Indians earn only 14 percent more than Malays

/* November 20th, 2008 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I’m sure the public is well aware of statistics on income according to races as revealed in Mid Term review of 9th Malaysian Plan. Specifically the average income for Malays and Indians were listed as below:

  • Bumiputera’s mean income
    increased by 5.2% to RM3,156 in 2007 from RM2,711 in 2004.
  • Indians’ income rose 3.2% to RM3,799 from RM3.456

That means the Indians on average earned 20 percent more than the Bumiputras in 2007 (RM3,799 versus RM3,156). The acceleration rate is 5.2 percent for Bumiputra against 3.2% for Bumiputras. If this continues, its possible that in next 5 years, the Bumiputras will earn more than the Indians, on average.

I’ve always asking why the term Bumiputra (and not Malay) is used. What would the statistics be like?

Thanks to MP Charles Santiago’s question in the Parliament, we get more details as below. It makes me think why those fellows in MIC never asked for such details before in the last decade (at least to my knowledge).

The statement and tables below show that the Malays in Peninsular earned RM3,311 on average in 2007 while those in Sarawak Rm3,503 and Sabah RM3,089. That means it doesn’t a genius to know that actual poverty is among the real Bumiputras (averagebetween RM2,063 and RM2,857). Orang Asli in Peninsular Malaysia are the worst with income around RM1,397.

That means, in 2007 the Indians earn on average only 14 percent more than Malays in Peninsular Malaysia (Its a fairer comparison as most Indians live in the Peninsular). Given the benefits and privileges the Malays get, is it fair to say that Indians are doing better than Malays? Shouldn’t the non-privileged communities be given handicap?

Reply on Average Income Breakdown

Reply on Average Income Breakdown

Reply on Average Income Breakdown 2

Reply on Average Income Breakdown 2

Complaints against civil service increases

/* November 20th, 2008 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


As more people become aware of their rights and multiple channels for complaints are created, its bound to happen. Due to things like HINDRAF rally, more Indians dare to stand up for their rights. The wins by opposition parties in some states also provides another voice for public to highlight their grievances.  The Internet through forums, blogs and websites provides more motivation and information for people to complain. Add to that the gun ho antics of Deputy Minister Murugiah who oversees the public complaints bureau, we have a spike on complaints received.

We have a civil service populated and ran mainly by people purportedly strong on religious values (praying 5 times a day should make me more God-fearing). So, what went wrong? Is it the system? Is it the employees? Is it isolated cases? Is it just a sign of times where people complain at the slightest excuse? Or is it that the civil service need to be revamped?

Complaints on public services have more than doubled in the past three years, especially those pertaining to abuse of power, corrupt practices and late or non-action by the officers concerned.

Public Service Department director-general Tan Sri Ismail Adam said the Public Complaints Bureau received 5,347 complaints last year, a big increase compared with 2,707 in 2005 and 3,397 in 2006.

“For the first nine months of this year, 6,059 complaints have been recorded,” he said in his speech at the opening of the Public Service national Quality Control Circle convention at Crowne Plaza Riverside Hotel here yesterday. Ismail’s speech was read out by his deputy Datuk Dr Ismail Alias.

Ismail expressed concern over the increasing trend of customers being dissatisfied, which marred the image and reputation of the public service.

Should Syariah and Civil laws merge?

/* November 20th, 2008 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


There’s suggestion by retired Chief Justice:

On Nov 6, retired Chief Justice Tun Abdul Hamid Mohamad said he foresaw that the combination of the two courts would harmonise common law and Syariah law principles in dealing with issues of conflicting laws and jurisdiction during his lecture at the Harvard Law School in the United States.

This is comment from Syariah Court Judge and Syariah Judicial Department director-general Datuk Ibrahim Lembut:

Islam will defend everybody. The impression that merging the two court systems will override the rights of the non-Muslims is wrong, he said.

Syariah laws and Islam will think of every religion and race, he told reporters after attending the International Seminar on Comparative Law at Marriott Hotel here yesterday.

However, we still have a long way to go before we can merge the two court systems although we have held talks between civil and Syariah lawyers on the possibility of harmonising the laws, he said, adding that Attorney-General Tan Sri Abdul Gani Patail had also given his views on the matter during the meeting.

Ibrahim said some civil lawyers attending such talks had refused to even consider harmonising the laws between the two systems.

He was commenting on a statement by MCA legal bureau chairman Datuk Leong Tang Chong that any merger would subject non-Muslims to Syariah jurisdiction on all legal matters, including inter-faith cases relating to marriage and divorce.

What do you think?

I think rather than merging both sets of laws, there should be some sort of bridge to link them both. Why should one be tried under a religious law which one does not profess to be part of? I think this idea may be construed as part of a long term strategy to Islamise the country. nearly 50 percent of the country’s population are not Muslims. Thus it is not wise to impose a law that does not relate to them in any way.

It would be better to study the overlapping laws, holes, and gray areas between two laws and clear them up. No one likes to see spouses make use of laws to manipulate children, nor do public like to read that families fighting over properties of the deceased, or bodies being snatched by religious department officers.

For those cases involving marriages being dissolved due to one party converting, then the marriage dissolution should follow civil law. Clear the slate, each person go on his own way. This is only natural as the marriage was done under civil law. So, BEFORE the person want to convert, divorce first.

Same goes for conversion. Those who are married must start fresh by divorcing their spouses and declaring their assets which are divided accordingly. For those who are single, the next-of-kin must acknowledge that he/she has been informed of the impending conversion. NOTE that its not an approval, but an acknowledgment so that family members are aware BEFORE conversion, and not after. The next-of-kin then knows that the body of the convert will end up in Muslim graveyard. No confusion.

For me, the problem is clear. Issues only arise when a party converts. Solve the problem at the root. Setup up proper documentation and procedures.

Your religion onto you … my religion unto mine ….

Not automatic citizenship if father is Malaysian?

/* November 19th, 2008 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I’m am surprised to read in today’s Star Metro section about the plight of Teresa Ratnam. Read the full story at the end of this post. Its clearly stated that if the parent is a citizen, the children is automatically citizens also. But in this case, the children have been deprived. Teresa is stateless but her husband Lawrence is Malaysian! Anak sendiri pun tak dapat kerakyatan??? UNLESS Lawrence and Teresa is hiding some facts, this is a crime by those officers in the relevant department. They should report to Deputy Minister Murugiah of BPA immediately, take legal action against the departments, and reveal the name of the officers who misled them. 10 years of suffering, how is the government going to compensate the children? Free medical treatment? Scholarship for education until university? Free low cost housing?

We have so many children from Indonesians and Bangladeshi mix marriages getting citizenship, but not for two Malaysians, one of which is stateless.

AS it is late now (11.45pm), I’ll suggest to the persons below tomorrow to do the above.

THE story of Teresa Ratnam is a story of suffering, right from the time when she was an infant.

The 40-year-old mother of three from Jinjang Selatan Tambahan in Kuala Lumpur was abandoned at the Kuala Lumpur Hospital at the tender age of four when her parents sent her there for treatment.

Teresa cannot recall anything from her past except the names of the couple who adopted her and took care of her until both of them died, after which she had to fend for herself.

She discovered the agony of not having a birth certificate, and was declared stateless. Without a citizenship, she was unable to get an education, let alone a job.

She survived by working as a maid until she met a kind and loving man who married her and gave her the security and protection that she needed.

In a quandary: Lawrence (right) with his wife Teresa and three children at their home in Jinjang Selatan Tambahan.

They have three lovely children – Daniel Christie, 12, Nelson Christie, 10, and Patricia Christie, five.

Teresa’s trouble begun when she and her husband G. Lawrence, 44, discovered that despite Lawrence being a Malaysian citizen, the authorities have denied citizenship to their three children as she is considered stateless.

Although Teresa was abandoned by her own parents, that did not stop her for being a loving and caring mother. It was simply heart-renting to see this woman sobbing and begging for mercy on behalf of her three children.

Don’t let my children suffer because of me. Please have mercy, Teresa sobbed as she pleaded for help to get citizenship for her children.

I don’t want my children to suffer. They are innocent and should not have to go through what I went through in life, she said.

My wife is a victim of circumstances. Due to no fault of hers she is unable to prove her citizenship, but I am a Malaysian citizen and my children were all born here, yet the government is denying them their basic right, Lawrence said.

He said he had spent 10 years of his life running from one government department to another trying to get his children’s citizenship problem resolved.

In some places they have treated me very unkindly by pushing me from one officer to another, making me run around from Putrajaya to Kuala Lumpur and all over the place, he said.

According to Lawrence, he has been to the National Registration Department, the Welfare Department, the Kuala Lumpur Hospital and the Public Complaints Bureau of the Prime Minister’s Department countless times yet no one was able to help him.

He said some officers even gave him wrong information which caused him to waste more time.

Lawrence is now desperate as his youngest child Patricia has been diagnosed to be suffering from a rare disease called Pierre Robin Syndrome, a congenital condition of facial abnormalities in humans, and she also has a heart problem and requires surgery as soon as possible.

We need an OKU (disabled person identification card) from the National Registration Department to enable her to get free treatment from the National Heart Institute because I cannot afford it, Lawrence said.

But to get the card, she needs her citizenship, and it is an urgent matter, he said.

Their eldest son Daniel passed his UPSR exams with five A’s and one B and will be going to Form 1 next year. But Teresa and Lawrence are worried that Daniel may not be able to go to Form 1 as he is not qualified to get the MyKad as he doesn’t have citizenship status.

We did not have problems when he entered primary school but now the school is saying there may be problems with him enrolling into secondary level, Lawrence said.

The family is seeking help from the Government to solve their problem and is hoping that Teresa’s natural parents or any other family member can come forward and produce documentation to prove that she was born in Malaysia.

According to the Federal Constitution, children born in Malaysia, with at least one parent holding citizenship is deemed qualified to be citizens.

It is strange that in this case, where the children’s father is a Malaysian citizen and they were born in Malaysia, they are still being deprived of their citizenship.

The Jinjang Selatan Tambahan Tamil Youth Club, the Jinjang Selatan MIC branch and Komuniti Bestari Jinjang Selatan are trying to help the family apply for citizenship for the children.

Those who can help can call Selvakumar at 012-615 6011 or R. Krishna Moorthy at 017-226 4952.

Bloggers Buff 2008

/* November 19th, 2008 by poobalan | View blog reactions No comments »
 Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I’m going. Managed to clear my schedule. I attended the 2007 event and found it to be quite beneficial. Now it has been “upgraded” to PWTC level. 🙂

Mahathir is coming, so this is a good chance to ask him some questions especially on his blog. There’s also a session on legal issues. Hopefully will be beneficial.

Here’s Novinthen, Mr Kamalanathan, and Amutha posing in the newspaper:

FORMER Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohammad will be the guest of honour at the bloggers conference called Bloggers Buff 2008 on Saturday at Putra World Trade Centre.

Mahathir, who is also a blogger, will be delivering the keynote address entitled Unity and Accountability in Blogging.

The event will be a conference-cum-networking event where established speakers will share their experiences.

“It is a stepping stone to get Malaysian bloggers from various genres to come together to open up their minds towards different aspects of blogging and to comment on issues that affect bloggers in the country,’’ Putera MIC national coordinator P. Kamalanathan said.


GoMobile is sponsoring the conference, which is being organised by MI Fest Management. Traxx FM is the official radio station for the event.

The one-day event is endorsed by Empower Lives, All Blogs and Malaysian Indian Bloggers (MIB) and supported by Putera MIC.

The conference will be held from 9am to 7pm.

The first session will be themed Blogging Realities and deals with current issues like ethics, law, money-making and technology.

The second session, on the other hand, is targeted at young bloggers.

Kamalanathan said bloggers could choose to attend both sessions at RM60 while the morning session was priced at RM50 and the afternoon session was at RM20.

The registration form is available at the official blog for the event – www.bloggersbuff.blogspot.com.

This event is opened to about 100 Malaysian bloggers for each session on a first-come, first-served basis.

Call Tim Fernandez (012-601 1126), Felicia Wong (012-530 2682), K. Novinthen (016-557 4227) or R. Amutha (017-639 3631) for further details.