Posts Tagged ‘Elections’

MIC turmoil continues as Kamalanathan is selected

April 15th, 2010
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Rumours of Mugilan and Kamalanathan’s name being proposed were going around since two weeks ago. However, MIC only put for Palanivel’s name. Till yesterday night there was big noises coming from MIC camp – CWC, branches in Hulu Selangor, and divisions in Selangor. But today afternoon saw Palanivel’s name replaced with P.Kamalanathan, the Information Chief of MIC as BN candidate for Hulu Selangor parliamentary seat by-election.

I saw part of his speech on TV just now. Quite spirited and focused on 1Malaysia thing.

“I will work hard.” he said, while thanking the BN leadership including deputy MIC president G. Palanevil for giving him the opportunity to stand as the candidate.

He vowed to take back the federal seat, formerly a BN stronghold, and deliver it to Datuk Seri Najib Razak as gift for his first year in office.

He dismissed speculation there was unhappiness by factions in MIC, who were unhappy with his nomination, and expressed confidence that he has the support of BN.

“I represent BN, I represent the brand of 1 Malaysia.”

He described himself as a soldier called into battle by the prime minister and said he was up for the challenge.

He added that he never expected to be nominated and was “shocked”, and “had shed tears” when informed by the party’s president at noon today.

He declined to comment on his political opponent from PKR but said he was ready to take to the ground and tell the people about the development opportunities BN could bring.

His BM and English is good, being from the younger generation. I’ve actually met him few times in some bloggers event and also at the Ponggal festival. I don’t know him personally so can’t say much, but he seems to be a nice focused guy. Anyway, nice or not nice doesn’t matter when in a political party as personal believes and ideals have to be sacrificed for party sake (unless you are Chew Mei Fun). He still maintains his blog, and also active in Facebook and Twitter. A bit on Kamalananthan:

Kamalanathan, 44, is a public relations expert [his is currently attached to Beras Jati), and is married to S. Shobana, a senior public relations manager at a private hospital.

He started his career as a clerk and later became a public relations officer with the Malaysian Palm Oil Promotion Council for six years.

He has a certificate in PR from the London Chambers of Commerce and Industry and a diploma in language translation and Bachelor in Mass Communications degree from Edith Cowan University in Australia.

Kamalanathan was a Selayang municipal councillor from 2004 to 2006 and the national co-ordinator for Putera MIC and party information chief since last year.

Within a span of 7 years, he has made it to be a candidate. Well done.

Anyway, if MIC members sabotage Kamalanathan, then he stands a very slim chance of winning. But not a problem as he will be renominated for GE13 as part of the newcomers.

Some interesting stories going around, including about the whole fiasco being planned in order to actually remove Palanivel so that new bloods can slowly move in and rejuvenate MIC (or so it is said). Time will only tell.

As for Samy and Palanivel, read this info from Malaysian Insider:

Samy Vellu had been saying “either Palanivel or nothing” right up to last night when he called an emergency party central working committee meeting and convinced its 35 members to unanimously back Palanivel as the candidate.

He had said MIC was ready to give the seat to Umno if Palanivel was dropped.

This morning he met Deputy Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin who told him that Palanivel was a no go.

Umno feels strongly that the Hulu Selangor grassroots, irrespective of race, was set against Palanivel, a hard working and clean man, but colourless and cold to ordinary people.

Public perception ruined him and his rejection in the constituency he headed for 20 years was borne out by numerous straw polls.

Samy Vellu informed Palanivel of the bad news, and toyed with either party secretary-general S. Murugesan or Kamalanathan as a replacement.

He eventually picked Kamalanathan (picture), who has the support of vice-president Datuk Dr S. Subramaniam and his son Vel Paari and the backing of the Dewar clan which controls the MIC.

Samy Vellu’s decision to back off after putting up a strong front has roiled the MIC CWC, with members already angry with the party president for failing to keep his word.

A campaign has already been started to ask Samy Vellu to take responsibility and resign.

But Samy Vellu told the CWC last night he would not resign as president.

Samy Vellu had strongly objected to MIC Youth deputy chief V. Mugilan, the preferred Umno candidate.

He argued that Mugilan betrayed the MIC by backstabbing Palanivel and the party.

Samy Vellu also offered the seat to Umno if Palanivel was not chosen, but Muhyiddin did not take the bait as it would have gone down badly among Indian voters.

There is talk of an offer to the slighted Palanivel to be appointed a senator and later made a deputy minister as a reward for his backing of Kamalanathan. But his aides say he will reject the offer.

His political career is in great doubt after this setback, although he remains deputy party president.

Muhyiddin and Samy are still confident (but i have learnt not to believe such talks):

But the tussle between the MIC and Umno has bruised the ruling coalition, with many members from BN’s main Indian party still seething with unhappiness over the development.

“He is a workaholic, straightforward, one who means what he says.

“He’s the only candidate. There is no candidate but him,” Muhyiddin said of Kamalanathan as a smiling Samy Vellu flanked him.

In his speech to over 1,500 BN members, Muhyiddin attempted to heal the rift caused by the tussle and showered praises on Samy Vellu and Palanivel.

“Even in my sleep, I see Samy Vellu’s face. He is a great man,” he quipped.

He explained that Palanivel was not chosen to contest because voters wanted a new face, saying that BN recognised his contribution to Hulu Selangor over the years.

“We have to give credit when it is due.”

Palanivel did not attend the nomination and Muhyiddin, at a press conference later, said it could be because the MIC deputy president had other things to do or was disappointed.

“That’s a normal human emotion but it won’t stay that way for long,” he said, adding that he hoped Palanivel will help the BN campaign and win the by-election.

Samy Vellu was also in a reconciliatory mood when he spoke to reporters.

“I promised the deputy prime minister that he will say everything. Today we are listeners and will stay behind and listen to his commands and directives to ensure absolute victory.”

He said Kamalanathan was a candidate who the PM had approved and who the party had accepted, when asked by reporters if the MIC had compromised on its earlier stand.

Samy Vellu added there would be no problems with local MIC branches which earlier had threaten to “close down” if Palanivel was not nominated to stand for the by-election.

“It will be OK, I have rung them up,” he said, adding that the branches would campaign so long as the candidate was from the MIC.

Asked if he feared that there would be sabotage due to unhappiness on the ground over Kamalanathan’s nomination, he replied: “They normally don’t.”

“We have not learnt the art yet” he said.

All in all, this have been a severe insult for MIC in the eyes of public. Maybe its some scheme by MIC folks that worked in order to bring in a new person and at same time offer something to Palanivel (Deputy Minister post??? wow…), but in reality, the integrity and morality of MIC have been tarnished since they were standing firmly behind Palanivel until willing to boycott or even dissolve branches.

Pakatan will still be under dogs even with a novice opponent from BN because Kamalanathan has the might of the federal machinery behind him. And Pakatan also facing more crisis as another ADUN just quit the party (Bakar Arang ADUN Tan Wei Shu).

BN to win, unless something goes wrong.

Dilemma on coalition or seat in Hulu Selangor

April 15th, 2010
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Looks like comments from Khairy hoping for “youthful”  young candidate is not appreciated by MIC in Hulu Selangor.  As a public, I feel BN have a chance of winning the seat if BN leaders minus the PM put a lid on their talks. Nearly every other word mentioned end up creating more problem for everyone else.

Today MIC had their CWC meeting at night. Not sure what is the outcome. Earlier, a number of Hulu Selangor MIC branches said will quit or close shop. Even other division leaders in Selangor are unhappy with interference by UMNO.

So, what is the option here? Stick with Palanivel which was the only option given by MIC to BN? That would mean respecting coalition partner’s choice. Or put another candidate (Mugilan says he would quit if nominated) which will be an insult to MIC? What BN values more? Coalition partner’s decision, sentiment on the ground (which may be conflicting as no one has done a proper and thorough survey), or chance of winning? If BN can win the seat by putting someone else, would they do it?

I also wonder if this just some drama being played, so that later can “patch up” and show how strong the coalition is. I for one, don’t trust politicians, especially those who tend to speak half-truths and no-truths before GE12. Before election, everything have to be taken with a pinch of salt.

I think it will be Palanivel after all.

The beauty of elections

April 9th, 2010
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


See what I mean? Doesn’t matter which acronym it is, when election time, all things can happen. Mountains can be moved, sea can be split open, so to speak. Regardless of what PR says, this sounds like goodies due to the timing.  Anyway, its just “can apply” status. Not sure how it will be after by-election. Land anyone?

RESIDENTS in Selangor who had been issued with Temporary Occupational Licence (TOL) for more than 15 years for areas gazetted as housing and plantation can apply for the 99-year lease.Mentri Besar Tan Sri Khalid Ibrahim said about 100,000 families stood to benefit from the scheme.

“Those who had lived on the land with TOL status for more than 15 years will be eligible to apply for the 99-year lease,” Khalid told reporters after chairing a state executive council meeting at the Hulu Selangor district on Wednesday.

He added that the move would enable genuine TOL holders to own the land for a longer period.

“However, we would give an option of a 60-year lease, to accommodate those who are unable to pay the land premium for 99 years,” said Khalid.

He added that land issues pertaining to Hindu temples, schools and roads would soon be resolved.

For example, the SJK(C) Rasa has been given the more land for a field to hold school activities.

“We hope certain individuals will not dig up this issue as the matter has been resolved,” he said.

Meanwhile, state exco for environment and tourism Elizabeth Wong said the decade-long land issue involving the 40 orang asli families in Kampung Gerachi near the Sungai Selangor Dam had been given compensation as per the agreement made in 2000.

All of them would be given land as compensation, she said.

HRP turnaround with IFs

April 6th, 2010
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


I’m getting more worried about HRP. First, they said won’t support any candidate. And today, Uthaya is saying will support Zaid with some “ifs”.  I don’t this is the right way to proceed as it will affect the integrity. I would rather if HRP goes to ground and educate the voters to make right decision. DON”T DECIDE FOR VOTERS. Go to ground, explain your cause, explain what voters should expect, explain the rights and wrongs of both coalition. Tell them about money politics, about bribing voters, about giving handouts. Tell them to think about the future of their district. Ask them to evaluate. Ask them to ask the candidates what they can do or have done.

Even though I’m in full support of getting land for Tamil schools, let the voters ask, instead of another party making conditions. Let the Indian voters say to candidates: allocate land for Tamil school and you get my vote. Let’s see which candidate dare to do it.

But do bear in mind, Tamil school issue only affects Indian community. The other communities are not bothered about it.  So, I think it won’t really affect the PR coalition if HRP doesn’t support PR because current ratings indicate Indian community is giving thumbs up to PM Najib (according to Merdeka Center, 71%).

Human Rights Party (HRP) pro-tem secretary-general P Uthayakumar is willing to back fellow Kelantanese and Pakatan Rakyat coordinator Zaid Ibrahim in the forthcoming Hulu Selangor by-election.

Earlier the party said it would not get involved. However, this dramatic ‘about-turn’ comes, in his words, with two ifs – one small and another big.

The small if: “Zaid should prevail on the other Ibrahim, Anwar, to approve land for all the 98 Tamil schools in Selangor,” said Uthaya. “If he doesn’t stand in Hulu Selangor as we expect, we will still support any other candidate who replaces him.”

Tamil schools sitting on their own land, according to Uthaya (right), would be eligible for federal government aid and grants. “We need to educate all our children irrespective of who they are including the stateless, foreigners, illegals and refugees. Children are the future of the nation and the world.”

Uthaya disclosed that his party, the unofficial political wing of Hindraf, has a long list of more than 100 Indian issues to take up with the authorities. But for the moment he would be happy to settle for the resolution of one issue – land for Tamil schools in Selangor.

“We don’t want grand announcements and hollow pledges,” warned Uthaya. “We want the state government to pledge in writing. The media will be our witness.”

Once bitten twice shy, continued Uthaya, “considering what a disappointment Lim Guan Eng – the Penang chief minister – has been.”

In the absence of a written pledge, the fear among Indian voters is that they would be forgotten again after one brief moment of glory as kingmakers.

The moment that the Selangor government makes its pledge in writing on land for Tamil schools in the state, HRP will be ready to reconsider its earlier position of studied neutrality in Hulu Selangor.

“Our members and activists from Hindraf will be ready to spring into action to bring in the votes for Zaid or whoever else stands in place of him,” swore Uthaya. “MIC won’t be a problem because they have actually written off the Indian votes.”

The HRP chief estimates that Pakatan can win in Hulu Selangor – a BN stronghold – if it bags a little over 4,000 of the 12,000-odd Indian votes.

This coupled with the majority of Chinese votes and a significant minority of Malay votes is sufficient to deny BN the parliamentary seat, according to Uthaya.

He reckons that BN doesn’t need the Indian votes to win but fielding an Indian candidate would be a bonus for them.

Earlier, before he came up with the land for Tamil schools proposal, Uthaya had asked Zaid whether he could cite even one instance where he spoke up seriously on Indian issues.

“We will help in Hulu Selangor if Zaid (left) can do that,” said Uthaya. “He may have done so (speaking up) on some minor issues but even here we are not sure.”

The big ‘if’ to win HRP’s and Hindraf’s support in Hulu Selangor is that the Selangor state government take the lead to stop ‘mandore politics’.

Uthaya didn’t ask for any written pledges here and this is more for future ties between HRP/Hindraf and Pakatan.

Uthaya explained ‘mandore politics’ as a situation where Indian legislators in the opposition, as in the BN, were reduced to the level of mandores in dealing with the community.

The work of the mandore politician is to announce empty pledges and have these suitably recorded in the Tamil media.

“We can see why mandore politics is happening in the opposition alliance,” said Uthaya. “Just like Samy Vellu and his MIC, the opposition alliance thinks that Indians are more foolish than the Malays and Chinese when it comes to politics.”

Uthaya pointed out that the Chinese and Malay communities, unlike Indians, are not plagued by the problem of mandore politics “because they would not tolerate this supreme insult for even a moment”.

The HRP chief sees a bleak future for the opposition alliance unless it can work together with his party and Hindraf to create a wave that would translate into votes. Of particular concern is the 67 parliamentary seats in Peninsular Malaysia where the Indians are the deciding factor.

Zaid was not immediately available for comment. Uthaya’s proposal, communicated to him via text message, drew no response.

Earlier, before Uthaya came up with the carrots for Zaid, the latter confessed in a text message that he had no idea who would be the PKR candidate for Hulu Selangor. He did not indicate whether he would be interested.

But it learnt that he’s keen to stand in Hulu Selangor provided he stands a 50-50 chance. Apparently he doesn’t mind even losing in the process as long as he does well in the by-election in terms of the votes garnered.

However Hindraf chair Waythamoorthy (right), speaking from Singapore, fears for Zaid in Hulu Selangor if Anwar continues labeling Hindraf as racist.

“Anwar called Hindraf racist twice within a week recently,” fumed Waythamoorthy. “He told a Tamil daily in Kuala Lumpur that Hindraf was racist and repeated the same thing in London a week later.”

Ironically, said Waythamoorthy, Anwar’s people at the same time keep appealing to him to highlight the Sodomy II trial in the international theatre.

The Early Day Motion on Anwar Ibrahim, introduced not so long ago in the British Parliament, is one such effort that Hindraf has made in recent weeks, stressed Waythamoorthy.

“At least the man should show a little gratitude,” he added.

Good fortune for Hulu Selangor folks

April 5th, 2010
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Whoever stands for whichever party, the Hulu Selangor folks stand to benefit a lot. From soaring rental rates (RM20,000???) to promises of new schools (I thought no campaigning yet?), looks like the idea that representatives serve best when they are “removed” is correct again.

The feeling is that the seat is for 1Malaysia as the majority last time around is a mere 198 votes. Even though some internal jostling for the candidacy is happening, I think MIC would get the seat as MCA and UMNO are well represented via state seats. Only way BN would lose if there’s an internal sabotage (can’t rule this out).

Throw in a few more goodies or feel good news, and can expect BN to win with an healthy majority. Prefect gift for first anniversary.

As for Pakatan, there’s nothing much to talk about other than Israeli links, a litany of court cases, Perak takeovers and such which may make for coffee shop talks and ceramah time, but won’t really affect the folks there. They have to rely on their track record of governing Selangor, and Hulu Selangor especially (a bit of a problem if their representative was not around often).

They are also doing their own campaigning and “distribution”:

DAP Kampung Tunku state assemblyperson Lau Weng San(left) confirmed to Malaysiakini that the state government will play an important role before nomination day. 

The political parties will then start campaigning, while government servants will play no further role, he said.

PKR election director Fuziah Salleh had earlier made a commitment that the party would not abuse state-owned resources in the campaign. 

However Malaysiakini has learnt that Pakatan is aggressively engaging voters through activities and meet-the-people sessions organised by state agencies.

Allocations and other forms of ‘sweeteners’ – including land titles and financial aid – have been distributed by Menteri Besar Khalid Ibrahim and state exco members via state government departments. However, it was claimed that voters had applied for such assistance earlier.

Pakatan’s argument is that state government programmes cannot be described as campaigning, so long as campaign material is not distributed and there is no fishing for votes.

I hope the winning candidate is one of poor health or with some criminal background so that when he/she is “removed”, the folks can enjoy another round of goodies. Maybe MACC will catch one or two representatives. Maybe someone will resign due to whatever reason. Let’s pray for another by-election soon, folks, preferably in our backyards 🙂

Note: Voter breakdown is as follows:

Hulu Selangor has 64,500 voters , with Malays making up 52.7%, Chinese 26.3%, Indians about 19% and other races 1.7%.