| Silver lining of Hindraf rally |
| RK Anand | Jan 7, 08 3:45pm |
|
On Nov 25 last year, some 30,000 people reportedly flooded the streets in Kuala Lumpur to participate in a rally. In a knee-jerk response, government leaders called it an act of extremism, arguing that all is well with the Indian community and hence there was no other motive, except for a sinister one, for such a rally. Scores were arrested, while five Hindraf leaders, four of whom lawyers, are being held under the Internal Security Act (ISA). The five were accused of having links with terrorist groups, a charge they have vehemently denied. However, as the days passed, there seemed to be an official recognition of the problems faced by the Indian community. Suddenly, all was not well after all. Even MIC and its leaders acquiesced, carefully pointing out the leaks that needed to be plugged. Positive side "This is the positive side of the Hindraf rally," argued Malaysian Indian Business Association (Miba) president P Sivakumar. "These professionals, who could have led comfortable lives, were forced to shoulder this issue because the groups tasked with helping the Indians failed miserably. They have sacrificed their freedom for this," he added. On the momentum of change stoked by Hindraf, Sivakumar said since the Nov 25 rally, there have been some positive developments. The most notable, he pointed out, is that it has united the Indian community. Apart from this, he said numerous meetings and assurances followed. "For example, the special meeting between Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi and Indian non-governmental organisations on Dec 14," added Sivakumar, who was present at the meeting. He said MIC and its president S Samy Vellu, who have come under intense pressure, are now forced to act for the betterment of the Indian community. "Not to forget Selangor Menteri Besar Dr Mohd Khir Toyo meeting with Hindu groups over the issue of temple demolitions and the prime minister also giving an assurance concerning this. "The premier, in his winding up speech during the special meeting, also acknowledged that help was not trickling down and promised to look into improving the delivery system. "After three generations of Indian Malaysian parents selling off their assets to educate their children, there is now hope of more educational grants and loans coming forth. "There is also hope that all races in Malaysia will one day be treated equally. Why did all of these happen? Because of the Hindraf rally," he noted. 'New champions' "But where would these new champions be if not for the rally?" he asked. In view of this, Sivakumar urged all parties, including the media, to stop using the word extremism to describe the rally. "This is an unkind term which should not be used," he said, calling the rally a "just cause" born out of "bottled-up frustration". "The rally, which was meant to be peaceful, was an eye opener, it got everybody talking. It even captured the world's attention," he added. Critics have lambasted Hindraf and its leaders for making claims, which they said, bordered on extremism and could lead to racial tensions. Chief among these are the claims that the government has marginalised the Indian community and subjected them to ethnic cleansing. 'No evidence' The veteran politician said this when asked if the government has evidence to back the accusation. Below is an excerpt from the Jan 2 interview. NDTV: Do you have any evidence to back your government's charge that Hindraf has links with terrorists? Samy Vellu: Hindraf said they would fight like the Tigers (LTTE), the way the Tigers are fighting in Sri Lanka. It was by (Hindraf chairperson) P Waythamoorthy. After he talked like that, we did an investigation and it was felt that he may have gone there for training. NDTV: Do you have evidence of this? Samy Vellu: No. It is our suspicion. |
Posts Tagged ‘Education’
MIBA Sivakumar talks about the positives of Hindraf rally
January 7th, 2008
tambirajah on education and extremism
January 7th, 2008I heard the excerpts by Datuk Dr Thambirajah on TV3 yesterday night (is it only me, or is TV3 becoming pro-Indian now?)
He said that only the parents can ensure the children's education. He said the community cannot depend on anyone else to improve their standards (means MIC and govt too?).
He also said that education is the only way to uplift the community.
SMC will work with anyone who is interested in the community development, but SMC does not support extremism.
He also said MIC had done much for the community, but much more can be done ("banyak lagi" he said). It can be improved, he said.
Focus on education and not extremism
KUALA LUMPUR: The way forward for Indians is through education and parents play an important role in the progress of their children, Sri Murugan Centre (SMC) director Datuk Dr M. Thambirajah said.
He said it was important for parents to constantly check on their children’s performance in school.
“Don’t blame the child if he or she is not doing well in school.
“As a parent, ask yourself what you have done to make your child a smarter person,” he said, when talking to about 1,200 parents on the Development of Human Capital and a Caring Society at the SM Vivekananda here.
Yesterday saw the start of a series of nationwide road shows planned by SMC, which was founded in 1982.
The centre provides free tuition to school students and is a centre for social and cultural advancement of Malaysian Indians, according to Dr Thambirajah.
“We want to explain the recent concern of the Indian community and how the community can move forward through education.
“In a multi-racial and multi-religious country, extremism by any ethnic or religious group will be counter-productive.
“Extremism will destroy the fine fabric of racial unity, harmony and peace in our country,” Dr Thambirajah added.
437 temporary teachers approved, but no funds?
January 7th, 2008One of the HM I talked to very recently said their school needed 2 teachers, but the district education dept said, no allocation (fund) available for the school to take in temporary teachers. The school have to appeal again, or another option is to cough up money to pay salary of temporary teacher themselves.
Nod for 437 temporary Tamil schoolteachers
THE Education Ministry has approved the appointment of 437 temporary teachers to ease the shortage of Tamil schoolteachers in the country, reported Tamil Nesan.
The president of the Malaya Tamil Schools Teachers National Union, P. Dharmalinggam, said the appointments would help cut the complaints of insufficient teachers to conduct classes and co-curriculum activities in Tamil schools.
He said those interested in the posts could obtain the application forms from the nearest state or district education offices.
He said the union would get the ministry to conduct training courses for these temporary teachers during the holidays.
hishamuddin blooper
January 6th, 2008after saying that it is not compulsory to pay the extra fees, who would expect our kiasu malaysians to donate money to schools? Now parents are scrambling to claim back their monies. better still, parents do not need to show proof of income and can always claim to be from low income.
According him "How is it that first you can afford, the next day you can't?"
– well i guess it is a matter of priority. once something is not compulsory, its position drops. parents can find better use for the extra few hundreds.
Also, hishamuddin has a message for kayveas – "become education minister, and then solve all the problems" as a response to kayveas' suggestion that fees can be standardized. So kayveas, you know what to ask the PM now 🙂
anyway, teachers i know say parents are literally fuming that "free schooling" is not free after all. what is few ringgits and old text books compared to hundreds of ringgits in fees.
read about free schooling at http://poobalan.com/blog/borninmalaysia/2007/11/12/free-schooling-in-malaysia/
Take your money back, says minister
PUTRAJAYA: "Go ahead, take your money back," an irate education minister said yesterday to parents who complained of extra charges imposed by schools and parent-teacher associations.
Datuk Seri Hishammuddin Hussein said as the charges were not compulsory, the ministry could not stop parents from seeking a refund.
He clarified that the charges, based on parents' income level and employment, were guidelines and not binding.
Hishammuddin was not too pleased with parents who had paid up and were now changing their minds following his announcement on Thursday that the charges were not compulsory.
"You could pay in the beginning. Why is it now you don't want to pay?" Hishammuddin asked at the ministry's family day at Putrajaya Wetlands here.
"How is it that first you can afford, the next day you can't?"
Hishammuddin expressed regret that the matter had become an issue.
"I'm not stopping schools from making a refund.
"I don't think any school will close down because of this."
Some parents were caught unawares on the first day of school when they were asked to pay extra charges, amounting to more than RM100 in some cases, for school maintenance, sport day, sport attire, school magazines and test papers.
Many were under the impression that such charges had been scrapped when the government announced in September last year that it was abolishing school fees from this year.
They failed to realise that this only applied to the government school fee of RM4.50 per primary pupil and RM9 per secondary school student.
Hishammuddin said it had been the standard practice for years to let schools and PTAs decide on the amount.
He took to task parents who did not bother to attend PTA meetings where such decisions were made but complained when they were asked to pay.
He said the ministry chose to issue guidelines instead of regulations to cap the amount schools could charge so as not to limit contributions from wealthy parents.
The ministry's guidelines on the charges recommend that for primary pupils, the amount is to be not more than RM38.50 for Package A, RM30.50 for Package B and RM23.50 for Package C.
For secondary schools, the charges are RM55.50, RM44.50 and RM33.50 respectively.
The packages differentiate between parents who work in big business or are civil servants in the professional group (A), professionals or civil servants in the support group (B), and petty traders, plantation, blue-collar and government workers (C).
On the call by Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Datuk M. Kayveas for the charges to be standardised, Hishammuddin commented:
"Kayveas can wait until he's education minister to solve all the problems."
Education director-general Datuk Alimuddin Mohd Dom said parents unable to pay the full amount requested could pay the amount they could afford.
He said parents who did not pay the fees should not fear that their children would be treated differently.
new age voters on cyberspace
January 6th, 2008NewsFocus: 'I'm pro nothing, but Malaysia'
'Apathetic', 'ignorant', and 'lazy' are labels hurled at Malaysian youth who are shirking their citizenry responsibility this coming election. But there are also those who make spreading political awareness their task, albeit in a less conventional way. The cyberspace, after all, doesn't just belong to the converted few
GOOD friends Michelle Gunaselan and Sarah Chan are your typical chic youngsters who work the week through just to live on Fridays.
Come weekends, the girls will hit clubs and party till the break of dawn.
And in-between sipping vodka to the thump of the house music the pair will ask other clubbers if they have registered to vote in the coming election.
Behind the party animal mien are two young people who take politics very seriously.
For far too long, politics had been associated with long, boring talks on issues that the young could not relate to, but that's a misconception, said Michelle, 25.
"People don't understand that politics pervades every aspect of their life.
"Whether you study in a private or public institution, what your first job is, what your salary is, the price of the shirt you bought from Topshop — they are all political decisions."
On nights when they are not shuffling on the dance floor, the duo attend political forums.
They, in fact, lent support to the people of Myanmar at a candlelight vigil before hitting a trendy nightspot in October last year.
Despite being in the know of the country's social development, Michelle and Chan said they did not know enough, especially about elections.
"Being in the media line, my friends and I consider ourselves quite savvy in terms of what's happening socially around the country," said 22-year-old Chan, who writes for a magazine.
"We were born in the 1980s, and the coming election will be our first.
"But we have no idea how it works, how the ballot box looks like, how to vote — we don't know the specifics. We know the issues, but not the process.
"This is quite worrying."
Textbooks, said Michelle, could offer only fundamentals and technicalities, but not other things young voters might like to know, such as who their MPs are, what they are doing for their constituents, and how local elections are carried out.
The women, along with four others, decided to search for answers collectively and also reach out to similar-minded peers.
The idea, mooted spontaneously at a barbeque in November, has now spawned into a Facebook group named VotED, which registered some 500 members within three days.
The account has now more than 800 members, made up mostly of young urbanites who have inked their names onto the electoral roll, or are beginning to take an interest in the political sphere.
In line with the group's aim to educate peers about the voting process, the women had initially planned to hold an event today, but it fell through due to lack of funding and the failure to get a venue.
Contrary to typical political seminars, the event was not to preach ideologies, but to educate young voters through talks, with the incorporation of vibrant lifestyle features such as music and films.
"Older people say that the young are not political, which is true to some extent, but who understands the dynamics better than us?" said Michelle.
Chan added: "We know what young people like and don't like. It has to be education, but in a fun-loving way.
"You know, we are the MTV generation with very short attention spans. It would be like attending a gig or party, but for a different cause."
On whether choosing not to vote should be respected as a right as well, Michelle answered in the affirmative.
"I completely agree with that, but in order to make any decision, one must be educated.
"You can choose not to vote for anyone, but have you completely gone through all the options? Or is it an emotional decision?
"It is a decision all right, but let it be an informed one."
Efforts to find a venue for the event came to naught because establishment owners, linking the group to political associations, were reluctant to host the event.
Chan, in stressing the group's neutrality, said that it ws not affiliated to any party.
"We all have personal opinions, but we're not going to put that into the agenda of the day. The point is education, not conversion."
Michelle added, "The moment you say something, you're instantly labelled as an opposition, that's really unfair.
"As a Malaysian group, we want what's best for Malaysia, and whoever offers us that should get the vote.
"I'm pro nothing, but Malaysia."
The massive turnout caught everybody by surprise, including the organiser – Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf).
"This must be acknowledged. It is because of the five individuals locked up under ISA that so many things are moving now," he told Malaysiakini today.
Sivakumar also pointed out that the rally gave rise to 'new champions' of the Indian community and some of them are branding the rally as a form of extremism.
In a related development, Samy Vellu told Indian television station NDTV that the Hindraf five are held under ISA on 'suspicion' of having terrorist links, namely with the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE).