Posts Tagged ‘MIC’

MIC Youth forms watchdog committee after Kugan saga

February 2nd, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Well, at least some good thing came out of Kugan’s death. MIC Youth is setting up a watchdog committee to “monitor and prevent such deaths from happening in the future”.

The Youth wing’s coordinator T Mohan told Malaysiakini that the committee would consist of 10 people, the majority of whom were lawyers and non-party members.

The committee itself will be headed by lawyer SP Muthuvelu, said Mohan.

The formation of the committee was discussed and agreed by the MIC Youth in a council meeting this morning.

“Muthuvelu will be the chairperson on the committee. He will be assisted by seven other lawyers, none of whom are from the party,” said Mohan.

He added that the Youth wing’s secretary C Shivarraj and another person would be the two representative of the party in the committee.

“We wanted independent people in the committee. Of the eight lawyers, four of them are from non-governmental organisations,” he added.

He further said that the main purpose of the committee was to look into custodial deaths and to give feedback to the government on how to stop such deaths from happening again.

The committee has been given three weeks to compile a list and conduct a research of past custodial deaths. We want to get to the root of this problem…to find out why it happens, especially to youths from the Indian community.

“And as soon as the committee has compiled a list of previous cases and our findings on the reasons for these cases, a memorandum will be submitted to the government and the police,” he said.

Aim is to stop custodial deaths

Mohan also said that the committee would take a keen interest in the Kugan case.

“We want the committee to tell us how the family can be compensated and what else could be done to help them.”

However he said the main thrust of the committee was to make sure that no more persons end up dead while in police detention.

“For starters this committee will be watching the police closely in the event there is another custodial death. In the long run, the committee hopes to put up workable proposals to ensure there are no more custodial deaths,” he said.

The Youth wing’s advisor S Vell Paari told Malaysiakini that the objective of the committee was to ensure that the youth wing was playing its role in protecting the Indian community.

“We can’t be doing things on ad hoc basis, trying to pool people every time something like Kugan’s case happens.

“That’s why we wanted this committee to be there on a permanent basis to look on such matters, to see how we can avoid them from happening altogether,” he said.

While Malaysiakini reported as above, NST had slightly different story:

MIC Youth has set up a watchdog committee to monitor cases of brutality and deaths in police lock-ups.

The newly formed committee comprises seven lawyers and three representatives from non-governmental organisations, all members of MIC Youth. [MK said only 2 from MIC Youth and 8 lawyers]

Acting MIC Youth chief T. Mohan said the committee had already begun compiling the details of the death of A. Kugan from the police and his family.

The 22-year-old died in the police lock-up at Taipan, Subang Jaya, on Jan 20.

He had been in detention from Jan 14 for investigation into his possible involvement in the theft of several luxury cars.

“These details will be contained in a memorandum to be submitted to the inspector-general of police and deputy prime minister within a week or two. [MK reported 3 weeks]

“We want the police to take action, including specialised training, to make its personnel more responsible for safeguarding human life so there is no repeat of a case like Kugan’s.”

Speaking after chairing the national MIC Youth council meeting yesterday, Mohan said the police and Home Ministry should re-open and thoroughly investigate every death in police custody.

“The reports of these investigations must be made public and action must be taken against the personnel involved to restore public confidence in the police force.”

Mohan said although people of all races had died in police custody, records show that in the last eight years about 80 Indians had died in lock-ups, possibly due to abuse by the police or by fellow prisoners.

“The police should also appoint more Indian officers to high positions. They would be better equipped to handle young Indian offenders and spread anti-crime awareness.

“Currently the highest rank Indian police officers have reached is Senior Assistant Commissioner I,” he said, adding MIC Youth was planning prayers for Kugan at the Klang Sivan temple on Friday evening.

By the way, does anyone keep track how many committees have been formed by MIC/other parties and their status so far? We don’t want it to be like some entities – many committees, but no action nor results.

Flag it and poof, its gone!

January 31st, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I got the news about a blog insulting Malaysian Indians from Selian who emailed me and others at 7.21pm yesterday. I checked out the blog and immediately flagged it for Blogspot to take action. Later, news about it was in Facebook – posted by Kavilan in his blog.

The blog had 6 posting – all in one day – with sole purpose of creating anger among the Indian community. The author also seemed unhappy with Malaysiakini for publishing many reports related to the Indians.

Some screenshot of the blog, courtesy of Selian (only small images as the contents are likely to elicit emotional response):

pendekar1

pendekar2

pendekar3

pendekar4

pendekar5

pendekar6

pendekar7

I met Kavilan at Mindsblog meeting today noon, and according to him the blog was removed by Blogspot at 1.30am. The proof below:

blog-removed

However, it did not stop Putera MIC folks from lodging a police report:

Putera MIC today lodged a police report over the existence of a blog, claiming that it contained entries that incited hatred against the Indian community.

Its information chief A. Premnath said the “Pendekar Tanahair” blog, run by a blogger using the pseudonym “Pendekar Ramlee”, also contained derogatory postings against the community.

He said that while it was not wrong to write about what a blogger felt about certain issues, it should not be to the extent of stoking anger among the multiracial society.

“We are all Malaysians irrespective of our races. Let us not incite hatred among us,” he told reporters after lodging the report at the Petaling Jaya district police headquarters here.

NST also quoted the police:

Petaling Jaya OCPD ACP Arjunaidi Mohamed, when contacted, confirmed that the police had received the report and that the police would carry out investigations.

Putera MIC chief P Kamalananthan and information chief Premnath commented in the Star:

Putera MIC information chief A. Premnath said he was alerted to the existence of the site by other bloggers and the party’s online monitoring committee on Friday. A complaint was sent to the overseas host asking it to remove the site.

“These types of messages can provoke anger among Indians and if left unchecked can disrupt our country’s unity.

“The person responsible is a coward who is hiding behind the name of a warrior,” said Putera MIC coordinator P. Kamalanathan.

He urged other bloggers to flag down the blog so the host would remove it soon before it posts more damaging messages against the community.

Better late than never. Well done to Putera MIC for their response.

As for Pendekar-whatshisname, the person should not be honored with any kind of comments or opinions. He/she shall not get the satisfaction nor the results he/she expected.

I think the bloggers showed tremendous maturity in not responding to the instigator. Instead, many flagged the blog, alerting Blogger and subsequently removing the blog. It is possible the said blogger will set up another one, but I’m sure we all know what to do – Flag it, and poof its gone!

Kugan saga continues, funeral postponed

January 23rd, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I was informed at noon that the funeral will be held today afternoon at Kinrara, Puchong. However, the family decided to follow MIC’s Vell Paari idea to go for second post-mortem at different hospital. So, the deceased was sent to UMCC and funeral postponed to another day.

Meanwhile, both Murugiah and Devamany provided reasons for their presence at the mortuary after the police said that two deputy ministers will be questioned:

Devamany, who is also MIC treasurer-general, told Bernama the Sepang police had contacted him over the statement.

“I got a call from someone who told me about this case and hoped for my presence at the hospital where the post-mortem was conducted. It was not only to seek the truth for the family of the man but also to calm down the situation and ensure that it was under control,” he said.

Murugiah said he went to the hospital after receiving a few calls from the media about a commotion there, and that he and Devamany managed to calm the situation.

“My duty as per the Public Complaints Bureau is to check on complaints from the public. Is it an offence to address public complaints?” he said.

Murugiah also said that he had briefed Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Tan Sri Bernard Dompok on the suspect’s death and that the minister had agreed to raise the matter with Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi.

Malaysiakini provided a longer explanation by both the deputy ministers:

When contacted, Murugiah (centre in photo) said that Kugan’s family members had already entered the morgue by the time he arrived there.

“I got a call from the victim’s family member at nearly 11pm and I rushed to the hospital… by the time I got there the family members had already rushed into the morgue,” he said.

“The reason I went there was to calm the situation as some of them were frantic after looking at the injuries on his (Kugan) body.”

Murugiah added that he also felt intimidated when members of the victim’s family began shouting at him, blaming the government as well the police force for Kugan’s death.

He said that he went to the hospital in his capacity as the chief of Public Complaints Bureau after receiving the call that night.

“I even called the Inspector General of Police (IGP) Musa Hassan and he promised that he would investigate the matter and assist the family,” Murugiah said.

He also said that he was ready to cooperate with the police on their investigation.

Devamany: I’ll cooperate too

Devamany also said that he went to the morgue to “help the situation” after receiving calls from MIC Youth leaders.

“I went there to see how I can help the situation… these are poor people and they are not empowered enough to tackle this by themselves,” he told Malaysiakini.

Devamany said although the family members were distraught yet they listened patiently to explanation from the hospital’s director on the post-mortem.

“The director assured that they would act fairly and would present the facts accurately,” said Devamany, who is currently in his constituency Cameron Highlands to deal with a landslide problem in a Hindu cemetery there.

Asked on the police probe on him for allegedly barging into the morgue, the MIC treasurer said that he was willing to cooperate with the police “as long as justice is served”.

NST frontpaged their reasons as well:

“I have no problem giving my statement,” said Murugiah, adding that he received a call from one of Kugan’s family members at 11pm on the alleged police brutality.

He said he reached the hospital at 12.30am and was shocked to see the commotion there.

“The doors to the mortuary were open. People were surrounding the body and photographers were taking pictures.
“I was taken aback and wondered why the hospital allowed people into the area,” he said, adding that emotions were running high.

to calm the situation by calling Inspector-General of Police Tan Sri Musa Hassan, who promised that the police would investigate the matter thoroughly.

He said Kugan’s family was satisfied with the police assurance and he left the scene at 3.30am. On Wednesday, Murugiah said he met the hospital director for an explanation on why the crowd was allowed into the morgue.

“The director said they were emotional and his staff were unable to control them.

Meanwhile, Devamany, who is currently in his constituency in Cameron Highlands, said he was willing to give his cooperation when he was back in town.

He, too, claimed he received a call from one of Kugan’s family members. He said the body was not in the mortuary, but in a room outside, where everyone was allowed to view it.

As a representative of the MIC, I had to listen to their grievances,” he said, adding that he was there between 1am and 3.30am.

I say Devamany scored some brownie points here. This is what the public expects – service 24 hours a day. Being politician is not easy, so one should know before sinking into it.

By the way, police has confirmed that investigation will continue since there are allegations of police abuse even though the post-mortem concluded death is due to liquid in lungs.

There are more related reports at www.mpkapar.com (YB Manikavasagam’s website) as well including a theory that the police or some other big name is also involved in the car theft syndicate. All this is still hearsay without concrete evidence.

Focus turns from death into mob attack

January 22nd, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Look at how NST made the family members and members of the public into a mob! Can’t believe this!!! And deputy ministers (Murugiah and Devamany) is being sought for questioning. This is one of few times where DAP, PKR, MIC and MS members were at the same place to show support over another case of death in police custody. Meanwhile the post-mortem result shows death was not due to foul play. But how to explain the injuries on the body? Was it inflicted during the arrest of the deceased?

The post-mortem indicates “fluid in lungs” as cause of death. How can fluid enter the lungs? That is the logical question one would ask. This person never had history of asthma, say the family. One possibility is being exposed to wet condition for prolonged period until moisture enters the lungs (something like pneumonia), I guess. Sleeping shirtless without blanket under air-cond daily or while hair/body is still wet can cause this as well.

So, even if its was not directly death due to injuries, circumstances and the environment of the custody may have led to the death.

The Star:

Selangor police chief Deputy Comm Datuk Khalid Abu Bakar said police would record the statements of two deputy ministers in connection with the morgue incident in which the body of A. Kugan, who died in detention, was tampered with.

He said the post-mortem showed that Kugan, a suspected car thief who was being questioned at the Taipan police station in Subang Jaya, died of liquid in his lungs.

… However, on Tuesday, Kugan’s family and members of the public allegedly barged into the Serdang Hospital mortuary where the body was being kept, ripped off his shirt, moved his body and took some photographs.

NST:

Deputy Minister to be quizzed over mortuary mob attack

SUBANG JAYA, THURS:

A deputy minister is expected to be called up by police for his alleged involvement in the mob attack at the Serdang hospital mortuary on Tuesday night.
Post-mortem revealed no foul play in the death of police detainee A. Kugan at the Subang Taipan police station.

The mob had allegedly pushed out a medical assistant and his two staff before conducting their own checks on the body.

Malaysiakini also reported the same:

The police will record the statements of two deputy ministers over yesterday’s incident where some 50 people barged into the Serdang Hospital mortuary where the body of a 22-year-old youth who died in police custody was being kept.

It is learnt that Deputy Ministers in the Prime Minister’s Department T Murugiah and SK Devamany were present at the morgue.

Meanwhile, MIC Youth’s advisor Vell Paari has outlined the next course of action:

He also said that he had informed Youth chief T Mohan to seek a second medical opinion on the cause of death.

“We should not just rely on the hospital post-mortem,” he told malaysiakini.

He said that the second independent medical report would help indentify the true cause of Kugan’s death.

“We talk and fight for the Palestine and Sri Lankan cause but similar atrocities are committed right under our noses. This has to stop and the cowards who caused the death of Kugan must be charged with murder,” he said.

Vell Paari also said that the party’s youth wing will work to set up a committee to monitor the welfare of all Indians under police custody.

“This will also avoid this sort of abuse and murder in the future,” he added.

I leave you with more photos from the mortuary, this time taken during MIC people’s visit, courtesy of Novinthen.

More on Kugan’s death in police custody

January 21st, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Here’s a link to Malaysiakini’s video, taken by Indrani Kopal. I quote their caution:

WARNING!
Due to the distressing nature of the following material, viewer discretion is strongly advised.

For those without access to Malaysiakini video, can download the clip in MP4 format by clicking here. You can useVideoLan VLC media player to view it.

Below is a slideshow of the photos at the Serdang Hospital.

There’s some photos at YB Manikavasagam’s website as well.

Unverified sources said that Samy Vellu was busy answering calls regarding this death while he was at the SJKT Vallambrosa school. It seems that among the suspects who tortured the detainee was a Indian inspector. Not sure on how valid this information is.

Meanwhile, the family of deceased lodged a police report and denied saying that the deceased was an asthmatic patient.  Some representatives from DAP, PKR, MIC and Makkal Sakthi were present there as well offering their support. MK reported that about 80 people were present at the Seri Kembangan police station, venting their anger ath the police.

They held up banners with pictures of the deceased, showing the injuries he sustained while in police custody.

The banners read: “police are licensed killers”, “police are killing Indians” and “police are thirsty for Indian blood” in Malay and English. They also briefly chanted slogans.

Talking to reporters later, Kugan’s family members said that the deceased did not suffer from asthma and could not have died from breathing difficulties, as claimed by the police.