Posts Tagged ‘Hindraf’

Biggest Anti ISA gathering

September 29th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


According to bmahendran.com, this was an unexpected crowd. Over 2,000 people managed to find time on Saturday night to spend a moment for the ISA detainees. HINDRAF contributed about 500 people while others like WAMI also come. This was a show of unity as people from all walks of life came together. The Chinese community are especially angry at the treatment of reporter Tan and politician Teresa, while others would be Raja Petra’s fans. I think by arresting these people, the goverment had led credence to the misuse of ISA. A bumbling Home Minister also does not help.

Hindraf volunteers and the PDRM did their job well, says Mahendran. I guess the presence of various groups helped in creating a more festive and relaxed atmosphere.

Let’s look at home the three media groups presented their new. Malaysiakini, The Star and NST had their own points to highlight:

Malaysiakini
:

About 2,000 people staged a peaceful march through the busy streets of Kuala Lumpur tonight calling for the abolishment of Internal Security Act and freeing detainees under the Act

Initially, two separate groups – Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf) and coalition of NGOs led by the Writer Alliance For Media Independence (Wami) – had initially planned to hold a candlelight vigil at Dataran Merdeka at about 7.30pm.

When they came across a police cordon at Dataran Merdeka, the Hindraf-led group numbering about 500 decided to march to the temple opposite the Puduraya bus terminal about 1km away.

The crowd marched unhindered towards their destinations and gradually the crowd swelled to about 2,000 people from all walks of life, with many carrying candles.

The other group, which was in a procession holding Chinese lanterns, eventually joined up with the Hindraf group.

The police were caught off-guard by the huge turnout. Many media personnel had also remarked that the large crowd was unanticipated as past vigils had been small in number.

Shouts of “Mansuhkan ISA (Abolish the ISA)”, “Bebaskan Raja Petra (Free Raja Petra)” and “Hindraf Valga (Long live Hindraf)” were chanted by the marchers.

Eventually, the crowd gathered at the temple compound where several individuals addressed the crowd with highly charged speeches.

Hindraf national coordinator R Thanenthiran said that government should heed the protesters’ demands to free ISA detainees.

“The Home Minister Syed Hamid Albar should listen to us. He alone cannot decide what is best for the country. Tonight, we the people, are the judges,” he said.

Later, Teluk Intan MP M Manogaran told the crowd that a large gathering is being planned to commemorate the first anniversary of the ISA arrest of five Hindraf leaders currently held in the Kamunting Detention Camp.

“We will keep holding gatherings until all ISA detainees are released,” he said.

Meanwhile, the crowd was peaceful throughout and a festive atmosphere permeates in the air.

Several supporters of detained blogger Raja Petra Kamaruddin were also at hand to sing ‘Happy Birthday Raja Petra’ as today was his birthday.

By 9pm, protest leaders dispersed the crowd. There were no reports of untoward incidents.

Hindraf national coordinator Thanenthiran later told reporters that the march tonight was proof that Malaysians can gather peacefully in order to express themselves.

“If the police follows the law, we can do the same,” he said.

In a statement immediately after the crowd dispersal, Hindraf leader-in-exile P Waytha Moorthy thanked the police for allowing the march to proceed.

“The government should now accept that Malaysians have sent a loud and clear message that the use of the ISA cannot be tolerated,” he said. Meanwhile, two visually blind participants told Malaysiakini at the scene why they took part in the march.

Ramli Abu Bakar, 51, said he has been supporting the anti-ISA movement ever since it was established because “the country has achieved independence and the act is nothing but a mediaeval law”.

“We have been independent for 51 years and why would we need such a legislation now?” asked Ramli.

Ramli’s friend, Kamal Abu Bakar, 48, echoed his views, saying that the government is “stupid for not abolishing ISA as it is no longer relevant”.

There were also supporters of Raja Petra who were in high spirits in showing their support to their idol on his birthday.

For Sampa Lee, 60, he said releasing Raja Petra and other detainees would be the best birthday gift the government could ever give to them.

“It would be the best present for Raja Petra and all Malaysians as we are all against the draconian law,” said Sampa.


The Star:

Almost 2,000 people from non-governmental organisations and opposition parties took part in a peaceful gathering near Puduraya calling on the Government to abolish the Internal Security Act (ISA).

They started gathering there at 8pm last night and dispersed one hour later.

Dang Wangi police chief Asst Comm Zulkarnain Abdul Rahman said police had received information that a gathering was scheduled to be held at Dataran Merdeka.

“But we had placed our people at various roads leading to Dataran Merdeka and this had caused the group to change the location of the gathering to an area near Puduraya.
“No untoward incident happened during the gathering and no arrests were made, but it added to the traffic congestion there,” he said. – Bernama

NST:

About 2,000 people marched from Dataran Merdeka to the Hindu temple near the Puduraya bus terminal in protest against the Internal Security Act (ISA).

The crowd started marching about 8pm while carrying candles.

Dang Wangi police chief Assistant Commissioner Zulkarnain Abdul Rahman said the march was held without a permit.

“However, no arrests were made and the crowd dispersed peacefully at 9.30pm,” he said.

At least all three agreed on the crowd figures.

A photo gallery is at National Express’ Picasa.

HINDRAF advises Samy to beg for forgiveness

September 24th, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Strong words indeed from Hindraf’s Thanenthiran!

The Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf) has challenged the MIC president to show guts by seeking the forgiveness of Indian Malaysians before pursuing the release of the detained Hindraf 5.“(S) Samy Vellu should kneel and beg for (forgiveness) for his wrongdoings (against) the community if he is sincere and honest about seeking freedom for our leaders,” said Hindraf national coordinator RS Thanenthiran.

“I am sure Indians have a big (enough) heart to forgive him if he asks.”

He also challenged Samy Vellu to pull his party out of Barisan Nasional (BN) if he fails to obtain freedom for the five leaders being held under the Internal Security Act (ISA).

“If he fails to secure their release from Kamunting (detention camp in Perak), then MIC should pull out from BN. Is he prepared to do that?” asked Thanenthiran, at a northern region meeting of the movement in Butterworth, Penang, last night.

Some 100 coordinators and activists from Penang, Perak and Kedah attended the two-hour meeting.

They appeared amused by Samy Vellu’s claim that he has asked the prime minister to consider releasing the Hindraf 5. This was followed by a similar call by the Coalition of Malaysian Indian NGOs.

“Samy Vellu (left) reportedly called on the government to detain our leaders. Now he has suddenly emerged to champion their freedom when he has lost all his government powers,” scoffed Thanenthiran.

The community has largely blamed Samy Vellu for failing to improve their low standing and to deal with social and economic problems.

Their disgruntlement prompted their desertion of BN in the March general election and led to the MIC leader losing the long-held Sungai Siput parliamentary seat – and consequently his cabinet post.

Thanenthiran said the MIC president had been a lame-duck cabinet minister at the time the ministerial order had been signed to detain the Hindraf 5, following a massive street protest held in Kuala Lumpur last November.

“It’s heartening to see BN and NGO Indian leaders coming together to secure the freedom of our leaders. But are they really sincere? Are Indian leaders from MIC, PPP and Gerakan prepared to withdraw from BN if they fail to secure the release of Hindraf 5?”

Uthayakumar’s health, he claimed, was deteriorating due to lack of proper medical care. A diabetic, the lawyer is said to be suffering from a worsening heart condition and high blood pressure.

“He is exercising regularly to keep fit,” said Thanenthiran, urging the Kamunting authorities to provide quality medical care.

Uthayakumar is learnt to have isolated himself from the other Hindraf detainees, and has restricted his list of visitors to family members, his lawyer Karpal Singh and a handful of Hindraf leaders including Thanenthiran.

So, would MIC quit Bn if Hindraf is not released? I doubt it. Samy Vellu already told that they have “full faith” in the Prime Minister. So, whatever the PM says, they will have to accept.

By the way, why is Uthaya limiting his visitors and isolated himself from the other 4 detainees? No reasons given in the report.

PM to consider on releasing Hindraf 5

September 23rd, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


As Samy Vellu mentioned earlier, he planned to meet PM and so he did. Malaysiakini reports that together with Dr S.Subramaniam, they tried to convince PM for 30 minutes to release the Hindraf 5. Prime Minister Badawi apparently told them that he will consider their appeal. Quoting Samy Vellu:

The prime minister promised to discuss the matter with Home Minister (Syed Hamid Albar) and come to a decision.

He said Abdullah told him that he will “study the situation and recommend appropriate action.

“We have full faith and trust in the prime minister, and we believe that he will do something (positive) on this matter,” he added.

Among the arguments put forward by Samy were:

1. Its been nine months since the five were detained (actually its 10 over months).
2. Some of them need medical attention
3. Their families have suffered and the detainees should be allowed to return home to look after their families
4. They pose no danger to the security of the country
5. By releasing them, it would “reduce the tension” within the Indian community.

I guess this is in addition to the original reason, which is to win back the support of the community.

“I am also being heavily pressured by MIC leaders and members to secure their release. Today, I have spoken to the prime minister and I can assure the MIC members that something good will prevail,” he said.

Next step is to raise the matter again in the BN supreme council meeting says Samy.

“We will seek the backing of all the BN leaders to secure their release,” he added.

If successful, this will be feather in the cap for MIC and Samy Vellu, and surely a certain percentage of the community will sway back to MIC. Or it could be that the community is just making use of MIC and Samy Vellu as they have the means to reach the government of the moment. Whatever it is, let’s not jump the gun. the PM have other pressing matters at hand, namely his political survival, to worry about the Indian community, MIC, and least of all, HINDRAF.

Let’s hope that this Deepavali will see the children happily in the arms of their fathers. But RPK have to sit it out alone, I guess.

HINDRAF to reimburse the RM1000 fine

September 22nd, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


PRESS STATEMENT

RE: HINDRAF WOULD UNDERTAKE TO PAY AND REIMBURSE THE RM1000 FINE PAID OR OWED BY ITS SUPPORTERS.

HINDRAF wishes to state that it would reimburse each and every of the 27 supporters who pleaded guilty on 18th September 2008 for the RM1000 they have paid or owe to the court in fine imposed for their participation on the peaceful HINDRAF rally on November 25th last year.

For those who have already paid the fine and those still owing to the court kindly contact our Selangor Coordinator Mr. Selvam on 016 9673066 to help facilitate transfer of funds and fine payment into court.

However we would continue to welcome any form of donations to help ease the burden of the remaining 27 who would undergo 2 months continued hearing beginning 23rd September 2008.

Those willing to make contributions could make their donations to our nominated accounts as below:

Bank – Public Bank Berhad

Account Name – P. Taramaraju & Aridass Velu

(Joint saving account)

Account No – 4-5235622-34

Tel No : 019- 330 5197

012- 332 3490.

Thank you

P.Waytha Moorthy

Chairman

HINDRAF

Forced to plead guilty or not?

September 22nd, 2008
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


The Rm1000 fine each for the 27 accused who pleaded guilty to unlawful assembly during HINDRAF rally has taken a new twist. Waytha claims that the trial of the balance 27 people which will run for two months continuously is an injustice and will cause the accused to lose their jobs:

The movement’s leader in exile P Waytha Moorthy told a press conference in Sentul, Kuala Lumpur via video conferencing, that the 27 individuals would lose their jobs during the two-month hearing.

“This is a great injustice to them. They are bound to lose their jobs, face severe financial crisis and their families would suffer,” said Waytha Moorthy who is in self-imposed exile in England.

The 27 are mostly odd-job workers and labourers who were among 54 individuals jointly charged for participating in an illegal assembly on Nov 11 last year in Kuala Lumpur.

He says that those who pleaded guilty did so out of fear since a prolonged trial period will affect them financially.

Naturally, the lawyer for the accused was incensed after Waytha’s comments. N Sivananthan denied the accusations and condemned Waytha:

In a statement today, their lawyer N Sivananthan denied the allegation and called on all quarters to stop politicising the issue.

He also took a swipe at the London-based Waythamoorthy, saying that he found the latter’s remarks “offensive and ignorant.”

Sivananthan said that the unjust treatment allegation was being equated to the fact that the court had given priority and its time to the trial of the said matter.

“I would like to categorically deny this (the unjust treatment allegation). The offence on which the guilty plea was taken carries a maximum two years’ imprisonment or fine (any amount) or a combination of both.

“Not only did the court only impose a RM1,000 fine, a time period of two months was also allowed for payment of the same with a proviso to extend the period to six months on a case-by-case basis,” he said.

“As a lawyer, I can confidently say that my clients have been treated justly and I find the comments made by Wathyamoorthy (left) from his refuge in London not only offensive but also ignorant.

“The admission of guilt was on the basis that my clients accepted the fact that laws need to be followed and that a failure to disperse when told to do so amounts to a breach of that law,” he added.

Meanwhile, Surendran, the lawyer for Hindraf 5 also chipped in, supporting Waytha:

Hindraf legal advisor N Surendran said that initially, the trial was supposed to last two weeks but was somehow extended to two full months.

Surendran said he has spoken to some of those who had pleaded guilty and claimed that many of them took the plea to avoid being absent from work and be subsequently axed.

“You can see here the enormity of the injustice. We have 27 people who have been forced to plead guilty because of a miscarriage of justice,” he said.

Surendran also urged the attorney-general and the government to drop charges against 27 individuals who he said were exercising their democratic right to assemble peacefully.

This was also rebutted by Sivananthan:

…Sivananthan noted that the comments made by Surendran are rather suspect since none of his clients had indicated that they were being “forced” to plead guilty.

“I don’t think he quite understands the concept of miscarriage of justice. The difference here is that my legal team and I are acting only as lawyers and not politicians whilst the individuals who are making these allegations are trying to dramatise this issue for reasons best known to them.
“I would therefore be grateful if the plea of guilt is not politicised by all parties concerned.”

So, which is which? As a lawyer, would you advise your client to plead guilty to avoid more problems and possible stiffer sentences? As a client, would you expect your lawyer to offer the best advice and as many options as possible to you?

Obviously its strange that this case was given much time and fast-tracked, but it can be taken either way – as a concern for the issue or to pressure the accused.

On the other hand, a sum of RM1000, which can be paid in installments is a good deal for the accused. So, on the smaller, individual scale, the accused can leave all this mess behind and move on in life. On a larger scale, the admission of guilt can be used to further condemn Hindraf, denounce the rally, and to try sway the community back to its original position.