Posts Tagged ‘discrimination’

Tan Sri Ramon on NEP deviation

January 21st, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Confirming what many Malaysians already know, one of the persons involved in the drafting of NEP, Tan Sri Ramon Navaratnam says this in Malaysiakini article:

The New Economic Policy (NEP) has deviated from its original aim of eradicating poverty in the country and thus, it is imperative that the policy is studied again in detail, not by politicians but by professionals.

MCPX

At the launch of a new book entitled “Malaya’s First Year At The United Nations” at the Royal Lake Club this afternoon, Ramon Navaratnam (right in picture) said, “I have some knowledge of it, as I was one of those who drafted the NEP. I agree with Tunku Abdul Rahman when he said there’s nothing wrong with the NEP per se, but (there are problems with) the way it is implemented.

“At that time, neither Tun Dr Ismail nor any of us thought of APs (approved permits) and special privileges for the rich. We thought of poverty eradication regardless of race and the removal of the association of occupation with race.

“But it has had different turns and twists, and I think it is well worth a study of where it deviates from the ideals and wisdom of people like the late Tun Dr Ismail,” added Navaratnam, who is also director of the Asian Strategy and Leadership Institute.

Race Relations Act plan grounded

January 20th, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


The Race Relations Act was mooted back in September by MCA after the Sin Chew reporter saga. The cabinet moved to work on it. However, there were hints that it will be “adapted” to our local environment as mentioned by Home Minister Syed Hamid.

In a major turnaround, it seems the Cabinet decided that such an act is not relevant.

The government has decided not to pursue the proposed Race Relations Act – just four months after saying that the cabinet had agreed to do so.

The change of heart was announced today by Unity, Culture, Arts and Heritage Minister Shafie Apdal.

He said that the cabinet has now agreed that there was no need for the Act, according to reports.

Shafie said that the cabinet had studied the matter thoroughly and has decided not to proceed with the proposed Act.

“Race relations is something that comes naturally and cannot be forced through legislation,” he told reporters today.

“That is why everyone in the cabinet agreed there was no need for such an Act.”

Shafie added that so many experts were against such an Act being implemented in this country.

The minister also said that he had studied similar acts in several other countries and found that such an act was not suitable here.

To overcome any religious tensions, the minister suggested that everyone respected each others’ religion and race.

“We have lived in harmony for more than 50 years. Why can’t we continue to do so? You cannot force someone to like you. It must come naturally,” he added.

Interesting words indeed – “The minister also said that he had studied similar acts in several other countries and found that such an act was not suitable here.” Wonder what he means by that.

Kuala Terengganu Indian voters meet Najib

January 14th, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I saw the Indians at Kuala Terengganu attending a dinner (organised by MIC?) over the TV. At that time, it was mentioned by the reporter that Deputy PM Najib may attend the dinner.

Looks like he did, and below is extract from NST report:

Datuk Seri Najib Razak last night urged the Indian community not to fall prey to the opposition’s provocative campaigns.

He said although there had been some recent problems affecting the Indians, these problems were not entirely insoluble.

“I am very confident that these problems can be addressed effectively through consultation and discussion,” he said at a dinner with the local Indian community.

The deputy prime minister acknowledged that there had been some dissatisfaction among Indians regarding several sensitive issues, including some that were raised within the Umno set up.

“Umno is a large party and the views of one or two members do not represent our stand as a whole.”

Najib said issues such as the destruction of Hindu temples had been blown out of proportion and exploited by some quarters for their own political benefit.

“Let me assure you of this: we are not the type of government that goes around destroying temples in the country.

Najib said the government was also constantly in touch with grassroots leaders from the community to solve their problems.

This included the problem of stateless Indians, he said, adding that he had raised this issue in the cabinet.

Najib urged Indians not to be fooled by the opposition’s propaganda, saying that unlike Barisan Nasional, Pakatan Rakyat was a loose coalition that could not even share common objectives.

3 things I would like to refer from his speech:

1. what he means by recent?

2. “including some that were raised within the Umno set up” and “the views of one or two members do not represent our stand as a whole” . I think the action that the party to in response to the one or two members is lacking. Latest incident is when banners saying close down Tamil schools were shown in Melaka during an unreleated protest by UMNO.

3. “we are not the type of government that goes around destroying temples in the country.” This is most laughable. While he may proclaim so, the truth is the opposite. Temples were and are being demolished for various reasons. He should have not said this statement.  He could have reworded it into something more acceptable like ” won’t demolish or relocate temples without proper procedures being followed”. Then, maybe we can consider his statement as possible.

At the same dinner, Sothinathan gave his views:

MIC vice-president Datuk S. Sothinathan said a party survey showed that in the March general election, 80 per cent of the Indians had supported Barisan Nasional.

“This time around, we do not see much problems in getting the support of the Indians.

“Things in Kuala Terengganu are far different as compared with the other states, for example during the Permatang Pauh by-election.

“There are no real issues among the Indian voters here,” Sothinathan said at the MIC office, near here.

Sothinathan, who is also MIC co-ordinator for the by-election, said he had been getting positive feedback during meet-the-Indian voters sessions.

“Most of the issues which they have raised are concerning day to day matters. We have pledged to look into their problems and seek solutions.”

One of the main grouses of the Indian community in Kuala Terengganu is difficulty in getting citizenship.

There was a case of an elderly couple, both in their 70s who have been here for more than 40 years but still have not got their citizenship.

Other issues include business opportunities, education, housing and employment in the civil service.

Sothinathan said MIC would also help to provide transport to bring back Indian voters working or living outside Kuala Terengganu.

1. Hmm…80% supported BN in the March general elections???

2. 40 years and no citizenship. Indonesian who comes now can be public bus driver holding PR. What an irony.

However, there seems to be a lack of local issues for Indian community, unless they look at national issues affecting the community. Of course, if what Samy Vellu says is right, there are some problems affecting the Indians due to UMNO itself!:

The MIC president also claimed that during his visit to the parliamentary seat of Kuala Terengganu recently to oversee the setting up of MIC’s operations room in preparation for the Jan 17 by-election, many had complained to him that Indian, especially Hindu religious songs and cultures, were allegedly barred from being practiced openly

Whoa! What a blooper! (or is it the truth?)

BTW, The same Star report mentioned that:

While the Chinese voters have been described as the “king-makers” in the Kuala Terengganu by-election, the voice of the 523 registered Indian voters cannot be ignored.

Of this number, 380 live in the area while the rest are working in Kuala Lumpur, Selangor, Penang and Johor.

Most of the Indian voters, at 235, are registered in the Bandar state seat, 188 in Ladang, 80 in Batu Burok and the rest in Wakaf Mempelam.

They are mostly businessmen and professionals, like lawyers.

This is critical as the majority by the previous MPs was only 628. If the Malay votes are split equally, the Chinese and Indians will be the king makers.

Kampung Pandan Indian settlement eviction looms

January 13th, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


While most of us are counting the hours to celebrate Ponggal, all’s not well with Kampung Pandan folks. Their relocation issue is still unsettled. The latest eviction notice by DBKL gave today as the deadline. Over time, many folks have left, but the remain families are sticking to their guns.

SOME 250 Indian families in the Kampung Pandan Indian settlement are worried that they would not be able to celebrate Ponggal (Harvest Festival) tomorrow as they have received final notices from the Kuala Lumpur City Council (DBKL) to vacate their houses by today, reported Malaysia Nanban.

The families had been living there for the past 70 years. In earlier letters to the residents, DBKL requested the residents to move into rental houses built by the city council in Bukit Jalil, Puchong.

The residents, in their counter offer, asked for houses in the Sri Alam, Sungai Besi area. DBKL rejected the request. The residents complained that the units in Bukit Jalil did not have the necessary facilities such as Tamil schools, temples and halls.

The residents are hoping that Federal Territories Deputy Minister Datuk M. Saravanan would look into the problem and find an amicable solution.

After the folks supported PAS in the elections last year, the DBKL sent eviction notices in June, giving one month for the residents to move out. The temple was demolished earlier. The residents organised a protest.

Now, after 8 months, there’s still no progress. The offer to relocate them to Puchong is on the table. But Kg Pandan to Puchong is so far away. How do we expect the residents to manage the extra expenses? Kids go to school in nearby schools, most of the residents should be working around KL centre. Puchong to KL is a jam-packed road. Can’t rely on public transport. Need to wake up much more earlier. Need to change schools (BTW, the Tamil school will be relocated or wiped off the face of earth?) So much of hassle and expenses.

The residents were asking for low cost houses in the same spot, but I doubt it will be granted. The place is surely meant for some mega development by big players. Not for low-cost residents. Now, they want the alternative accomodation to be at Sg Besi (which is also a bit far) citing lack of facilities (no temple, hall, school) at Puchong. DBKL rejected the request.

The elected MP can only shout and support so much. In the end, the responsibility lies with the Ministry and DBKL.

Samy Vellu and previous BN MPs have tried before, but nothing much happened. What can Saravanan do now?

Terror At SJKT Ladang Vallambrosa

January 5th, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


The was a big a commotion today at SJKT Ladang Vallambrosa. The school was forced to start double session this year due to increased student intake and lack of fund from the government. The school HM has been practically begging for extra tables and chairs, but all felt to deaf years. I remember the HM grumbling about lack of furniture last year itself. He was asking for donations to get some chairs.

The dual session did not go down well with some of the parents who claimed that this was a major hassle and extra expenses for them.

Someone also brought a printed copy of a document from the Internet which showed that a large amount of money was allocated to the school from government via JKR for construction work. But the person(s) claimed the construction was not worth the amount of money allocated. They accused the HM of corruption.

Oh ya, Makkal Sakthi people were there as well, lending their voice and energy.

So, some parents (allegedly) came with some local Kapar folks armed with parangs to threaten the HM. They smashed his car as well at the school. Police, PPD staff and Kapar MP Manikavasagam can attest to this. They were all there today.

Even the PPD staff were not spared and hurled with abusive words.

Manikavasagam on his part said he will look into this problem within a month.

Well, I know the HM personally for more than 4 years now, being related in a way. Nice guy, a HM who sent his kids to Tamil school unlike some HMs. He has the kids welfare in his mind all the time.

Word is that some troublemakers (PTA? ex-PTA? unhappy parents?) are out to cause problems. If they really got guts, take it up with the PPD, PPN, MOE, JKR, and Samy Vellu.

In the meantime, since parents oppose the dual session, the students can study in the canteen or under some trees.

Note: The above was narated via telephone by HM’s wife.

Update 6/1/08 – parang and police were not found at scene.