Posts Tagged ‘Protest’

Solution for Kg Buah Pala?

August 4th, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Lim Guan Eng says developer agrees to share the land with the residents (7.30pm today). He is to discuss with the residents, and if they agree, problem settled.  However, Nusmetro still talking about the residents moving out – perhaps to temporary housing? And what would the coperative say?

Demolition postponed till August 18 since the residents filed an appeal and appeal will be heard on that day only. Developer can’t demolish until appeal is heard and decided upon. So, for the moment, the residents can breathe easy.

 The way I look at it, options are quite clear – (i) buy back/reclaim land, (ii) share land, or (iii) compensate and move out/evict. Each of the solution may bring another set of problems – political, financial, legal, and social.

 

Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng said Tuesday evening that the developer of the Kampung Buah Pala land has agreed to share the 2.6ha plot with the villagers.

He said he would discuss the proposal with the villagers at a meeting with them at Komtar which started at 8.05pm on Tuesday.

He spoke to reporters in a short press conference before the meeting began

Earlier, Bernama reported that the planned demolition of houses in Kampung Buah Pala Tuesday has been postponed, once again, to Friday, pending a solution to be worked out for the 23 families facing eviction from the area which is to be developed.

The villagers are scheduled to have a meeting with the state government Tuesday night.

State government representatives had met last night with the developer of the land, Nusmetro Ventures (P) Sdn Bhd.

Nusmetro Ventures executive director Thomas Chan said the company had come to an agreement with the state government to set Friday as the new deadline for the villagers to move out of their houses.

Chan, who was accompanied by the company’s lawyer, told reporters he would wait for the outcome of tonight’s meeting between the villagers and the state government.

Penang Deputy Chief Minister II P. Ramasamy met the villagers Tuesday and said the draft of a solution was being prepared by the state government.

“We have also agreed to meet the residents at Komtar (where the state government office is located) at 7.30pm today to discuss the draft,” he told reporters after the meeting.

Kampung Buah Pala residents protest photos

July 2nd, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Thanks to Khai Beng for the photos:

Kedah DAP to pull out from state government

July 2nd, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


This may be signs of things to come. In Penang, its PKR. In Selangor, its PAS. In Perak, its all three of them.

In Kedah, the DAP has one representative in the state assembly. The state DAP has decided to pull out, subject to HQ feedback. Reason given – “undelivered promises” by the Kedah government, and not giving equal treatment to all Kedahans.

State DAP chairman Thomas Su Keong Siong, said the decision to demolish the 30-year-old abattoir was the last straw.

“We are pulling out of the state government as we find we can no longer work with other PR assemblymen,” he told reporters here two hours after the abattoir, located near a densely-populated rsidential area, was demolished by Alor Star city council workers.

The demolition, which started about 3pm, proceeded smoothly for about two hours despite the presence of a small group of DAP members, including Su, who held placards protesting the move.

Su, who is also state assemblyman for Pasir Pinji in Perak, said the state government had failed to handle the issue properly.

He said he had met state Housing and Local Government Committee chairman Datuk Phahrolrazi Zawawi on Tuesday to ask if the state executive council had agreed to the state DAP’s request to delay the demolition.

“He told me he would raise the matter with Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Azizan Abdul Razak. Today, I received an SMS from the state executive councillor (Phahrolrazi) that the matter had not been discussed at the weekly state executive council meeting today,” he said.

Su, who was careful not to mention Azizan’s name throughout the press conference, said he had also learnt that the city council was planning to demolish a multi-purpose hall at a Hindu temple in Jalan Pegawai and a Chinese temple in Jalan Tanjung Bendahara here.

He said other issues that substantiated the DAP’s claims about the state Pas included the state government’s policy of a 50 per cent housing quota for Bumiputeras and the delay in approving a building plan submitted by the Kedah Buddhist Association.

The problem came to a boil after an illegal pig abattoir was demolished by Alor Setar City Council two days ago. The demolition of the slaughterhouse was another reason which had prompted the state DAP to quit the pact.

“Although the slaughterhouse was operating on land belonging to the Alor Setar City Council, the state government has the power to postpone the demolition. This will give more time for the Kedah Pig Traders and Slaughterer Association which operates the slaughterhouse to find a new site,” he said.

Mayor Datuk Khazali Din was quoted as saying recently that the abattoir had been erected illegally on the site for the past 30 years.

The council had ordered the association to vacate the place several times since 1995 with the latest in May this year.

Kedah MB says its DAP’s fault because didn’t do anything to solve the problem in the last one month (Kedah DAP had failed to deliver on an alternative site for the facility after asking for a month’s grace) , while Kedah PKR admits that its shoulders part of the blame for not acting fast to solve the problem. However, PKR supports the demolishment.

Kg Bukit Pala showdown

June 30th, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


As it stands, the residents are pissed off with their ADUN lawyer RSN Rayer. He tried to give some excuse saying he is standing with them or something. They are also accusing the state government of not doing anything, not caring about them, just like the previous government. Lim Guan Eng will be waking up to a protest tomorrow from his own rakyat, who helped his representative to get a place in the state government. He was upset with HINDRAF’s claims, and asked them to protest at federal government level so that the federal government can do something under National Land Code.

HINDRAF is planning a series of protests at DAP offices throughout the country. That speaks something for their impartiality. At least they step on everyone’s toes once in a while. But it remains to be seen if they can get an estimated 10,000 people at KOMTAR this week. Probably less than half of that is my estimate.

Question also arise if the Indians in DAP will stand with HINDRAF or with Penang state government. My guess is party comes first for them. How about those in PKR ? – no news from Manikavasagam, Sivarasa or Gopalakrishnan so far.  MIC  should be having  good time seeing the misery of DAP/PKR, but I’m not sure what they themselves are doing to solve the problem as well. It was their partners who caused all this problem in the first place. Which makes them, what, partners-in-crime? The role of  the previous state government who caused all this headache for current state government should not be forgotten.

Can the state government buy back the land from the people it sold to? Probably not if it the buyers got it over some dubious and nominal fees, thus standing to make a large amount of money. Lim Guan Eng says the figure will be astronomical. if want to buy back And secondly, there may be no laws to compel for such buy-back options or to stop the development of the land. I guess the only way is to discuss with the developer or relocate the whole village to another location.

Anyway, Deputy CM 1 Mansor is doing some firefighting work – trying to talk to the developers, Koperasi Pegawai Kerajaan Pulau Pinang Bhd and Nusmetro Venture.

He said that he would ask the developers to hold on to the vacant possession directive served on the villagers while the state investigates allegations of misuse of power and corruption in the transfer of the land.

“I am confident that the developers will cooperate with the state,” he told a press conference here on Monday.

The residents filed an application today to set aside an ex-parte order dated June 16 obtained by the developers, to issue a writ of possession, which is to be enforced at 11am on July 2. In their application, the residents also applied for the bailiff’s notice, execution and enforcement of the writ to be set aside. In his affidavit, labourer K. Shanmugham said to date he and the other village residents had yet to be served with the Court of Appeal’s order dated May 11. He said the writ of possession was defective as the Koperasi and Nusmetro Venture have failed to obtain any permission from the authorities and the Penang Municipal Council to demolish the houses in the village. The application will be heard on a date yet to be fixed.

A bit of background on the village (from Malaysiakini):

Originally the village was legally gazetted as the Helen Brown housing trust under the Housing Trust Act 1950.
However, in 2005, the land office alienated the land to the state government without dissolving the trust which is a requirement under law.

Penang Island Municipal Council (MPPP) had allegedly given planning approval in 2007 to Umno-linked Nusmetro before the land was legally transferred to the cooperative. This is a breach of the council’s building by-laws.

The land was only transferred on March 27 last year – nine days after Pakatan Rakyat captured Penang in the general election.The land transfer was done by certain land officers without the knowledge of the current government.

How would this turnout? I expect the talks between Mansor and opposition-controlled company to fail. There will be some bloodshed and arrests, and Kampung Buah Pala will cease to exist. After 6 months, we will forget all this and move on. In 2013, the issue will be raised again, but both parties will not be getting any mileage because one caused the problem, and the other failed to keep to its promise to solve the problem.

7 arrested over demolition of houses in jinjang selatan tambahan

June 15th, 2009
|  Subscribe in a reader | Subscribe to poobalan.com by Email


Latest news:

Seven people, including one activist, have been arrested today for trying to stop the demolition of houses in Kampung Jinjang Selatan Tambahan in Kuala Lumpur.

Six of those arrested were residents whose houses were being demolished by the Kuala Lumpur City Hall (DBKL). The sole activist – Julie Wong – was from urban poor people’s organisation Permas.

They have been taken to the Sentul district police headquarters for questioning.

Human rights movement Suaram said that it received reports that several people were injured caused by DBKL officers during the incident.

“We call on the police to release the seven individuals immediately. We remind the police that their duty is to ensure safety of all Malaysians and to curb violence from being used against residents and activists instead of arresting them,” said Suaram in a statement.

The movement also condemned DBKL for taking a heavy-handed approach in the demolition.

“We also call on DBKL to respect the rights of the residents of Kampung Jinjang Selatan Tambahan, to halt demolition works immediately and to take the concerns of the residents of Kampung Jinjang Selatan Tambahan into consideration,” it added.

The demolition exercise by DBKL today involved 17 houses to make way for a new road connecting Jalan Kepong to Jalan Segambut.

The new road project is now stalled as a result of these houses which lie on the way.

Deadline expired yesterday

Although DBKL has issued these residences a notice to relocate, the residents claimed that the notice was served to residents of Kampung Benteng.

Kampung Benteng no longer exists as they have been evicted by DBKL for the same roadwork.

Its dreadful to read stories like this. Our community seem to end up as losers whenever development takes place. why? uneducated? illiteracy? wrong advice? ignorance? crooked politicians and administrators? profit-oriented developers/land owners? lop-sided law?  We have many such cases – bukit raja, putrajaya, jinjang, kampung pandan, bukit pala, sungai buloh, bukit jalil, etc. in most (if not all cases), the settlement were established before independence, so what are the remedy for these situations? Who were the people involved in the “talks/negotiations”?

Reading about the mental anguish of one such family is sad indeed:

AFTER months of anguish and sleepless nights, one of the families in the 17 homes in Jinjang Selatan Tambahan (JST) that are to be demolished, called it quits.

M. Ramasamy, who had been living in the area for 45 years, decided to take up the offer of a unit in the Batu flats offered by the Kuala Lumpur City Hall (DBKL) yesterday as he had no other choice.

Too much to bear: Ramasamy being consoled by his family members and neighbours after he broke down.

While the DBKL officials were helping him shift out, the other affected residents were holding a press conference down the road to seek justice for their case.

When the other residents caught wind of Ramasamy’s move, they all went to stop Ramasamy and his family from shifting out.

The residents were upset to see Ramasamy’s family in tears and demanded that the officers put back the furniture they had loaded onto the lorry.

As they persuaded Ramasamy, the tension and anguish got the better of him and he broke down in tears.

“I never wanted to shift; from the first day, we have wanted to remain here. We have lived here for more than 40 years,” he said.

He added that one of the main reasons for his decision to shift out was the mental torture of not knowing when the DBKL would demolish his home.

“At night, unknown people would roam our streets on motorbikes and cars. We felt really unsafe, and all this prompted us to move out,” Ramasamy added.

Ramasamy had not gone to work for a week, which added to his stress.

“I am worried that during my absence from work, they might fire me, but at the same time, I have this problem at home,” he added.

After 15 minutes of shouting, negotiation and tears, the DBKL officers finally put the family’s belongings back into their house.

The JST residents, who held Temporary Occupancy Licences until 1997, had been given a final extension until yesterday to shift out.

Thus far, the DBKL has been branding the TOL residents as squatters of Kampung Benteng and have addressed them as such in letters sent to them.

The residents held the press conference yesterday in a final bid to lobby for a halt to the demolition exercise.

The houses are being demolished to make way for a new road connecting Jalan Kepong to Jalan Segambut (near the KTM Segambut).

JST Residents Association secretary Sin Ah Seng said the road was a not a necessity as it would only create a bottleneck.

“The road will end at Metro Prima Kepong; this route will only flood the place with more cars,” he added.

The road was initially supposed to be built about 20 metres from the affected houses but the route was changed due to the presence of high tension electricity cables.

On June 8, DBKL officers had spray-painted the homes with the words “T/R 10/06/09”, meaning that the houses were to be demolished on June 10.

The residents immediately met DBKL deputy director-general of services Datuk Amin Nordin to seek justice.

“He instead forced us to accept the letter and the keys to the flats if we wanted to stay until June 14,” said another resident, S. Susil Raj.

Raj said they reluctantly opted to accept the keys to buy more time to stop the demolition.

Another issue that is bothering the residents is the DBKL’s offer to them to shift out.

According to resident M. Selvamani, they were offered a flat and RM1,000, but the money would not even be enough for the extra fittings needed in the new flats.

“Amin said the flats are ready for occupation but our survey of the place revealed that most units do not have electricity and water supply,” Selvamani added.

The units also lack light bulbs and fans as well as doors and grills, which would cost RM1,200 to fix.

Moreover, the DBKL would deduct RM402 as deposit and the balance would be given to the residents later, but it was not stipulated when.

For some houses, like Ramasamy’s, which house three or more families, the residents would have to bear extra costs as they would all need to shift into separate units.

Their current furniture will not fit into the flats, which are smaller than their current homes which are more than 1,200 sq ft.

“We will have to buy new mattresses, kitchen cabinets, sofas and a host of other new things,” Ramasamy said.

He added that in the current economic situation, it was a burden to come up with such a large amount of cash.

Selvamani said these problems would only prompt the residents to turn to illegal moneylenders like Ah Long.

Ramasamy said while the land belonged to the government, the homes were theirs and they needed to be compensated accordingly.

“We built our homes slowly over the last 30 to 40 years; the authorities should give us the right compensation,” he added.

The residents will be facing the DBKL officers again today as the extension expired yesterday.

Look at their neighbours at Jinjang Utara, 16 years and still counting – no permanent homes yet, but the people living there still having hope. Our country have lots of people who don’t fulfill promises and yet still stay in power or position.

In another case which was highlighted recently, its the SIME UEP company which did not build houses for ex-plantation workers in Bukit Raja housing project in Klang.