Posts Tagged ‘discrimination’

food problem from PLUS to local universities

December 30th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Roti canai and tosai lover Michael Yeap makes it a point to stop at the Ulu Bernam rest area near Tanjung Malim for breakfast when driving to Kuala Lumpur.

However, his 15-year love affair may have to end after Dec 31 because the stall that serves the Indian delight has failed to obtain a permit to continue operating at the rest area.

The 60-year-old dance instructor said he would time his travel so that he would either catch breakfast or lunch at the Indian stall at the rest area.

“I have been doing that for the past 15 years. I love the food there,” he said yesterday.

“But during my last visit, the operator told me his permit for the stall has been terminated,” Yeap said, adding that the stall was the only one run by an Indian there.

He said he or other travellers would be unable to find non-Malay food along the expressway if the permit were to be terminated.

The Star

I took PLUS quite often in the last two months. Most of the time before this, ‘ll enjoy a cup of tea or coffee together with some roti bakar (toast bread). But recently, not many stall are offering roti bakar (There’s one chinese stall in Air Hitam stop towards JB). Worse still, there’s lack of real Chinese and Indian food. The chicken rice or fried kuey teow doesn’t taste authentic. No fresh thosai or roti canai with thick, tasty sambar (dhal curry).  Most of the stalls are selling Malay food or localized version of other cultures’ food. There can be many copycat chicken curry, but nothing beats the authentic southern Indian chicken curry (IMHO).

Forget about getting vegetarian food. You can only depend on bread and fruits.

This is only natural as population imbalance increases. Traffics towards northern states will be predominantly of certain race, thus only those selling particular type of food will make profit. Those catering for minority will eventually suffer a loss as they can’t get the business volume needed.

But, those rest areas in the middle and southern region should have more multi racial meals.

Recently, the lack of non-Malay food served along the expressway was highlighted by Ipoh Barat MP M. Kulasegaran at a press conference. Kulasegaran said there were only a handful of stalls that served non-Malay food in the Tapah and Ulu Bernam rest areas.

“Many Malaysians use the expressway and it is a problem to those looking for vegetarian or non-Malay food,” he said.

Kulasegaran said he was not against the number of Malay food stalls at the rest areas but he was hoping that PLUS would allot more stalls for non-Malays.

He said he had written to PLUS, the Malaysian Highway Authority and the Works Minister to look into the matter.

According to PLUS representative, they are planning to introduce fusion food, and also said that meals were introduced based on demand. Also, the stalls were terminated due to various reasons as given below:

When contacted, PLUS senior public relations manager Khalilah Mohd Talha said PLUS would introduce a fusion of Malay, Chinese and Indian foods that appealed to the masses next year.

We are re-looking at our rest and recreational areas along the North-South Expressway. We are introducing more varieties in terms of menu to appeal to travellers from different ethnic and cultural background.

She said PLUS had never practised discrimination against the multi-racial stall operators, but over the years, operators requested to serve titbits and more Malay-based food based on demand for those kind of food.

We do invite multi-racial stall operators. The response is another story.

She said licences were only terminated if the operators did not comply with the Health Ministry’s guidelines on food preparation, cleanliness of premises or hygiene discipline, did not pay rental or had customer complaints.

“But this is after several warnings are issued.

Well, for those who are having certain preferences or limitations, better plan your journey well so that not deprived of your meals.

Now, the same problem is also manifesting in local universities. Recently, UM closed down its only Chinese-run food stall due to violation of its rules – serving non-halal food and employing non-Muslim cook. This was protested by the students and MCA stepped in. Through the BN Youth Education Bureau, the university management were persuaded to reinstate the stall at College 12. The college has about 600 Chinese student of 1200 students.

However, the stall operator has to abide by the rules –  Chinese cooks are allowed but only halal food and must be clean.

According to MCA Youth education bureau chairman, Chong Sin Woon, who had brought the issue of the stall closure to the BN Youth, the Chinese stall was ordered to close in May.

“However, on the insistence of students, the stall was allowed to operate until this month.

“UM then awarded the tender for the stall to another operator.

“The reason given by UM was that the stall served non-Muslim food and employed a non-Muslim cook.”

Chong said the demand by MCA Youth, acting on behalf of Chinese students, was that the food be prepared by a Chinese chef, especially as there were a total of 13 other stalls at College 12, run by Muslim operators.

Chong said only Universiti Sains Malaysia had proper Chinese food stalls while Chinese stalls at Universiti Putra Malaysia and Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia were only allowed to serve vegetarian food.

This begets the question – who should be tolerant? Is it wrong to eat the food the students are used to? What is the unversity imparting to its students? One-sided rule? All it takes is some extra measures to ensure the areas where non-halal food are separated. Disposable utensils can be used in some cases.  And we seldom can get nice Indian food if cooked by non-Indian, so I guess its the same for the Chinese. The food will be watered down or tastes different. So why get fixated with the rule that must be Muslim cook only? If there are muslims who like Chinese food, then set up another stall la! This kind of small things can be settled easily.

This problem rarely happens in Indian restaurants/stall as they don’t cook pork-based dish. All the chicken and mutton are halal. So its easy to accept Indian cook compared to Chinese cook. Yet, how many universities have Indian stalls with Indian cooks?

While I was in university, there was a short period when a chinese stall operated. It disappeared after a year or so. Most of the time, the Indian students get food from outside. The food served in the cafeteria had a kind of smell which was terrible.  Many of my friends, especially in their first year were forced to eat in-campus since no other option. But after entering second year, all those who had own transport seldom visit in-campus cafeterias.

As time goes by, due to relatively small population of Indian and Chinese students in local universities, the non-muslims stall will die a natural death. Unless of course we consider students from China (some of which who are Muslims). So, non-Muslim students face stiff challenge in adapting to university environment especially those who only avenue to a degree is local university.

Typical response over dismal local movies

December 28th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


So, the rakyat is being lined up to be the fools again. Ready to pay RM20 for a foreign (Hollywood) movie? I wonder if movies from Indian subcontinent and Chinese diaspora will be penalised as well, just to force us to endure 2 hours of torture in the name support local movies.

Frankly speaking, I don’t really fancy watching local movies. The ones I enjoyed were some  P Ramlee and AR Badul movies looooong time ago. Nowadays, I’ll fail if there’s any question on local actors or movies. I was blasted by Then for wasting time watching Naana Neeya few months back, so its not a matter of Malay movies, but Tamil movies as well.

Local film directors are obviously gleeful over the proposal by the Malaysian Film Producers’ Association to hike the ticket price for Hollywood movies.  Some of their comments:

“It is a good step but it should not stop there,” said award-winning director Datuk Paduka Shuhaimi Baba.

She said another way to help the industry was for local producers to have a bigger cut of the box-office collection.

“Currently, producers and cinema operators are sharing the ticket sales equally. Producers should get a higher cut.”

She said cinema operators could also share the promotional costs of local movies.

Shuhaimi said many countries were imposing regulations to protect their movie industry.

Director Ahmad Idham Ahmad Nazri said:

cinema operators would also benefit from higher ticket prices for Hollywood movies.

“The screening for a local movie now is limited to 14 days — the minimum required by regulations — as cinema operators will replace it with Hollywood movies to generate more income.

“With a hike, they will get more income from one or two Hollywood movies, thus encouraging them to give more days to local movies.”

Director Afdlin Shauki said the number of Hollywood movies in local cinemas should be limited.

He said China only allowed 20 Hollywood movies to be shown annually.

“It means only the best movies from Hollywood are shown, which is good for movie-goers”

Afdlin, however, cautioned that the ticket price hike could backfire.

“At the current ticket price, you can watch two movies, one Hollywood and one local. But if you increase the price to RM20, movie-goers might just skip local movies altogether.”

Let’s see what one guy commented in NST:

A local production professional said increasing the ticket price for Hollywood movies to RM20 to save the local film industry would not make movie-goers watch local films.

Danny G said the move would only make DVD sellers happy and bring down the cinema industry, which was now enjoying a revival.

“The reason why most local movies are not attracting the crowd is because they are poorly made and lack a good storyline.

“It should be noted that movies by Yasmin Ahmad that have good storylines command a good following among movie-goers.”

Danny said he recently went to watch the Antu Fighter movie and found it so ridiculous, he walked out midway.

“One should not go into production with a weak story just because there is funding, and complain later that the ticket sales are poor. ”

Danny said local movie-makers should improve the quality of their films not by using lots of special effects but by emphasising on a good storyline.

BTW, I read that the three local movies released recently bombed. One of it was the Antu Fighter mentioned above.

So, is a protectionist policy needed to revive or develop our local movie industry? Is it a sign of lack of patriotism from our rakyat? Or are the movies not meeting the exceedingly high standards or tastes of local moviegoers? In terms of storylines, technology, directing, and perhaps acting, I think we are quite lagging in one or more aspects if compared to other countries.

Local movies basically means those catered for the Malay market, thus eliminating nearly 40% of target audience (in Peninsular Malaysia). The market is small, so how many movies can we produce in a year? Is there a big enough field for 20 over local movies in a year?

Now, we have Indonesian, Korean, Japanese, Thai, Iranian etc. movies being shown as well. These cater for the foreigners and also hard core moviegoers. The market is very diversified, so local movie producers have to work triple hard to succeed. They can’t rely on discriminatory policies on the expense of others. We already suffer a lot from NEP and its offshoots.

This is the age of Astro, bit torrents and pirate DVDs. By putting a higher ticket value, people will look for alternative avenues, and I very much doubt that local movies will be on their minds. Just subscribe to Astro or one of the many Internet service providers.

OK, its easy to criticise, so what’s the solution? I think there should be categories of movies – are we going to develop indies, art/noir, sci-fi/tech, drama/action, horror etc. We shouldn’t kid ourself by targeting all areas. Then, we should set up funds to allow directors to make movies. This fund can be derived from the entertainment industry, global institutions, or CSR from MNCs and GLCs.

But money alone does not guarantee a roaring success. There are many cases stretching from Hollywood to Hong Kong.  We should cultivate local talents – start young in schools, organise competitions. Offer free/discounted viewing for local movies instead of charging more for foreign movies.

And of course, the guidelines on censorship most likely have to be revamped. You can’t have one set of rules for foreign movies and another for local ones. From kissing scenes to bloody attacks by vampires, foreign movies win hands down! If we can’t treat the public as mature and able to make own decision, we might as well close down the local movie industry and move on to other industry.

Let them wait till 31st Dec!!!

December 18th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Deputy Home Minister Datuk Wan Ahmad Farid Wan Salleh, in an interview with Reuters yesterday, said the government was “still reviewing” The Herald’s licence and was following “due process”.

“Until Dec 31, we are not going to announce anything. There is plenty of time. Let them wait.”

Now, I hope this is yet another “miscommunication” or “misquote” by the press. But if not, it shows the arrogance and high-handedness of the deputy minister.  Imagine the publishers having to wait UNTIL THE LAST DAY before finding out if they will get permit for following year or not. If there are paid employees working under the publishers, can they find another job if the Herald is closed down on the very last day? To add salt to wound, Herald made their application for permit renewal way back in JULY! That’s 6 months of inefficiency for you.

I get the impression that the ministry (or at least the deputy minister) is purposely making life hard for the Herald, possibly due to the court case on usage of the word “Allah” made by the Herald against the ministry. So, is this a case of intimidation, perversion of justice, and/or gross negligence?

Read the NST report yourself:

Catholic weekly The Herald may have to stop publication as its publishing permit, which expires at the end of the month, has still not been renewed.

The weekly, recently the subject of controversy over the use of the word ‘Allah’ in its content, needs to have the permit renewed by Dec 31 to continue operations next year.

Its editor, Father Lawrence Andrew, said the paper’s licence was usually renewed three months before the deadline.

However, this year, the Home Ministry has yet to renew the permit although The Herald applied for a renewal earlier than it usually does.

“We expected difficulties, so we applied in July. There should be no reason for the delay,” said Lawrence.

“The government said it was still reviewing our licence. But we are now at the tail-end of the year. I must let people know what is going on.”

On the paper’s use of the word “Allah”, he said: “The issue is in the courts.”

Deputy Home Minister Datuk Wan Ahmad Farid Wan Salleh, in an interview with Reuters yesterday, said the government was “still reviewing” The Herald’s licence and was following “due process”.

“Until Dec 31, we are not going to announce anything. There is plenty of time. Let them wait.”

However, Lawrence is optimistic about the publication’s chances of operating again although warning letters from the ministry don’t bode well for the future.

“In their letters, they say that what we write can be a threat to national security. But issues like the economic and food crises are also ethical things which affect families and faith.”

Asked if The Herald would “tone down” if its licence was renewed, he said: “We are not being adamant or stubborn, but when there is a food or economic crisis, how can we tone down?

“We wrote about the fuel prices and asked people to pray that it would go down. And it did. What’s wrong with that?”

Asked whether it was The Herald’s editorial slant that was the problem, Lawrence said he was not sure.

“Our paper is only sold in churches. We don’t sell it to vendors or Muslims. They cannot prevent us from educating our people and expanding their faith.”

He said if The Herald’s publishing permit was not renewed, he would leave the matter to Archbishop of Kuala Lumpur Tan Sri Murphy Pakiam to decide.

The Herald has a readership of about 14,000 nationwide.

marriage course for malaysians

December 17th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I see the non-existence of compulsory marriage course for non-privileged malaysians as a form of discrimination. Why should it be provided for certain segment of the society only? Isn’t a happy family vital for practically everything that our leaders want our country to achieve? From economic progress to national unity, a strong and stable family is critical, yet we can’t even seem to have a fair provision in providing marriage courses.

Now, PPP’s Deputy Minister Murugiah says that a memorandum will be submitted (by whom under what capacity?) to provide compulsory marriage course for non-malays. Can this be also included in the Cabinet Committee for Indian Community?

A MEMORANDUM will be submitted to the Government urging it to make it compulsory for non-Muslims to attend marriage courses before their wedding, said Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Senator T. Murugiah.

He was reported in the Malaysia Nanban as saying that the number of divorces among the Indian community had risen tremendously.

The Government could give approval to a marriage after the bride and groom present their certificate of attendance at the marriage course, he said.

Can only catch people on bicycles?

December 11th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I wrote about robbery in relative’s house last week. And what I read in papers this week? Policemen busy catching people riding bicycles! Aiyo! Are they filming some sort of comedy here?

JERIT (Jaringan Rakyat Tertindas) is running a “People Riding for Change” expedition, which had 65 participants, which is to stop over in Kedah, Penang, Perak and Selangor before proceeding to Parliament House to hand over a people’s claim to the government. They have harassed by police since day one. Don’t the police have anything better to do? If the crime in those states are under control, why not send those cops to Bukit Antarabangsa to help out the landslide victims?

I think the police are becoming fodder for tea time jokes. Hopefully they can clean up their image by chasing after mat rempits instead of harassing bicyclists. Just assign few men to monitor or cycle along (!) cukup la. Deploy others in public areas, flood prone areas, or send them to Bukit Antarabangsa la.

This JERIT people should have applied to state government for official support and request for police outriders. Then it will be correct – police assisting the public.