learn that hero is already married and was diagnosed with a disease. Not wanting his wife to suffer over his slow impending death, he pretends to commit suicide and goes to India (which is the present time story). While the heroine is recuperating after surgery in US hospital, he checks up on his wife from afar. She seems to be continuing with her life. His friend convinces him to return to his wife. The hero sends off the heroine back to India, and explaining in a letter that he doesn’t have feeling for her. As he was about to meet his wife,  a haunting figure that keeps popping up (Death?) scares him. He leaves, with the contented feeling that his wife is happy without him. The movie ends with hero going to Brazil. He lives each day as it comes.  A twist in the ending, but ultimately it falls flat because he lives longer than 6 months, and doesn’t want to get second opinion from other doctors to reevalute his condition.

7am Arivu– arguably one of the most hyped movies of 2011 and the reviews been mixed between excellent and below expectation. Starring Surya, introducing Shruti Haasan to Tamil cinema,  Ashwin Kakumanu along with Vietnamese actor/stunt director Johnny Tri Nguyen, its directed by AR Murugadoss. The movie is quite long and nearly 2 hours and 45 mins, thus some scenes were a drag. Songs were OK but reminded me of Ayan and Varanam Ayiram. The sad song by SPB is nice. Story is historical and sci-fi thriller, about a monk/prince from Tamil Nadu who went to China to help the people there. He was the famous Bodhi darman, founder of Shaolin temple. The story continues in modern day where China plans to attack India via biowar using their agent (Johnny) and a researcher’s (Shruti) work on Bodhi Darman’s ancestral lineage may disrupt the Chinese governments plans. Surya acts as Bodhidarman and also his descendant a circus artist. Rest of the story is how the duo team up to stop Johnny’s plan. Movie had plenty of dialogues promoting Tamil civilisation, and that seems to attract many viewers. Stunts were OK but sometimes felt like overdone. Actors all acted well, but I felt Johnny was too robotic and emotionless, while Shruti’s voice seems to struggle to speak in Tamil. Expectation was high for the movie but just felt like something lacking. Still, a commendable effort and worth watching. Read my review here.

Aadu Puli – I had big hopes on Aadi after Eeram, but this movie was a disappointment. Typical romance and fighting movie involving corrupt politicians and gangsterism. Also stars Poorna, Prabu.

Aadukalam – My pick of top movie for 2011 at the moment is this one. Starring Dhanush, GM Kumar, Taapsee and Kishore. Story about cock-fighting community. Touching, comedic, bumbling romance. Must watch. Only thing is that heroine was a bit bland.

Avan Ivan – A comedy movie starring Vishal, Arya, Janani Iyer, Madhu Shalini, Ambiga, GM Kumar and cameo by Surya. Directed by Bala, it was one of the anticipated movies of 2011. Vishal acted well, but Arya’s scope was smaller. Every character played their role well. One of the better movies of 2011.

Doo – Starring newcomers Sanjay, Manasa and Nakshatra, along with Rajesh, Oorvasi, Jegan and few others. The story is about a boy whose love is declined by a girl during school days. Years later, they meet again, and this time love blossoms. The girls proposes and they become a couple. As time goes, they find that they have more things NOT in common, and ends up breaking up. At the exact time, another girl enters the guy’s life due to an accident, and the both of them seemed more compatible. The rest of the movie is about will they get back together or will the 2nd girl get the boy.

Enggeyum Eppothum – One of the best movies of 2011. No glamour or ridiculous stunts, packed with emotion, focus on typical life. Starring Sharavand, Jai, Anjali and Ananya, along with many other characters, the story is a flashback within a flashback, intertwined with realtime event. The story unfolds spectacularly with the headlong accident between 2 buses. Then the flashback begins focusing on  the passenggers in the bus, including the 4 main characters. Jai and Anjali are lovers going back to his hometown, while Ananya secretly fell in love with Sharavand. Very touching story. All the actors did well, Ananya with her “first time in Chennai” scenes, Anjali as the bold girl who intimidates and makes fun of Jai, Jai as the soft guy.  The scenes were well taken and jive very well. The ending is also powerful. Some good songs as well, “masamma, aaru masamma”, “un peyarai theriyathu”, “sottha sottha ” which are soothing and melodious songs. The director Saravanan and actress Anjali won awards from OneIndia public poll for best director and best actress respectively.

Eththan – Vimal who acted in Pasangal and Kalavani returns in this movie which is similar to Kalavani. He acts as a youth with mimicry talents who has debts all around. Also stars 16 year old Sanusha (mute girl in Renigunta), Jayaprakash and Manobala. Vimal’s aim is to start a business, but doesn’t seem to work out. Along the way he meets a Sanusha. BTW, the story starts as a flashback as the hero and heroine escape from the heroine’s rogue uncle who is intent on marrying her.  The story picks up at the one hour mark, as in a twist the hero pawns the heroine’s jewelry to help a friend. The heroine’s uncle who owns the pawn shop thinks the hero is his niece’s lover. Has a nice song, Sivappu Thamaraiye.  Movie is comedic with some irritating and entertaining antics by the hero. If you had seen Kalavani, then this movie has similar antics. Some scenes will have you in stitches. After some sentimental scenes, the couple being chased by bad guys scenes, and typical fight scene at the end, the movie ends well.

Ilaignan – Ex-CM Karunanidhi’s movie starring PA Vijay, Meera Jasmin, Namitha, Nasser, Remya Nambeesan, Suman, Vadivelu, Sarath Babu among others. Story about tyrant businessman and how a the workers led by a energetic youth rise against him.  Keep if for a really free day.

Kaavalan – Looks like a near copy of Bodyguard. Starring Vijay, Rajkiran, Asin, Roja, Mithra Kurian, Vadivelu and others. Vijay is sent from village to town to ensure he doesn’t end up in trouble. His job is to be bodyguard to bigshot’s daughter. He falls in love with a girl who calls him on handphone, not knowing its Asin. A twist in the middle wakes up the audience from sleep. First half is typical Vijay masala and comedy. Can skip it. Second half was a better.

Kullanari Koottam – A love story between useless boy (Vishnu Vishal) and a girl from police family (Remya Nambeesan).  Girl’s father allows them to get married, if the boy gets a police job. Easy yeah? Except boy’s father totally dislikes policemen (not sure why) . Rest of the story is how he goes for police selection, befriends other candidates, and exposes corruption in police selection process. Can watch on a free day.

Kandaen – A love story starring Shantanoo Bagyaraj and Reshmi Gautham as the couple, along with Santhanam for comedy, Vijayakumar and Asish Vidyarthi. Shantanoo pretends to be blind in order to find a suitable girl for marriage. He ends up falling for Reshmi. Her father doesn’t agree to her to marry a blind. The couple plan to get register married. At the office, Shantanoo is revealed to be not blind, and the heroine is upset. He manages to convince her. She forgives him for the lie and they get engaged. Soon after that, Shantanoo gets blinded temporarily after a fight. The rest of the movies deals with how Shantanoo trying to pretend to be normal. Some  misunderstandings occur along the way before the couple patch up and Shantanoo successfully undergoes operation to cure the blindness. The movie is the typical love story, with the blind twist as an attraction. The acting is OK, but since the story is normal, nothing much to attract the audience’ attention. Can skip this movie unless you got nothing to do. Movie has song catchy tunes, with the “Narmada” song doing well. Malaysia’s Dr Burn also sang a song.

Ko – One of the anticipated movies of 2011 due to the different storyline. It stars Jeeva, Kartika Nair (80s actress Radha’s daughter), Piya Bajpai, Ajmal, Prakash Raj, and Kota Sreenivasa Rao. The story is about politics and elections. Jeeva acts as photographer with a newspaper and the two heroines are journalists. Ajmal plays a young leader of an NGO who enters the election fray. Prakash Raj is Chief Minister while Kota Sreenivasa Rao is opposition leader. We see how media helps to reveal wrongdoings of politicians, and at the same time, can be manipulated to those with wrong intentions. The storyline is a bit different, with some twists. I think the love angle actually disrupted the movie instead of enhancing it. The action thriller has some nice songs (which seems to come at wrong places), but the direction is a bit weak and editing could have been better. The leads actors did well, but some of the stunt and scenes can be better. The movie did well in the cinemas and considered a hit. Worth watching.

Mankatha – One of the much hyped and expected movies of 2011. Its Thala’s 50th movie, and personally I think it conveys a wrong message that crime does pay. Not a milestone that one would prefer. Stars a experienced and high profile ensemble – Ajith, Trisha, Arjun, Andrea, Vaibhav, Anjali, Subbu Panchu, Premgi, Jayaprakash, Lakshmi Rai, Mahat Raghavendra and Ashwin Kakumanu. Directed by Venkat Prabu and music by Yuvan. Background music and 2 songs are OK, the rest typical run of the mill songs. Lakshmi Rai seems to be making a comeback with some meaningful role. Trisha, Andrea and Anjali’s role nothing much to shout about, can say wasted role. Ajith plays a negative role with his usual mannerism to the border of irritation. Arjun and the rest did well. Story is about illegal betting industry involving cricket. A group of friend plan to rob a big sum of illegal betting money being transferred. Their plan is discovered by Ajith who joins them. The rest of the story is about double-crossing and few twists. Initial part quite draggy. Fight scenes also quite long and boring. Some loopholes in the story, but overcome by Ajith’s presence. Dialogue got plenty of references to other movies (Ajith) and also current issues. Rated 18, so not for family viewing due plenty of foul language (muted).

Maveeran – a movie dubbed from Telugu (Magadheera which was the top grossing Telugu movie in history) starring Ram Charan Tej, Kajal Aggarwal, Dev Gill and Sarath Babu.  Basically its about a 400 year old unrequited love. First 1.25 hours was ridiculously taken, with logic-defying (and unnecessary) stunts by the hero. There’s some flashback to the historical part with some nice settings. Kajal Aggarwal looked and acted as required, and did quite well. Not sure why it became a blockbuster in Telugu, as there’s nothing ultra special in the movie. Watch if if too free or if you are a fan of Ram Charan or Kajal Aggarwal.

Mayakkam Enna – Arguably one of the blockbuster for 2011, but I caught it only in 2012. Starring Dhanush and Richa Gangopadhayay, directed by Selvaraghavan. Story is about amateur photographer Dhanush who yearns to be a famous photographer like his idol. Along the way, he falls for his friend’s girlfriend and they end up getting married. Dhanush becomes an alcoholic due to failures/setbacks (especially when his idol uses Dhanush’ photo as his own) and also has an accident, but his wife stands by him through the turmoil (even caused miscarriage). In the end, he succeeds in winning an international awards and all is well in the end. A good performance by Dhanush and also the heroine Richa. Simple storyline, emotional and heartwarming. Some great songs like Pirai Thedi and Naan Sonnathum. A must watch in my books.

 Muran – starring Cheran, Prasanna, Haripriya, Nikita, Jeyaprakash and newcomer Suma Bhattarcharya, this is a thriller movie which started off well, but fizzled out towards the end to a predictable ending. Still its a watchable movie. Story is about two people who accidentally cross paths. Cheran is a musician while Prasanna is a son of a rich businessman (Jeyaprakash). Cheran end up hitching a ride with Prasanna, and along the way they exchange their sad story. Cheran is living an unhappy married life with wife (Nikita) and is in love with a fashion designer (Haripriya). He is unable to divorce his wife since she doesn’t agree due to some inheritance problems.  Prasanna, meanwhile says his ladylove (Suma) committed suicide after being raped by his own father (Jeyaprakash) on a business trip. Prasanna suggests that he kills Cheran’s wife and in return Cheran is to kill his father. In this way, Cheran will be relieved of his misery and Prasanna will get his revenge. However Cheran disagrees and they part ways. Some time later, Cheran’s wife dies in an accident. Cheran believes it was an accident, until Prasanna enters his life, admitting to killing Nikita. Prasanna also proceeds to kill Nikita’s brother, a policemen who is suspicious of Cheran. Cheran is forced by Prasanna to try kill his father, but he fails to do so a few time. One day, one of Lavinia’s friend who works in Prasanna’s company reveals what actually happened to Suma. Cheran learns that Prasanna is the bad guy and not his father, and refuses to take part any further. Prasanna goes away, but leaves a subtle threat, saying accidents will happen, even to Lavinia. Cheran becomes paranoid as Prasanna attempts to hurt Lavinia. In the end, Cheran plans to get rid of Prasanna, but as the struggle in a fight, Prasanna falls down from the rooftop. Acting wise, the main actors did well, but the story became lethargic and draggy halfway. We could more or less predict that Prasanna is not who he seems to be.

Muthukku Muthaga – Typical sob story that drags like a megaserial. With cry queen Saranya in it, you can expect sad ending. About a family with 5 sons and how their lives turns for the worse when most of them get married.  Stars Vikranth, Ilavarasu and Saranya.

Nanjupuram –  A movie about snakes, set in village boy-love-girl story. Stars TV drama actor Raghav (who doubles up as music composer), along Mohini. Story about superstitions and caste issues.  The hero doesn’t believe the stories about the snake and ends up killing some. He also hurts a snake while saving his lady love, and according to village lore, have to stay hidden for next 40 days. The villages build a tower to keep him safe. The story revolves on how the couple try to stay alive for the next 40 days. BTW, the hero is from high caster family while the heroine from low caste family, so there’s a side story where the families try to marry of the heroine in the absence of the hero. The ending is a bit unexpected. Story has promise, but moves slowly and lacks oomph factor. Watch it if got nothing else to do.

Nil Gavani Sellathey – A thriller movie ala Texas Chainsaw Massacre or Wrong Turn. Plenty of red herrings as the story of 5 friends going on a trip goes awry. Stars the director himself (Anand Chakravathy), Dhansika, Jagan and others. Watchable.

Osthe – A Simbu action flick, so expect plenty of dialogues, mannerism and style. The movie is a remake of Hindi film Dabangg. Simbu is a cop who plays by his own rules. VTV Ganesh has a role as Richa’s father.  Jithan Ramesh is Simbu’s half-brother, Nasser is step-father and Revathi is mother. Saranya Mohan is Jithan Ramesh’s love interest and Nizhalgal Ravi is her father.  Comedy is provided by Santhanam who is Simbu’s assistant. Simbu and his step-father doesn’t have a good relationship. Due to Simbu’s actions, the bad guys end up killing his mother, and also turn his brother against him. In the end, Simbu reconciles with his family and the baddies lose. The story intertwines cop versus baddies with sibling rivalry. Songs are catchy such as Neduvali, Pondatti, Osthe Maame, Kalasala Kalasala (Mallika Sherawat special appearance) and the melodious Unnale Unnale. Watchable movies if you are looking for some entertainment flick.

Pathinaaru – Another movie that seems to have much promise but falls below expectation. Starring Shiva and Madhu Shalini, two college going youths in love. The girl’s parents oppose love marriage and pass a story book for the couple to read, with hope that they give up their love. The book is the story of the girl’s father. The couple do some detective work to trace the father’s ex and in the end, the go on their own ways.

Payanam – A supposed to be thriller of a plane hijacking terrorist story. The acting is OK only, but the story, screenplay, props, action mostly fall flat and not convincing. Only to be watched if got nothing to do. Stars Prakash Raj, Nagarjuna, Sana Khan, MS Baskar, and few others.

Ponnar Shankar – One of the lousiest movies of 2011 or even in recent memory. I’m still at lost as to why Sneha acted in this movie. Prashant (dual role as per the title) should be careful with the directors and roles he chose to act or he can kiss his acting career goodbye. For first 1.5 hours, Prashant spoke about 5 lines only I think. The movie’s action scenes, directions and story had plenty of loopholes. Some of the scenes look like cut and paste from other movies. The two new heroines Pooja and Divya (one a Miss India, the other a famous model) are pretty faces and did well considering its their debut. The story is based on historical events but spoilt by bad direction, acting and action. However, cinematography is quite good. The movie has a star-studded cast: Nasser, Vijaykumar, Rajkiran, Kushboo, Napoleon, Ponvannan, and Prabu among others, but their acting overshadowed by the weak plot and direction. Skip it unless you are die-hard Prashant fan.

Poraali – A Samuthirakani direction starring his buddy Sasikumar, Allari Naresh, Swathi (from Subramaniyapuram) and Vasundra (aka Adhisiya from Thenmerku Paruva Kaatru) along with Ganja Karupu. Its not your typical storyline (but we’ve come to expect that with Samuthirakani and gang). The story start quite suspensefully as we see Sasikumar and Allari Naresh escape from a group of people. They end up staying with Ganja Karupu and work in petrol station. The heroines come in the form of a fellow petrol station worker and a resident staying in the same building. After some time, Sivakumar starts a business venture and does well. Ganja Karupu helps to advertise his business and that’s when the baddies turn up. The second half of the movies provides flashback and we realise the two heroes are actually escapees from a mental asylum! How they ended up there, why baddies are after them and how thing end up well forms the rest of the movie. Plenty of action in the second half as Sasikumar and gang outwit turn the tables on the bad guys and triumph. Story is good, direction crisp, not many potholes. But songs are not memorable. Worth watching if you want something different.

Rowthiram – Starring Jeeva, Shriya Saran, Jayaprakash, Prakash Raj among others. Its about a young guy (Jeeva) whose trained by his grandpa(Prakash Raj)  to stand up for justice and face any wrongdoers, much to the chagrin of his parents (Jayaprakash as father). He ends up getting into the wrong books of the baddies in town (a plethora of them, ranging from MLA, big goons to local goons), and what ensues is lots of fighting. Not to disappoint the guys, there’s a romance track involving the guy and a student (Shriya). There’s also the sentiment track with his siblings getting married without telling him, and parents disappointment with his rough ways. Typical movie that leaves nothing for audience to think about. Story is normal bash-em-up type. Jeeva acted well, but I think he should choose the scripts carefully (oops  Music is average. Nothing much to talk about. Watch it only if you are Jeeva or Shriya fan.

Sadhurangam – This movie was released about 5 years later due to some unknown reasons. It stars Srikanth as a journalist for a magazine and Sonia Agarwal (yup that’s how old the movie is!) as is love interest. The movie is about Srikanth who investigates and exposes wrongdoings by politicians, local thugs and government officers. He ends up stepping on the wrong toes, and one day his lover gets kidnapped. The rest of the story is about he rescues her. An average movie in my opinion. Had one or two nice songs.

Seedan – Not sure how Dhanush ended up in this movie, as Lord Muruga nonetheless! No heroine for him in this movie. Basically how Lord Muruga help fulfill the marriage dreams of a girl (Ananya). comedy scenes with Vivek are enjoyable a bit.

Singam Puli – Jeeva in a dual role comedy cum thriller. One good and one bad sibling story. Also stars Divya Spandana, Honey Rose, Ponvannan and Santhanam. Comedy is OK.

Siruthai –  One of the 3 Ponggal releases, along with Danush’s Aadukalam and Vijay’s Kavalan. Reminds of one the Surya movie with double role (Vel). Karti Sivakumar plays a small time conman Rocket Raja with Kaatu Puchi (Santhanam) in Chennai. They live a happy go lucky life, until Karti falls for Tamannah during a wedding function. There’s some irritating antics until we see the intersection of the other Karti, DSP Rathnavel Pandiyan. The DSP dies midway and Karti takes over the role of the DSP to beat the baddies. Boring songs, typical Tamannah acting, the normal Karti acting we are used to, some weird/comedy villains. Good thing Santhanam and Karti’s comedy brings some laughter.

Thambikottai – Forgettable movie starring Narain, Poonam Bajwa, Prabhu,  and Meena in a sister role. Typical village problem end up revenged by youth after a series of flashbacks.

Thoonga Nagaram – Starring director Gaurav, along with Vimal, Anjali, Barani and others about the live of few people in the city that doesn’t sleep, Madurai.  Has an interesting twist about plotting friends against each other. Watchable.

Uyarthiru 420 – I’m not sure why they bothered making this movie. The hero is lyricist Snehan,  who acts as a con artist. The premise has lots of promise but direction and storyline makes it a below average result.

Vagai Sooda Vaa – A story set in the rural parts of Tamil Nadu in 1960s where the folks live by working in a village brick-making industry. This is a heart-warming story of a trainee teacher (Vimal) who is posted to that village in order to earn his teaching certificate.  The story on his trials and tribulation, including humorous scenes of being bullied by children, parents and even the village goat is a wonder. Iniya acts as a tea stall owner who falls for him. His sacrifice would put many teachers to shame. It also stars Iniya (also acted in Yuddham Sei), Bhagyaraj, and Ponvannan. The movie is different from the normal masala movies, though some of  songs were superb. “Poranne Poranne” and “Sara Sara Saara Kathu” were frequently heard on radio.  The movie may not appeal to the younger generation due to to its seriousness (poverty and education) and lack of glamour/hero appeal/stunts, but its a must watch movie in my book.

Vaanam – Simbu and Bharath starrer which was a hit. Along with Anushka Shetty, Prakash Raj, Saranya, Santhanam, Jasmin Bahsin, Vega Tamotia, VTV Ganesh and Jayaprakash. About lives of few individuals and how they intervine towards a tragedic end involving terrorists when all of them end in Chennai. Watchable.

Velayudham – Vijay continues his unenviable run of making dud movies. This time around, he gets to portray a hood-wearing, sword-wielding, Robin Hood lookalike, who suddenly can fight like martial arts exponent. To accompany him on this disastrous adventure, we have poor Saranya Mohan as his “love of his life” younger sister, Genelia as a reporter who falls for him, and Hansika Motwani (Namitha lookalike) as his village relative who also in love with him. Genelia acted well here, different from her normal crazy girl routine. Saranya’s talents are wasted in this movie, while Hansika is basically eye-candy for male audiences. Other supporting cast include Santhanam, MS Baskar, and Pandiyarajan. The story is about Velu who comes to town to get his investment for his sister’s wedding.  Due to some incidents and luck, he saves the public from bombs set up by terrorist. And he is mistook to be Velayudham, the fictional character created by journalist Genelia who is supposed to avenge the public. Genelia tries to convince Velu to take up the mantle of “superhero” and become Velayudham. He refuses until he is affected when the investment company closes shop and he witnesses an investor commit suicide. From then on, he goes after the baddies who are linked to politicians and terrorists. Ending is predictable as the good guy prevails. The songs are OK, with hits like “Rrathathin ratthame”, “Chillax”, “Mayam Seidhayo”, and “Sonna Puriyadhu”. The movie was voted as Best Movie of 2011 in OneIndia public poll. Watch it if you have nothing else to do, or die-hard Vijay fan.

Vellore Maavattam – An action flick starring Nanda and Poorna. Nanda is an police officer while Poorna is his love interest. Typical cop and baddie film. Lousy movie. Watch if only either die hard Nanda or Poorna fan.

Venghai – A normal action film starring Dhanush, Tamannah, Ganja Karupu, Rajkiran, Prakash Raj, Livingston, Oorvasi, YG Mahendran, Ponnambalam, Charlie and others. After some different interesting movies from Dhanush, he returns to typical masala movie. Dhanush is sent to city by his father (Rajkiran) to learn some responsibility from his uncle (Livingston). Prakash Raj is the local politician who needs support of Rajkiran but is actually the bad guy.  In the city, Dhanush sees his primary school classmate Tamannah and after some scenes, fall in love with her.  Due to some problem, Prakash Raj ends up want to revenge Rajkiran and Dhanush. There’s a twist towards the end where Tamannah is seen plotting against Dhanush’s father due to some history. You will get the normal stuff – fights, romance, fights, glamor, fights, emotion, fights, comedy. One or two OK songs. Only for Dhanush and Tamannah fans.

Veppam – A movie starring Karthik Kumar and Nithya Menen along with some actors from Telegu movie industry, like Nani and Bindu Madhavi.  One of the songs became a hit (Mazhai Thuli Mazhai Thuli). Story is about 2 brothers Balaji and Kartik (Muthukumar and Nani) who were left to fend themselves since children after their mother committed suicide due to drunken father.  Once grown up, the father (now a pimp/gangster) wants to build a relationship with them. The brothers have a good friend, Vishnu (Karthik Kumar), who is in love with Viji (Bindu) a call girl under the brothers’ father’s care. The brothers also have a friend in Revathy (Nithya). Kartik and Revathy love each other. The movie’s choppy direction, lack of continuity, constant dialogu censoring and wooden acting made it an unpleasant watch. Even though there was an element of thrill after the hour mark, where Kartik is arrested for the death of his friend Vishnu, the interest picks up temporarily only. The rest of the movie focuses on why Kartik was arrested, which involves a drug deal gone wrong. Not worth watching.

Yuddham Sei –  One of the better movies of 2011. Cheran in a moody role, plenty of unexpected twists and turns. YG Mahendran and Jayaprakash also acted in this movie. Well made thriller about revenge and prostitution syndicates.

Yuvan Yuvathi – Love story starring Bharath and Rima in the lead roles, along with Sampath as Bharath’s father and Santhanam as his friend. Its basically about two people who accidentally meet during visa application to US (The hero applying to escape from father who forcing him to get married, while the heroine applying to get married in US). The hero falls in love with the heroine after some mishaps and scenes, but gets a shock when he realises she’s getting married. The father misunderstands the situation and kidnaps the heroine, causing her to miss the flight, hence the wedding cancelled. She is angry at the hero and disappears. After some time, coincidentally, the two of them end up in a foreign country, where the hero tries and succeeds in wooing the heroine. They go back to his hometown, and after some action+emotional scenes, the father accepts her. Pretty boring movie with a typical storyline.  Two nice songs in “Oh My Angel” and “Un Kannai Parthe Piraghu”. Only for Bharath fans.

Movies I have not seen yet (as of 31st Dec 2012):

Mapillai

Nadunissi Nayagal

Engeyum Kadhal

Paasakaara Nanbargal

Narthagi

Aaranya Kaandam

Deiva Thirumagal

Konjam Mazhai Konjam Veyil

Kanchana

Vandhan Vendran

Vedi

Vithagan

Mambattiyan

Rajapattai

My list of top movies for 2011 (so far):  7am Arivu, Aadukalam, Avan Ivan, Enggeyum Eppothum, Ko, Thoonga Nagaram, Vagai Sooda Vaa, Vaanam, Yuddham Sei, Mayakkam Enna, Poraali.

My vote for best actors for 2011 (so far): Dhanush, Vishal, Jai, Jeeva, Vimal, Simbu, Cheran.

List of movies for 2011 can be viewed here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tamil_films_of_2011

My previous reviews  are here:

2010: http://poobalan.com/blog/movies/2011/01/08/tamil-movies-2010/

2009: http://poobalan.com/blog/movies/2009/12/31/tamil-movies-2009/

Malaysian students ranking in PISA survey for reading, mathematics and scientific literacy

/* January 16th, 2012 by poobalan | View blog reactions 3 comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


The OECD Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) arose from OECD policy initiatives in the latter half of the 1980s aimed at improving the quality of education throughout OECD countries.

PISA  is an international study which began in the year 2000. It aims to evaluate education systems worldwide by testing the skills and knowledge of 15-year-old students in participating countries/economies. Since the year 2000 over 70 countries and economies have participated in PISA.

PISA is an international comparative survey of 15-year-olds’ knowledge and skills in reading, mathematical and scientific literacy.

PISA seeks to measure how well young adults have acquired the knowledge and skills that are required to function as successful members of society.

Sixty-four countries or economies originally participated in PISA 2009: all 34 OECD countries plus 31 partner countries and economies. These 65 participants administered the PISA 2009 tests in 2009.

An additional 10 economies were added in 2010, under PISA2009+. Malaysia is one of the 10, along with Costa Rica, Georgia, Himanchal Pradesh (India), Malta, Mauritius, Miranda (Venezuela), Moldova, Tamil Nadu (India), and UAE.

PISA 2009+ involved testing just over 46 000 students across these ten participants, representing a total of about 1 377 000 15-year-olds.

The PISA sample is drawn from the population of students aged between 15 years and three months (completed) and 16 years and two months (completed) who attend educational institutions and are in the equivalent to Grade 7 or above.

PISA assesses outcomes primarily in the areas of reading literacy, mathematical literacy and scientific literacy.

Reading literacy: An individual’s capacity to understand, use, reflect on and engage with written texts, in order to achieve one’s goals, to develop one’s knowledge and potential, and to participate in society. Mathematical literacy: An individual’s capacity to identify and understand the role that mathematics plays in the world, to make well-founded judgements and to use and engage with mathematics in ways that meet the needs of that individual’s life as a constructive, concerned and reflective citizen. Scientific literacy: An individual’s scientific knowledge and use of that knowledge to identify questions, to acquire new knowledge, to explain scientific phenomena, and to draw evidence-based conclusions about science related issues, understanding of the characteristic features of science as a form of human knowledge and enquiry, awareness of how science and technology shape our material, intellectual, and cultural environments, and willingness to engage in science-related issues, and with the ideas of science, as a reflective citizen.

So, let’s see how our 15-year olds performed among the 75 economies which includes OECD countries:

Students in Malaysia attained a mean score of 414 on the PISA reading literacy scale. This mean score is below the means attained in all OECD countries and equivalent to the mean scores estimated for Brazil, Colombia, Miranda-Venezuela, Montenegro, Thailand and Trinidad and Tobago. In Malaysia, 56% of students are estimated to have a proficiency in reading literacy that is at or above the baseline level needed to participate effectively and productively in life. Students in Malaysia attained a mean score of 404 on the mathematical literacy scale. This mean score is below the means attained in all OECD countries. In Malaysia, 41% of students are proficient in mathematics at least to the baseline level at which they begin to demonstrate the kind of skills that enable them to use mathematics in ways considered fundamental for their future development. In Malaysia, there was no statistically significant difference in the performance of boys and girls in mathematical literacy.

Malaysian students were estimated to have a mean score of 422 on the scientific literacy scale. Malaysia’s mean score was significantly higher than that estimated for the lowest scoring OECD country, Mexico. In Malaysia, 57% of students are proficient in science at least to the baseline level at which they begin to demonstrate the science competencies that will enable them to participate actively in life situations related to science and technology. In Malaysia, there was a statistically significant gender difference of 10 score points in scientific literacy, favouring girls.

FYI, The top economy in the survey, across all 3 areas was Shanghai (China). Singapore was consistently among the top 5, while India’s two states were quite bad, occupying the lower 3 rungs. Other countries which were consistent in top 10 places were Hong Kong, Japan, Finland, Canada and Korea.

Below are some snapshots of the comparison tables.

Reading:

Math: Science:     The full report (PDF) is found here. (caution: its a 13.5MB size file). sources: http://www.acer.edu.au/media/acer-releases-results-of-pisa-2009-participant-economies/ http://www.pisa.oecd.org/pages/0,3417,en_32252351_32235731_1_1_1_1_1,00.html

Tamil school renamed after Datuk Pathmanathan

/* January 15th, 2012 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


FYI: the school in question is SJKT Ladang Tanah Pancis.

A 63-YEAR-OLD Tamil school in Tanah Pancis in Rompin, Negri Sembilan, will be renamed after former deputy health minister and MIC vice-president Datuk K. Pathmanathan.

Its headmaster Rajan Gopal said the decision was made as Pathmanathan, who died in 2001, had made huge contributions to the state, country and the Indian community, reported Makkal Osai.

The renaming ceremony to be held on Dec 3 will be attended by special envoy with Ministerial rank for Infrastructure to India and South Asia Datuk Seri S. Samy Velu.

The estate-born Pathmanathan was the Teluk Kemang MP for four terms from 1974 and had actively fought for the rights of Malaysian Indians, especially in the fields of education.

When he headed MIC’s education bureau, he was credited with getting more places for Indian students in public universities.

He was also the founding chairman of Manipal Medical College in Malacca and was instrumental in getting both the governments of Malaysia and India to agree to a twinning programme between the college and an Indian university.

source: http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2011/11/25/nation/9972663&sec=nation

MyIndians doing their work to solve citizenship issues

/* January 15th, 2012 by poobalan | View blog reactions 2 comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Had the pleasure of volunteering with MyIndians last year for education workshop. They are also focusing on citizenship issues, so this is another avenue for community to get help. Contact them at www.myindians.com or click on MyIndians link at the sidebar of this website.

Statelessness — in which a person is without nationality or citizenship — is a social problem in Malaysia in which the numbers involved remain vague.

According to sources, there might be up to half a million unregistered and unrecognised Indians here.

However, since October last year, an independent portal, MyIndians.com, has been acting as a connecting medium for Stateless Indians to help each other.

Despite carrying out its work with little fanfare, the website accumulated 20,000 registered members and garners about 125,000 visitors a month.

The portal is manned by a team of less than a dozen officers, led by author-columnist Datin Vasanthi Ramachandran.

“Over the past year, we have helped about 3,000 cases, most of them concerning birth certificates and MyKad issues,” she said.

“Many of these Stateless Indians are poorly informed and live in fear of being found out, and it takes a lot of effort to convince them to trust us so we could help them.”

MyIndians.com promotes a community-helps-community concept via its “Helping Hands” section, where those in need of financial, educational or medical assistance can file in their cases which are then highlighted on the website for registered members to help.

When The Malay Mail visited MyIndians’ office in Jalan Desa Kiaramas, Mont Kiara, recently, Vasanthi and her team were preparing a holiday education programme for academically under-performing children, aged 10 to 15.

“Most of these children only know Tamil. They have little communication skills, so they have problems expressing themselves. We have come up with a fun, interactive programme so they don’t get bored and, at the same time, are inspired by what they learn,” said Vasanthi.

“We are doing what we can but more members of the community need to come forward and help, too.”

Cases resolved by ‘MyIndians.com’

• TWIN boys Kenny Jayraj Selvaraj and Kevin Suraj Selvaraj, 14, were adopted when they were just a few days old, by Selvaraj Amalraj and Josephine Retnam. The siblings were given up by their 17-year-old mother who was unable to care for them as she did not have Malaysian citizenship, resulting in the twins being issued red identification cards. The boys have since applied for citizenship on two occasions but their applications were rejected by the National Registration Department (NRD).

However, after discussing the matter with NRD officers and with the assistance of MyIndians.com staff, Selvaraj was advised to track down the twins’ biological parents. Their biological mother was traced, allowing for the necessary changes to be made to their birth certificates. The twins have now been awarded citizenship.

• Sarveswaran Saravanan, 13, had not been attending school as he did not have a birth certificate or identification card. Sarveswaran also could not be registered as his natural father was unreachable.

His mother, Packiam Gopal, was hesitant to seek assistance for fear of being penalised for not providing relevant information pertaining to the boy’s father. However, with the help of MyIndians.com, both mother and son have since submitted their application and been interviewed by the NRD.

• Sudagar Sadrasagaran, 31, never applied for a MyKad due to financial and personal issues. Also, his natural mother could not contacted. To obtain a birth certificate from the NRD, it is compulsory to have information on the applicant’s mother. With the help of MyIndians.com, the required documents were successfully traced. He is now a proud owner of a MyKad.

• Santiyah Mugunthan, aged four, could not be registered as her parents’ “marriage” was not legally binding. MyIndians.com provided assisted to the family by linking them to the relevant agencies, including the Social Welfare Department. Santiyah’s parents are now all smiles as Santiyah finally has a birth certificate.

• Suganthan Manivanan, aged one, was registered without his father’s details as his parents separated and, due to personal reasons, his father refused to cooperate. MyIndians.com discussed this case with the NRD and since then, both of Suganthan’s parents have registered their marriage. The authorities agreed to make the necessary amendments to the child’s birth certificate.

• Kaithiri Vengathiyah, 12, was given up for adoption because of financial restraints. Vengatiyah Chandariah and Sellamah Polliah raised Kaithiri as their own when she was only a few days old. Due to the lack of information on the biological parents, Kaithiri never received a birth certificate.

MyIndians.com advised her foster parents to track down the biological mother, who then gave consent enabling the NRD to proceed. Kaithiri received her birth certificate last month and is now due to receive her MyKad, too.

source: http://mmail.com.my/content/86444-website-help-indians